Archive for regional disparities

Fewer Farms, Flat Output: U.S. Dairy’s Efficiency Paradox

U.S. milk production increased 0.1% in January 2025—even as 5% of dairies closed their barns. How did herd growth and tech investments fail to boost yields? From California’s water wars to Texas’ tax-fueled expansion, dive into the data and political battles reshaping America’s dairy future.

Summary

The U.S. dairy sector confronted stark contrasts in 2024: milk production increased 0.1% year-over-year in January 2025, yet 5% of farms (1,420 operations) shuttered due to crushing input costs, labor shortages, and consolidation pressures. Regional disparities intensified as Texas and South Dakota leveraged tax incentives and tech adoption to expand herds. At the same time, California and Wisconsin faltered under drought, regulatory burdens, and declining productivity per cow. Federal subsidies disproportionately buoyed mega-dairies, accelerating an industry divide between industrialized operations and niche producers. Amid debates over immigration reform, methane mandates, and raw milk deregulation, Republican-led efforts to balance free-market policies with farmer protections underscored the political tightrope shaping dairy’s uncertain future.

Key Takeaways

  • Production Paradox: U.S. milk output inched up 0.1% in January 2025 (19.1B lbs) despite a 7-pound drop in per-cow productivity, highlighting efficiency stagnation.
  • 5% Farm Closures: 1,420 dairies closed in 2024, disproportionately small operations in Wisconsin (-400) and California (-85) squeezed by feed costs, labor shortages, and debt.
  • Regional Divide:
    • Growth: Texas (+6.5%) and South Dakota (+6.5%) expanded via tax breaks, tech adoption, and methane digester subsidies.
    • Decline: California (-5.7%) and Arizona (-4.9%) faltered under drought and H5N1 outbreaks.
  • Consolidation: Mega-dairies (>5,000 cows) now produce 43% of U.S. milk, buoyed by federal subsidies (93% of 2024’s $1.2B Dairy Margin Coverage payments).
  • Policy Battles:
    • GOP pushes Farm Freedom Act to redirect subsidies to small farms and block EPA methane rules.
    • Raw milk deregulation splits Republicans, pitting consumer choice against food safety risks.
  • Labor Crisis: 73% of dairy workers are migrants; Trump’s deportation threats clash with industry pleas for visa reforms.
  • 2025 Forecast: 800–1,200 more closures expected as China’s tariffs and feed inflation persist.
U.S. dairy production, farm closures, efficiency paradox, regional disparities, GOP policy reforms

U.S. milk production increased 0.1% year-over-year in January 2025 to 19.1 billion pounds, masking a deepening divide: 1,420 dairies (5% of operations) closed in 2024, disproportionately affecting small Republican-aligned farms. While mega-dairies thrive under federal subsidy structures, grassroots conservatives demand deregulation, immigration reforms, and protections for raw milk sales—issues now central to the GOP’s rural revival platform.

Production Paradox: Small Farms Squeezed by Regulation and Labor Gaps

The USDA’s January 2025 report highlighted a 10,000-head herd expansion but revealed output per cow fell to 2,020 pounds monthly (-0.5% YoY). For small farms, productivity declines collided with regulatory burdens:

  • Oregon’s CAFO Controversy: A 2023 rule briefly required farms with as few as three cows to install $100,000 manure systems, reversed after an outcry from smallholders. “This was corporate cronyism disguised as environmentalism,” said Oregon dairywoman Sarah Kline, referencing lobbying by industrial dairy groups.
  • Labor Shortages: Republican-led states face acute worker deficits, with 73% of farm labor reliant on migrants—half undocumented. Trump’s proposed mass deportations risk destabilizing $43B in dairy output unless visa reforms emerge.

“We’re not against rules—we’re against rules written by bureaucrats who’ve never stepped in manure,” argued Texas Agricultural Commissioner Sid Miller, a Trump ally. “Let us compete without DC dictating our margins.”

Raw Milk Debate Becomes Conservative Litmus Test

The FDA’s nationwide raw milk ban faces GOP-led rebellion:

  • Pennsylvania’s Showdown: Gov. Josh Shapiro faces pressure to revoke raw milk licenses after H5N1 detections, but Amish farmers argue it’s religious liberty.
  • Market Dynamics: Raw milk sales surged 38% in 2024 in deregulated states like South Dakota, where permits cost $50/year. Critics counter that listeria outbreaks—like the 2024 Lancaster County death—show risks outweigh liberty arguments.

Republican Split:

  • Pro-Deregulation: “Consumers deserve choice,” said Rep. Thomas Massie (R-KY), the Milk Freedom Act sponsor. “If you trust farmers with your steak, trust them with milk.”
  • Pro-Safety: “Deregulation without testing is Russian roulette,” countered Kansas GOP state Sen. Beverly Gossage, blocking a raw milk bill.

Policy Reforms: GOP Balances Mega-Dairy Backers and Populist Base

Subsidy Reallocation

  • 2024 Data: 93% of Dairy Margin Coverage payments went to herds >500 cows.
  • Emerging Solution: The Farm Freedom Act (GOP proposal) would cap subsidies for operations >2,000 cows, redirecting funds to small farms adopting methane-reducing feed additives.

Immigration Tightrope

Farm groups lobbied Trump to exempt dairy from deportation plans, proposing:

  • Guest Worker Expansion: 15M seasonal visas to stabilize labor.
  • E-Verify Softening: Exemptions for states with <4% unemployment.

“We need workers, not walls,” said Idaho Dairymen’s CEO Rick Naerebout, a Republican. “If we deport 50% of our workforce, 30% of U.S. dairies fold overnight.”

