Archive for European Dairy Farmers

EU-China Dairy Trade Dispute Intensifies: What It Means for Global Markets

Curious about the EU-China dairy trade dispute and its global impact? Find out how this conflict could reshape the dairy industry.

Summary: In a significant escalation of international trade tensions, China has launched an anti-subsidy investigation into European Union (EU) dairy exports, igniting global concerns. The probe, announced by China’s Ministry of Commerce, aims to scrutinize subsidies provided to EU dairy farmers, suspecting these financial supports have unfairly bolstered the competitiveness of EU dairy products in the Chinese market. This move is perceived as a retaliatory action following the EU’s tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles. The investigation, set to span over a year, will examine imports dating back to early 2023, potentially resulting in substantial tariffs or restrictions on European dairy products entering China. The EU-China dairy trade dispute is rooted in the complex global commerce network and regulatory procedures, focusing on major European exports like fresh cheese, milk, and cream and examining 20 subsidy schemes. European organizations like FrieslandCampina and Dairy Industry Ireland collaborate with investigating agencies to demonstrate compliance with international trade standards. If the charges are confirmed, EU dairy imports may face severe taxes or limitations, impacting European farmers and altering global trade dynamics. Major dairy exporters like New Zealand and the United States also stand to be affected. European dairy associations, such as Eucolait and Copa Cogeca, are calling for assistance measures to support European farmers amid this looming trade conflict.

  • China initiates an anti-subsidy probe into EU dairy exports, citing unfair competitive advantages due to subsidies.
  • The investigation could lead to significant tariffs or restrictions on EU dairy products entering China.
  • The probe is seen as a retaliatory measure following the EU’s tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles.
  • Investigation covers key dairy products like fresh cheese, milk, and cream, examining 20 different subsidy schemes.
  • European dairy organizations, including FrieslandCampina and Dairy Industry Ireland, are working to prove compliance with international trade rules.
  • The outcome of the probe may substantially impact European dairy farmers and shift global trade dynamics.
  • New Zealand and the United States, major dairy exporters to China, might also feel the repercussions.
  • European associations such as Eucolait and Copa Cogeca are urging for measures to support farmers during this trade dispute.
EU-China dairy trade dispute, Chinese Ministry of Commerce, improper subsidies, European dairy producers, global commerce network, regulatory procedures, state subsidies, unfair edge, European market, major European exports, dairy products, EU's Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), potential losses, Irish dairy exports, investigating agencies, international trade standards, Chinese inquiry, fresh cheese, milk, cream, subsidy schemes, severe taxes, limitations, European farmers, global trade relations, New Zealand, United States, market share, supply chain, price volatility, AHDB, powder prices, global production, pricing plans, larger-scale precedent, European dairy associations, Eucolait, Copa Cogeca, labor conflict, assistance measures, adverse effects, local production, self-sufficiency, market share, European dairy farmers, new markets.

The EU-China dairy trade battle is rapidly escalating, and it’s about more than just milk and cheese. What is really at stake here? According to Eucolait, the European umbrella group for the dairy sector, ‘For many years now, the European Union has proven to be a reliable supplier of high-quality dairy products and ingredients to the Chinese market.’ It is alarming that dairy will be sacrificed in an industrial dispute over electric automobiles. The European Commission should urgently and decisively act to resolve this trade dispute. The need for a swift resolution is paramount. Let’s investigate the specifics and understand how this conflict will impact global markets.

Background: The Catalyst for Conflict 

The Chinese Ministry of Commerce has probed potential improper subsidies for European dairy producers. This measure primarily avenges the EU’s levies on Chinese electric automobiles. What is the true story behind these tit-for-tat measures?

The conflict is rooted in the complex global commerce network and regulatory procedures. Earlier this year, the European Commission placed duties on imported electric cars from China, citing worries over state subsidies that allegedly provided Chinese manufacturers an unfair edge in the European market. In response, China focuses on major European exports such as dairy products, which are heavily subsidized by the EU’s Common Agricultural Policy (CAP).

This growing situation highlights the giant geopolitical chess game in which big economies use trade policy as instruments of influence. Chinese authorities claim that EU subsidies under different CAP programs, such as critical income assistance and incentives for young farmers, create an unfair playing field for domestic dairy producers. On the other hand, the EU believes that its subsidies are entirely compliant with World Trade Organization (WTO) standards, characterizing China’s measures as excessive and politically motivated.