Regional Case Studies: Red State Strategies

Texas’ “Dairy Freedom Zone” Success

  • Growth: +42,000 cows added in 2024 via:
    • 10-year property tax abatements for methane digesters
    • Right-to-farm laws blocking nuisance lawsuits
    • State-funded robotic milker training ($5M program)

Wisconsin’s Crisis to Opportunity Shift

After losing 400 dairies in 2024, GOP lawmakers passed:

  • Small Farm Revitalization Act: Grants up to $50k for value-added ventures (artisan cheese, A2 milk).
  • Raw Milk Pilot: 50 licensed farms can sell directly if quarterly test results are posted online.

2025 Outlook: Republican Policy Priorities

IssueGOP StanceDemocrat Counter
CAFO RulesExempt farms <200 cowsApply uniformly
Methane PolicyVoluntary credits at $8.50/tonMandate 40% cuts by 2030
TradeRetaliatory tariffs on EU dairyRejoin TPP negotiations

Projected Impacts:

  • Closures: 800–1,200 small farms at risk without subsidy reforms
  • Exports: China’s 25% dairy tariff could cost $420M unless resolved via Trump’s “reciprocal trade” mantra

The Bottom Line

The GOP’s dairy dilemma—pitting pro-corporate donors against populist farmers—mirrors national tensions. While raw milk and immigration dominate headlines, existential questions remain: Can Republicans reconcile free-market ideals with farmer demands for protectionism? As Kansas dairyman Clint Robinson said, “We don’t want handouts. We want handoffs—of power from DC to our county boards.” The party’s 2026 midterm success may hinge on answering that call.

Learn more

Join the Revolution!

Bullvine Daily is your essential e-zine for staying ahead in the dairy industry. With over 30,000 subscribers, we bring you the week’s top news, helping you manage tasks efficiently. Stay informed about milk production, tech adoption, and more, so you can concentrate on your dairy operations. 

NewsSubscribe
First
Last
Consent

U.S. Dairy Margins Hit 3-Year Low Despite Global Price Surges

Dairy farmers face a perfect storm as 2025 margins tighten to $10.14-$12.47/cwt. Despite global price surges, domestic demand plummets by 20%. With feed costs rising and regional disparities widening, operators must navigate complex market forces. Will your strategy beat the 37% profitability threshold?

Summary:

The market outlook paints a complex picture for U.S. dairy farmers. While the Global Dairy Trade auction showed unexpected strength with whole milk powder up 4.1%, skim milk powder up 4.7%, and butter up 3.4%, domestic demand in the U.S. plummeted in December 2024. Cheese consumption fell 3.1%, butter 7.0%, and nonfat dry milk 20.2%. U.S. milk equivalent exports were down 2.6% year-over-year, with nonfat dry and skim milk powder exports dropping 23.4%. The margin dashboard projects tightening margins for dairy farmers, ranging from $10.14 to $12.47 per cwt through November 2025. Regional variations are significant, with Wisconsin having the highest projected margin at $11.75/cwt and California having the lowest at $9.09/cwt. The report highlights the need for farmers to navigate carefully between export opportunities and weakening domestic demand while managing feed costs, which are projected to rise in 2025.

Key Takeaways:

  • Dairy farmers’ profit margins vary significantly by region, with the Midwest showing higher returns than areas like the Southwest.
  • Feed costs are rising, drastically impacting profitability due to its substantial share in dairy farming budgets.
  • The Midwest benefits from lower feed costs, but labor shortages present ongoing challenges for farmers.
  • Southwest dairy farms face tighter margins due to higher operational costs and fluctuating milk prices.
  • To counteract financial pressures, adopting export strategies, innovative feeding practices, and exploring new product lines are recommended.
  • Upcoming USDA events and webinars offer opportunities for farmers to collaborate and explore solutions in the current economic climate.

Empty shelves tell the story: U.S. dairy demand plummets 20.2% in December 2024. As domestic consumption falters (-3.1% cheese, -7% butter), farmers face tightening margins and export reliance. Will 2025’s $10.14–$12.47/cwt projections leave your operation stocked for survival?

Midwest operators lead with $11.75/cwt margins, while Texas operators grapple with $10.65 returns. American dairy farmers face unprecedented margin compression in 2025, with projections showing national averages of $10.14-$12.47/cwt through November. While Global Dairy Trade (GDT) auctions show 4.1% gains for whole milk powder, the collapse of December’s domestic demand (-20.2 % for nonfat dry milk) creates complex regional challenges. 

Regional Realities Demand Tailored Responses 

Margin Disparities Emerge 

RegionMargin (USD/cwt)Key Challenge
Midwest11.75Labor costs
Northwest10.84Water Access
Southwest10.65Feed logistics

Source: USDA/CME State Profiles 

Strategic Implications 

While Wisconsin’s $11.75/cwt margins lead the nation, Texas operators face dual pressures of $12.04 feed costs and tightening credit markets. California’s $9.09 margins now require 18% greater efficiency than 2024 averages to maintain profitability. 

Operational Shifts by Region 

Midwest Opportunities 

  • Lock March corn at $4.93 before seasonal demand spikes
  • Leverage 21.1% cheese export growth through Great Lakes ports

Southwest Challenges 

Operators must develop tailored strategies to address these geographic disparities. For Northwest operators facing $11.10/cwt feed costs, three immediate actions emerge: 

  1. Implement RFID feed tracking to reduce waste by 9%
  2. Shift 15% of production to value-added butter markets
  3. Hedge soybean meal at $328/ton November futures

Market Mechanics Behind Margins 

Feed Cost Pressures Intensify 

CommodityCurrent Price2025 Projection
Corn$4.93/bu+4.2% YoY
SBM$308/ton+6.8% YoY

Production Paradox 

Cheese exports surged 21.1% despite 0.7% lower domestic output, creating inventory headaches for Midwest cooperatives. Meanwhile, butter markets show concerning divergence: 

  • CME spot prices down 3.4%
  • GDT auction prices up 3.4%

The Bottom Line

Dairy operators face a pivotal moment as 2025 projections reveal margins tightening to $9.09-$11.75/cwt nationwide. Regional disparities call for tailored strategies, such as leveraging Wisconsin’s labor-cost advantages against California’s $11.91/cwt feed cost crunch. While export markets offer a silver lining with a +4.1% increase in Global Dairy Trade (GDT) gains, the domestic demand downturn (-20.2% for nonfat dry milk) urges farmers to focus on efficiency tools such as precision feeding or transitioning to value-added shifts—like seeing a 14% rise in buttermilk production. Due to this tightness in margins, there is no room for guesswork. Operators must lock in favorable corn futures at $4.93 for March 2025 immediately. Operators must lock in favorable corn futures at $4.93 for March 2025 to surpass the 37% profitability threshold. Will your operation surpass the 37% profitability threshold? 

Learn more: 

Join the Revolution!

Bullvine Daily is your essential e-zine for staying ahead in the dairy industry. With over 30,000 subscribers, we bring you the week’s top news, helping you manage tasks efficiently. Stay informed about milk production, tech adoption, and more, so you can concentrate on your dairy operations. 

NewsSubscribe
First
Last
Consent

Dairy Market Recap for the Week Ending August 18th 2024

Find out how rising dairy prices affect your farm and what you can do to stay ahead. Are you ready for the market changes? Read more now.

Summary: The dairy market is experiencing a whirlwind of changes this summer, with significant fluctuations in butter, cheese, and milk production across the United States. Tight spot cream supplies in the East and Central regions contrast with steady churning in the West, while cheese production faces regional disparities due to varying milk availability. Fluid milk volumes are dipping across much of the country, influenced by high temperatures, although the Pacific Northwest remains an exception. As milk production forecasts for 2024 and 2025 are lowered, dairy farmers are navigating a complex landscape marked by supply limitations and shifting demands. International dynamics further add to the complexity, with changing production patterns in Europe, Australia, and South America influencing global dairy prices. Dairy costs have reached record levels, affecting farmers and producers. Factors driving these prices include fluctuations in milk output and increased demand in global markets. Butter prices have remained stable, while cheese prices have varied. Nonfat dry milk has decreased slightly, but dry whey has maintained a mixed trend. Grade AA butter closed around $3.1800 in mid-August, with a weekly average approaching $3.1410. Declining cream supplies in the East and Central areas have made churning rare, while the West remains active. Cheese demand is constantly in flux, with milk supplies tightening as schools stock up. Retail cheese demand is increasing, providing vitality to the market. Grade A NDM and dried whey have remained slightly lower than the weekly average, leading to constrained supply and surging demand. The Pacific Northwest has moderate temperatures, while dry dairy products are making waves due to their complex supply and demand dynamics. International markets significantly impact U.S. dairy pricing, with hot weather worsening the seasonal decline in milk output in Europe.

  • Tight spot cream supplies in the East and Central regions, with steady churning in the West.
  • Cheese production faces regional disparities due to varying milk availability.
  • Fluid milk volumes are dipping across much of the U.S., except in the Pacific Northwest, influenced by high temperatures.
  • Milk production forecasts for 2024 and 2025 have been lowered, impacting dairy farmers.
  • International dynamics, including production patterns in Europe, Australia, and South America, influence global dairy prices.
  • Dairy costs have reached record levels due to fluctuations in milk output and global demand.
  • Butter prices remain stable, while cheese prices show regional variations.
  • Nonfat dry milk prices have slightly decreased, and dry whey prices show mixed trends.
  • Increasing retail cheese demand suggests a strengthening market.
  • Moderate temperatures in the Pacific Northwest are aiding milk production stability.
  • International hot weather conditions are worsening the seasonal decline in milk output in Europe.

Have you ever wondered why your grocery store’s dairy section has become more expensive recently? It’s not just inflation; dairy costs are skyrocketing at record levels. These fluctuating market movements may have a significant impact on farmers. Staying educated is more than just a good idea; it’s essential for managing this ever-changing world. Understanding the mechanics behind these pricing changes might make the difference between prospering and barely scraping by. Several reasons are driving these growing prices, including fluctuations in milk output and increased demand in worldwide markets. Butter prices have remained stable over the previous week, whereas cheese prices have varied. Nonfat dry milk has decreased somewhat, although dry whey has maintained a mixed trend. These little adjustments have a significant effect on dairy producers like you. By the end, you’ll better understand why keeping ahead of market trends is not just advantageous, but necessary for proactive decision-making.

ProductLatest Closing PriceWeekly Average PricePrice Change (+/-)
Butter (Grade AA)$3.1800$3.1410+0.0400
Cheese (Barrels)$2.2550$2.1840+0.2370
Cheese (40# Blocks)$2.1000$2.0495+0.1275
Nonfat Dry Milk (Grade A)$1.2550$1.2380-0.0155
Dry Whey (Extra Grade)$0.5500$0.5590-0.0275

Wondering How the Dairy Market is Faring This Summer? Let’s Break It Down. 

How was the dairy market doing this summer? Let us break it down. First, let’s discuss butter. As of mid-August, Grade AA butter closed around $3.1800, with a weekly average approaching $3.1410. “Why the uptick?” you may wonder. Declining cream supplies in the East and Central areas have made churning rare, while the West remains active.

Cheese is now the subject of an ongoing drama. Barrel cheese closed at $2.2550, while 40-pound chunks sold for $2.1000. Weekly averages rose significantly, with barrels at $2.1840 and blocks at $2.0495. Cheese demand is constantly in flux: milk supplies are tightening, mainly as schools stock up, making Class I requirements a top priority. But guess what? Retail cheese demand is increasing, providing vitality to the market.

What about nonfat dry milk (NDM) and dried whey? Grade A NDM finished at $1.2550, slightly lower than the weekly average of $1.2380. Dry whey concluded at $0.5500, with the weekly average dropping to $0.5590. The story here is one of scarcity—whether condensed skim or whey, everyone feels the squeeze.

The primary result is that constrained supply and surging demand are paving the way for a volatile market. As a dairy producer, it’s crucial to monitor these market trends and navigate these developments. This vigilance will help you understand the market’s future direction and make informed decisions. Will these tendencies remain consistent? Only time will tell, but your proactive monitoring will keep you ahead of the curve.

What’s Going On with the Butter Market? Spoiler: It’s Quite the Roller Coaster! 

Are you aware that the butter market is seeing exciting changes this summer? Let’s get into it. Butter production has reached a seasonal low, which is unsurprising given the time of year. Limited spot cream supplies have hampered churning schedules in the East and Central areas. However, the West has a different narrative. Despite the seasonal fall, butter output in this area remains steady. This geographical disparity represents a fragmented market in which location influences manufacturing tendencies.

As the autumn season approaches, butter demand is expected to rise. Customers begin to reserve their quantities to get ahead of the seasonal rush. It’s that time when everyone prepares for Christmas baking and festive feasts. Don’t remember that consumers purchase 3-5% more butter in the autumn than in summer [Bureau of Labor Statistics]. This increase in demand has a positive impact on butter prices in the latter half of the year. This anticipation of increased demand should make you feel prepared and ready to capitalize on the market.

What does this imply for pricing? The butter market is stable, but those positive factors could impact prices as the autumn season unfolds. This is especially important for dairy producers and dealers seeking to capitalize on market circumstances. In summary, although supply may be at a seasonal low, demand is increasing. This dynamic will substantially influence butter prices as the year ends.

Let’s Talk Cheese: What’s Driving This Market’s Steady Climb? 

Let’s discuss cheese. Have you observed how the cheese market has recently been stable with a modest upward tendency? There are a few main variables influencing this. One of the most potent influences is milk supply. Cheesemakers suffer when milk quantities tighten, as they have recently, particularly in the East. Limited milk implies fewer raw materials for manufacturing, resulting in a rippling impact on supply and pricing.

But it isn’t just about the milk. Regional demand is also an important consideration. Food service demand has been consistent, but retail demand is where things become interesting. Consider this: with schools resuming, there is an increase in demand for cheese. Why? Educational institutions are large consumers of dairy products, and their buying activity increases when the academic year begins. This increase in demand strengthens the market and helps to keep cheese prices firm.

The limited spot milk supply in the central area is projected to keep prices above Class III until around Labor Day. Meanwhile, farmers in the West feel the strain but seem to have enough milk to keep the wheels going. Inventory levels vary per company, but the overall message is cautious optimism. As we approach the autumn season, combining milk supply and increased school demand may pave the way for the next phase of cheese market dynamics. The resilience and determination of farmers in the face of supply constraints should inspire and motivate you in your own operations.

What’s the Real Story Behind Fluid Milk Production This Summer? It’s a Tale of Regional Contrasts 

What is the true story behind fluid milk production this summer? It’s a story of regional disparities caused by temperature fluctuations and varying seasonal needs. Dairies throughout the United States report lower milk output as the summer heat takes its toll. Temperatures in the highland and southern desert regions reach triple digits, putting cow comfort at risk and decreasing milk output.

However, the Pacific Northwest is a significant exception. Here, moderate temperatures—peaking in the 70s during the day and dropping to the 50s at night—have helped to keep milk quantities stable. This geographical heterogeneity is essential in influencing our overall fluid milk trends.

Seasonal changes play a significant role in the dairy market. With the back-to-school season approaching, there is an increased demand for Class I, notably fluid milk products. This demand prompts milk to migrate within areas to fulfill local demands, resulting in restricted supply and higher spot market prices. For example, spot milk prices reached $3.50 over Class, up $1.00 from the previous week. Understanding and anticipating these seasonal shifts can help you prepare and adapt your business strategies accordingly.

While some areas see a seasonal fall in milk production, others maintain their levels. This intricate interaction of environment and seasonal demand affects the fluid milk market, keeping dairy producers on their toes. As we look forward to the following months, we should evaluate how these regional and seasonal elements will continue to impact milk quantities and pricing, posing difficulties and possibilities for individuals in the dairy business.

Why Are Dry Dairy Products Making Waves in the Market? Let’s Get Into It. 

As we concentrate on dry dairy products, the landscape for commodities such as nonfat dry milk, dry buttermilk, and dry whey shows a complex narrative of supply and demand dynamics influencing pricing and availability. Nonfat dry milk (NDM) costs, for example, have stabilized somewhat while rising in some places. This variation corresponds to the lower availability of condensed skim, which tends to fall with seasonal milk production. Less milk means less opportunity to create NDM, pushing prices upward.

Dry buttermilk is a mixed bag: inventories are available but not growing, indicating a balanced market without oversupply. The supply limitations are less severe than in NDM, but they are strong enough to prevent prices from decreasing. End users should expect pricing to be steady or higher, depending on their geographical market.

Then, we have dry whey, which highlights the market’s intricacies. Prices have fluctuated across areas, mainly due to the limited supply of selected labeled whey, keeping the market somewhat positive. The selective scarcity adds an element of uncertainty, causing companies that manufacture higher-protein concentrates to prefer whey protein concentrate markets.

Overall, it is evident that, although supplies of these dry items remain constant in certain circumstances, they are tightening in others. This equilibrium, or lack thereof, profoundly influences market circumstances and price structures. Supply chain coordination and strategic procurement planning become more critical as processors and end users negotiate these challenges.

Global Dairy Dynamics: How International Markets Shape U.S. Dairy Prices 

International markets substantially impact U.S. dairy pricing since different areas confront distinct difficulties and possibilities. Hot weather has worsened the seasonal decline in milk output in Europe, notably in Western countries such as France, Germany, and the Netherlands, resulting in lower milk yields and reduced availability of dairy products. This has added uncertainty to the market, raising farm gate milk and cream prices and impacting global trade dynamics.

Meanwhile, in Eastern Europe, the picture is more upbeat. Countries such as Belarus are increasing milk output. According to USDA and CLAL statistics, Belarus witnessed a 3.7% rise in milk output in June 2024 compared to the prior year. This localized expansion helps to offset shortages elsewhere and contributes to the more excellent worldwide supply chain.

Oceania’s story is a mixed bag. Australia’s dairy exports have fallen 23.5 percent from the previous year owing to weather-related challenges and a tight feed market. Despite this, estimates for ordinary to above-average rainfall indicate some respite in the next season. In contrast, during recent trading events, New Zealand’s anticipated milk price for the 2024/2025 season has increased, partly due to a higher index price for whole milk powder. This surge is anticipated to keep global dairy prices up.

South American dairy farmers have benefited from neutral weather trends. Countries such as Brazil and Uruguay indicate good circumstances that should sustain continuous milk production. Cow comfort and pasture quality have been constant and favorable, ensuring a consistent supply of dairy products.

These worldwide dynamics influence supply and demand in the United States market. Reduced output in crucial regions such as Western Europe and Oceania may require more imports to meet local needs, thus raising costs. On the other hand, increased production in Eastern Europe and South America may help stabilize world supply, reducing dramatic price volatility. It’s a delicate balance that American dairy producers must strike, with worldwide trends constantly changing the landscape.

Have You Noticed More Dairy Ads Lately? You’re Not Imagining Things. 

Have you seen an increase in dairy advertising recently? You are not imagining things. According to recent studies, retail advertising totals have increased significantly. Conventional ad numbers are up 5%, but organic ads have increased by 52%. That’s quite a bump! Traditional ice cream in 48-to-64-ounce containers has been the most marketed item, with typical cheese in six-to-eight-ounce pieces following closely after. Even in the organic section, half-gallon milk remains popular.

So, what does this imply for you, the dairy farmer? These retail trends are more than simply statistics; they reflect customer desire. When marketing for dairy products rises, it usually indicates high customer interest. And increased customer interest generally results in higher costs. For example, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported a 2.2% increase in the July Consumer Price Index (CPI) for total food, while dairy goods showed mixed patterns, including a 1.3% increase in fresh whole milk and a significant 6.1% increase in butter.

Now, let’s connect the dots. As demand rises, farmers must plan for both possibilities and problems. Higher retail pricing often results in more significant profit margins for manufacturers. However, it is a double-edged sword; increasing demand for feed and other resources may result in higher production costs. Furthermore, the pressure to maintain high-quality output will increase as prices rise.

Be watchful and adaptive. Monitor consumer trends and store ads. They provide crucial information on the market’s direction. Altering your strategy proactively may help you capitalize on these developments, ensuring that your efforts pay off now and in the future.

Supply and Demand Shifts: How Will Lowered Milk Production Forecasts Impact You? 

As we examine the most recent supply and demand projections for the dairy market, it is clear that the picture is changing dramatically. The World Agricultural Outlook Board’s (WAOB) August Supply and Demand Estimates show that milk production predictions for 2024 and 2025 have been reduced. This change is based on the most current statistics, which show a fall in cow inventories and reduced production per cow for both years.

How does this affect dairy farmers? Lower milk production predictions inevitably result in tighter supply. In dairy economics, tighter supply often puts upward pressure on pricing. The predicted decrease in milk production coincides with the expected price rise for different dairy products. The price estimates for cheese, nonfat dry milk (NDM), and whey have been increased in response to recent price gains. The all-milk price is expected to climb to $22.30 per cwt in 2024 and $22.75 per cwt in 2025.

Butter, however, offers a somewhat different narrative. Despite decreasing milk output, the butter price projection 2024 has been revised downward. This might be due to altering market dynamics or current inventory levels that are adequate to fulfill demand. However, the lower milk supply for other goods, such as cheese and whey, is expected to sustain further price hikes.

Despite decreasing output, robust local and international demand for dairy is predicted to stabilize prices. Dairy producers should optimize their processes to capitalize on increased pricing while controlling decreasing milk yield.

The Bottom Line

The dairy industry is active and diverse, with butter production balancing seasonal lows with anticipated demand and cheesemakers dealing with limited milk sources and unpredictable stocks. Temperatures impact regional variations in fluid milk production. In contrast, dry dairy product pricing varies due to restricted milk supply and altering seasonal demand. International market patterns influence U.S. pricing, emphasizing the need for monitoring and agility. Are you using all available data and insights to improve your operations and keep ahead of these changes?

Learn more: 

Germany’s Dairy Industry Faces Largest Herd Decline in a Decade: Over 650,000 Fewer Cows & 27,000 Fewer Farms in 10 Years

Uncover the reasons behind the most significant decline in Germany’s dairy herd in the past decade. What are the driving factors behind the reduction of over 650,000 cows in just ten years?

The German dairy sector is in a state of decline that demands immediate attention. According to the statistics agency of Germany, Destatis, 2,222 dairy farms were lost between May 2023 and May 2024, bringing the total to under 50,000 for the first time. The numbers of dairy cows are also plummeting, with almost 650,000 disappearing over the past decade. These drastic changes underscore the urgent need for policy changes. We must address these developments as they will shape the future of the German dairy sector, and policymakers have a crucial role in this transformation.

YearNumber of Dairy CowsNumber of Dairy FarmsAverage Herd Size
20144,311,08677,12156
20154,300,00074,00058
20164,280,00070,80060
20174,250,00067,50063
20184,200,00064,00066
20194,150,00060,50069
20204,100,00057,00072
20214,050,00054,00075
20224,000,00051,00078
20233,950,00049,45280
20243,668,00047,23077

Germany’s Dairy Sector Faces Unprecedented Shift 

The dairy industry in Germany is changing noticeably. Between May 2023 and May 2024, the number of dairy farms declined by 2,222, bringing the total down for the first time below 50,000. This emphasizes the significant difficulties and changes facing the sector, which could affect German dairy farming.

A Sharp Contraction: The Steep Decline of Germany’s Dairy Cows 

The decline in dairy cow numbers is a significant and long-term trend. Over the past ten years, the industry has seen a staggering decrease of 643,086 cows, with 45,000 fewer cows than just a year ago. This steep drop, driven by labor shortages and inadequate investment, underscores the profound changes within the sector. We must adapt to these changes as the industry grapples with these transformative issues.

A Decade of Transformation: The Stark Changes in Germany’s Dairy Industry 

The dairy sector in Germany was quite different ten years ago. Back then, there were 27,669 dairy farms, sharply distinct from the 49,452 we know today. This suggests significant structural changes in the farming industry. Dairy cow counts fell from nearly 4.3 million to 4,656 million, cutting 643,086 cows. Labor shortages, lack of investment, and shifting customer tastes explain this decade-long contraction—the biggest in industry history.

Shifting Dynamics: How Farm Sizes Reflect Broader Trends in Germany’s Dairy Sector

How farm sizes are distributed in Germany’s dairy business exposes more general industry patterns. Labor shortages and inadequate investment have caused significant reductions in medium-sized farms—especially those with 10 to 49 dairy cows. Larger farms also suffered a transitory rise in farms with 200 or more cows between May 2022 and May 2023, followed by a decline. Farms with 100 to 199 dairy cows showed the most minor shrinkage, suggesting stronger resilience or adaptation methods in this group.

Consequences of Herd Consolidation in Germany’s Dairy Sector

With 74.2 cows per farm per farm, Germany’s dairy sector clearly shows a consolidation tendency. Smaller farms grow or shut down, resulting in bigger, more effective businesses. This change fits world movements toward a more agricultural economy of scale and efficiency. This consolidation depends critically on financial factors like restricted investment and labor shortages. Furthermore, flexitarian diets and declining dairy intake influence these changes as the industry adjusts to customer tastes.

Regional Disparities in Dairy Herd Contraction Across Germany 

The degree of herd reduction throughout Germany’s states exposes notable geographical differences. With the herd contracting 6.7 percent, Saarland had the biggest fall. This decline points to problems like labor shortages and inadequate regional investment.

Baden-Württemberg, on the other hand, saw the slightest decline; the herd size dropped only 1.6 percent. This little decrease points to a more robust dairy industry in Baden-Württemberg, which has provided an excellent response to dietary changes and market dynamics problems. These differences expose Germany’s dairy sector’s various regional strengths and weaknesses.

The Bottom Line

Driven by dwindling profitability, labor shortages, changing customer tastes, and strict environmental rules, Germany’s dairy industry is undergoing its most major overhaul in a decade. The herd size declined by 45,000 cows, while the number of dairy farms dropped by 2,222, lowering the total to less than 50,000. Different areas have responded differently to these developments; medium-sized farms have suffered less.

As the sector grapples with economic difficulties and a shift towards sustainable and ethically produced dairy products, the need for long-term planning and sustainable solutions becomes more pressing. Environmental constraints continue to impact herd numbers, and farmers must now think creatively about their responses. The ripple effects of these changes are felt in rural economies, supply lines, and global dairy markets. Policymakers and industry players must come together to devise sustainable solutions that balance environmental care with financial feasibility. This calls for laws and procedures that uphold Germany’s ethical dairy farming standards and ensure long-term sustainability.

Key Takeaways:

  • The number of dairy farms in Germany decreased by 2,222 between May 2023 and May 2024.
  • For the first time, the total number of dairy farms in Germany has fallen below 50,000.
  • The German dairy herd reduced by approximately 45,000 cows in one year.
  • Over the past decade, the number of dairy cows has contracted by 643,086 animals.
  • The average number of cows per farm in Germany now stands at 74.2.
  • Farms with 10 to 49 dairy cows experienced the highest rate of decline.
  • The number of large farms with 200 or more cows initially increased but also saw a decrease in the most recent period.
  • Regional differences are significant, with Saarland witnessing the largest contraction at 6.7% and Baden-Wurttemberg the smallest at 1.6%.

Summary:

The German dairy sector is experiencing a significant decline, with 2,222 farms lost between May 2023 and May 2024, bringing the total to under 50,000 for the first time. The number of dairy cows is also plummeting, with almost 650,000 disappearing over the past decade. This drastic change underscores the urgent need for policy changes to shape the future of the German dairy sector. The dairy industry was different ten years ago, with 27,669 farms, and the number of dairy cows fell from nearly 4.3 million to 4,656 million, cutting 643,086 cows. Labor shortages and inadequate investment have caused significant reductions in medium-sized farms, particularly those with 10 to 49 dairy cows. Larger farms also experienced a transitory rise in farms with 200 or more cows between May 2022 and May 2023, followed by a decline. Farms with 100 to 199 dairy cows showed the most minor shrinkage, suggesting stronger resilience or adaptation methods. The dairy sector shows a consolidation tendency, with smaller farms growing or shutting down, resulting in bigger, more effective businesses. Regional disparities in dairy herd contraction across Germany expose notable geographical differences. As the sector grapples with economic difficulties and a shift towards sustainable and ethically produced dairy products, the need for long-term planning and sustainable solutions becomes more pressing.

Learn more:

Is 2024 Shaping Up to Be a Disappointing Year for Dairy Exports and Milk Yields?

Are dairy exports and milk production set for another uninspiring year in 2024? Discover the trends and expert insights shaping the industry’s future.

Bart Peer, voeren van vet aan melkvee in Beuningen t.b.v. Misset/Boerderij Opdrachtnummer: 416573 Kostenplaats 06003 Fotograaf: Van Assendelft Fotografie

The dairy industry‘s backbone has been its milk yields and exports, critical for regional economies and farmers’ livelihoods. While demand for high-quality dairy products boosts growth and revenue, the sector faces significant changes. 

The U.S. dairy industry is currently at a crossroads. Year-over-year milk production declined by 1.3% in February 2024. The U.S. milking cowherd has shrunk monthly since June 2023, with limited heifer availability adding to the woes. Despite some resilience in milk component production from December to February, larger challenges overshadow these gains. 

“It’s hard to imagine milk production making material improvements with cow numbers down year-over-year, heifers in short supply, and rough economics in several regions,” says Phil Plourd, president of Ever.Ag Insight. 

With fewer cows, economic stress, and stagnant heifer replacements, 2024 may bring more uninspiring results. Consequently, the dairy sector‘s growth and sustainability metrics could fall short, impacting potential recovery and expansion.

Understanding The Decline: Year-Over-Year Milk Production Trends

Notably, the USDA Milk Production Report highlights a 2% year-over-year decline across 24 central states in April. This pattern aligns with nationwide trends, reflecting more profound systemic challenges in the U.S. dairy sector. Although May 2024 saw a slight increase in per-cow output, total production fell marginally. 

Several key points arise from these reports. The persistent reduction in herd size contrasts with improved per-cow productivity, which fails to offset the decline fully. The milking cow population has dropped to 8.89 million head, a year-over-year reduction of 55,000. 

Regional disparities add complexity. Some areas sustain or boost production slightly, but places like New Mexico saw a drastic 17.3% decline, exposing regional vulnerabilities. 

The economic landscape, marked by falling prices and moderate shipment volume growth, also dampens producers’ recovery prospects. Thus, closely monitoring economic conditions will be crucial for predicting future milk production trends.

YearMilk Production Volume (in billion lbs)Year-Over-Year Change (%)
2020223.2+2.2%
2021225.6+1.1%
2022223.5-0.9%
2023220.0-1.6%

Analyzing Annual Shifts in Dairy Export Patterns

The past year has marked significant changes in dairy export trends, with volume and value experiencing notable fluctuations. Although 2023 saw U.S. dairy exports total $8.11 billion, this represented a 16% decrease from the record year of 2022, highlighting the volatility of global dairy markets

One primary factor in these shifts is the decline in domestic milk production, directly impacting export volumes. Despite some milk and milk component production growth from December to February, the overall trend remains challenging. 

Volatile agricultural markets and external factors like El Niño weather patterns have further complicated global supply chains. Additionally, reductions in farmgate milk prices and persistent on-farm inflation continue to strain U.S. dairy farms.

YearTotal Export Value (in billion USD)Percentage Change from Previous YearKey Factors
20206.2+5%Stable milk prices, moderate global demand
20217.0+13%Increased global demand, favorable trade agreements
20229.7+19%High global demand, favorable prices, export market expansion
20238.11-16%Weakened global demand, eased prices
2024 (Forecast)8.5+5%Slow recovery in demand, stable prices

Key Determinants in Milk Production Outcomes

Environmental challenges like droughts and extreme weather events have become significant obstacles to stable milk yields. These conditions can severely affect forage quality and availability, impacting the quantity and quality of milk from dairy cows. For instance, droughts reduce grazing land and drive up feed costs, further straining production budgets. 

Rising production costs have also hindered farmers’ ability to invest in essential technologies. Modern dairy farming requires advanced milking systems, automated feeding mechanisms, and enhanced herd management software. Yet, persistent economic pressures and on-farm inflation make such investments challenging, directly affecting milk yields by reducing farm efficiency. 

Labor shortages continue to impede dairy operations. The industry relies on a consistent and skilled workforce. Still, the COVID-19 pandemic and immigration policy uncertainties have left many farms understaffed. This labor scarcity delays essential operations and hinders the implementation of quality control measures, impacting overall milk production.

Key Influencers on Dairy Export Performance

Trade tensions continue to cloud the outlook for U.S. dairy exports. Tariffs and trade barriers stemming from geopolitical conflicts create uncertainty and hinder competitiveness in global markets. These economic disruptions inflate costs and squeeze profit margins for U.S. dairy farmers

Additionally, changing consumer preferences are shifting demand away from traditional dairy products to plant-based alternatives, driven by health and environmental concerns. This trend challenges dairy exporters to develop innovative strategies to recapture market share. 

Moreover, the U.S. dairy industry faces stiff competition from dairy powerhouses like New Zealand and the European Union. These countries are backing their dairy sectors with proactive export strategies and government support, making the global market fiercely competitive. U.S. producers must innovate and improve efficiency to sustain their place in the international market.

Potential Implications for 2024

The anticipated decline in dairy exports could impose significant financial strain on U.S. dairy farmers. With exports representing a crucial revenue stream, any downturn will likely impact their bottom lines and economic stability. This financial pressure may force producers to reassess their operations, potentially leading to further reductions in herd sizes and investments. 

Compounding these challenges, lower milk yields are expected to affect overall supply, which could, in turn, drive up prices. While higher prices might seem beneficial, the reality is more nuanced. Increased prices can lead to reduced consumer demand and heightened competition from global markets, making it harder for U.S. products to remain competitive. 

In light of these hurdles, there is a clear need for government intervention and support to stabilize the industry. Programs such as Dairy Margin Coverage (DMC) have relieved producers, and their continuation will be essential. Additionally, new initiatives could be explored in the upcoming Farm Bill to address the evolving challenges faced by the dairy sector, helping to ensure its long-term viability and sustainability.

Producers’ Perspective: Navigating a Challenging Market

Producers nationwide are acutely aware of today’s challenging market. Many are reevaluating their strategies with dwindling cow numbers and fluctuating feed costs driven by volatile agriculture markets and adverse weather conditions. Persistent declines in farmgate milk prices and high production costs continue to squeeze profit margins, leaving dairy farmers in a precarious position. 

In response, innovative measures are being adopted. Beef-on-dairy operations, merging beef genetics with dairy herds, enhance profitability. Raising fewer heifers and cutting operational costs are becoming standard practices. Automation and technology promise to improve efficiency and cost management. 

However, the pandemic-induced labor shortage remains a critical bottleneck, with health concerns and regulatory constraints limiting workforce availability. Producers are diversifying income streams to mitigate these issues, venturing into agritourism or other agricultural enterprises to buffer against market volatility. 

Looking ahead, producers are closely monitoring market dynamics and profit margins, with any potential rebound in milk production depending on improved economic conditions and informed decision-making. Enhanced sustainability practices are also a focus as farmers strive to reduce methane emissions and implement eco-friendly methods.

Future Forecast: What Lies Ahead for Dairy Exports and Production?

The outlook for dairy exports and milk production is complex and shaped by various factors. Dr. Christopher Wolf of Cornell University emphasized the role of El Nino weather patterns, potentially causing feed cost volatility. Combined with persistent on-farm inflation, these conditions challenge dairy producers facing reduced farmgate milk prices. 

The shrinking dairy herd adds to the difficulties, with a limited supply of heifers restricting milk production growth. USDA reports forecast a slight downward trend for 2024. 

However, high beef prices and decreasing milk production might boost milk prices later in the year, offering market stability. Krysta Harden of the U.S. Dairy Export Council aims for a 20% export target, reflecting ambitions to expand the U.S. presence in global dairy markets despite trade uncertainties. 

In contrast, the EU projects a 1% increase in cheese exports but declines in butter and skim milk powder, presenting market gaps that U.S. exports could fill to boost overall value and volume. 

The future of U.S. dairy exports and milk production hinges on economic conditions, weather patterns, and strategic industry moves, requiring stakeholders to stay informed and adaptable.

The Bottom Line

The dairy industry’s challenges in 2024 are undeniable. The outlook appears grim with a persistent decline in milk production, reduced cowherd sizes, and a heifer shortage. Although U.S. dairy exports showed some promise, achieving long-term goals is still being determined amid fluctuating markets and soft milk prices. 

Industry stakeholders must take proactive measures. It is crucial to explore strategies to enhance production efficiency and improve margins. Expanding export opportunities could capitalize on a potential market resurgence later this year. 

The path to recovery is complex but possible. With informed decision-making and efforts to address current challenges, stabilization, and growth are within reach. Adapting to market trends will be vital in navigating these turbulent times successfully.

Key Takeaways:

  • Year-over-year milk production saw a 1.3% decline in February 2024.
  • The U.S. milking cowherd has been consistently shrinking each month since June 2023.
  • Despite a dip in cow numbers and heifer availability, milk component production showed some growth from December through February compared to the previous year.
  • Phil Plourd, president of Ever.Ag Insight, highlights the difficulty in imagining significant improvements in milk production under current conditions.
  • Economist Dan Basse expects tight cow numbers to persist given the static heifer replacement rates.
  • U.S. dairy exports were strong in February 2024; however, they remain below the record levels achieved in 2022.
  • Dairy Margin Coverage (DMC) indemnity payments provided essential support to producers in 2023 amid declining feed prices and soft milk prices in 2024.

Summary: The dairy industry, which relies on milk yields and exports for regional economies and farmers’ livelihoods, is facing significant challenges in 2024. In February 2024, year-over-year milk production declined by 1.3%, with the U.S. milking cowherd shrinking monthly since June 2023 and limited heifer availability adding to the woes. Despite some resilience in milk component production from December to February, larger challenges overshadow these gains. The USDA Milk Production Report highlights a 2% year-over-year decline across 24 central states in April, reflecting more profound systemic challenges in the U.S. dairy sector. Regional disparities add complexity, with some areas sustaining or boosting production slightly, while places like New Mexico saw a drastic 17.3% decline. Milk production volume has seen significant changes in the past year, with U.S. dairy exports totaling $8.11 billion in 2023, a 16% decrease from the record year of 2022. Environmental challenges like droughts and extreme weather events have become significant obstacles to stable milk yields, impacting forage quality and availability, and straining production budgets. Rising production costs have hindered farmers’ ability to invest in essential technologies, and labor shortages continue to impede dairy operations. Trade tensions and geopolitical conflicts are causing uncertainty and hindering global market competitiveness for U.S. dairy exports. Government intervention and support are needed to stabilize the industry.

Send this to a friend