The stakes are enormous, with potential losses well beyond the sectors directly involved. For instance, Irish dairy exports to China were €426 million (US$487 million) in 2023, with an estimated €46 million at risk due to the current investigation. Organizations such as FrieslandCampina and Dairy Industry Ireland are ready to collaborate with investigating agencies to demonstrate compliance with international trade standards. The gravity of these potential losses underscores the need for swift resolution.

This disagreement highlights an important point: the global marketplace is always susceptible to the ebb and flow of international politics and policy choices. Despite its isolated character, the dairy industry is now embroiled in a more significant economic battle between two economic behemoths, highlighting the interwoven nature of contemporary commerce.

The Stakes: What’s Under Investigation? 

The Chinese inquiry targets dairy products, including fresh cheese, milk, and cream. It looks at 20 subsidy schemes that give EU dairy an unfair edge. How may this affect the global dairy market?

First, if the inquiry confirms the charges, EU dairy imports may face severe taxes or limitations. This would not just hurt European farmers but also change global trade relations. Key exporters like New Zealand and the United States may embrace the chance to boost their market share in China.

Furthermore, interruptions in the supply chain might cause price volatility. For example, the UK’s AHDB has said that rising milk output had already dragged down powder prices. Further limitations might worsen the trend, affecting global production and pricing plans.

This investigation might create a larger-scale precedent, prompting other governments to study subsidies and trade practices more closely. The European Commission’s challenging approach to protecting its policies and sectors may result in comparable reprisals, culminating in a more significant trade battle.

This probe is more than just a bilateral disagreement; it can affect global dairy markets, altering everything from price to international trade ties. How the EU and China handle this will influence the industry’s environment for years.

Industry Reactions: Voices From the Field

European dairy associations, such as Eucolait and Copa Cogeca, are outraged. They say the dairy industry is unjustly pulled into an unrelated labor conflict. What are their worries, and how do they intend to respond? Let’s look at their opinions.

Eucolait, the European dairy industry’s umbrella body, vigorously opposed the inquiry. They argue, “It is unjust that dairy will be sacrificed in an industrial fight over electric automobiles. The European Commission should do all it can to resolve this trade dispute as soon as possible [source]. Their biggest worry is the impact such investigations may have on the global dairy industry, possibly influencing pricing and trading routes.

In a social media post, Copa Cogeca shared similar sentiments: “This further escalation in the EU-China trade relationship and the continuous impact on our sector is very worrying.” They emphasize that European dairy farmers and agricultural cooperatives produce and export in complete compliance with EU and WTO standards. The association cautions against what they see as an unjustified challenge to the EU’s Common Agriculture Policy (CAP) and calls for a strong reaction from the European Commission to protect the industry’s interests.

These organizations are actively advocating for speedy and decisive action. Eucolait has encouraged EU officials to prioritize diplomatic resolution of the dairy trade problem, highlighting the historical significance of EU-China trade ties. Meanwhile, Copa Cogeca calls for extensive assistance measures to mitigate any adverse effects on European farmers throughout the probe.

Market Impact: Shifting Trade Dynamics 

China has traditionally been a major importer of EU dairy goods. Nonetheless, recent statistics show a significant decrease in these imports owing to increasing local production and a goal for self-sufficiency. This current probe into EU dairy subsidies may accelerate this trend, possibly reshaping global trade patterns.

The inquiry may encourage Chinese purchasers to seek dairy goods from non-EU suppliers, such as New Zealand, which now accounts for 51% of China’s dairy imports. Countries like the United States and other non-EU territories may experience an increase in their export quantities to China.

This investigation might result in a loss of market share for the EU, requiring European dairy farmers to seek new markets or strengthen partnerships with current ones. This transition might influence global supply chains, boosting competitiveness among dairy producers.

On the price front, the study might increase market volatility. Reduced demand from China may result in an excess of dairy products in the EU, putting downward pressure on pricing inside Europe. In contrast, nations that gain from filling the Chinese market vacuum may see price hikes owing to increased demand.

These changes may result in worldwide fluctuations in dairy product pricing for consumers and merchants. Market players must remain adaptable and sensitive to changing trade dynamics to reduce risks and capitalize on new possibilities.

As this inquiry progresses, the global dairy business confronts uncertainty and possible disruption, highlighting the interconnectedness of international commerce and the consequences of governmental choices.

Global Players: Who Stands to Gain or Lose? 

New Zealand and the United States are critical participants in China’s dairy import sector, with shares of 51% and 13%, respectively. With the European Union under examination, these nations may perceive an opportunity to increase their market presence. Could this move usher in a new era for the global dairy trade?

Any interruption in EU dairy imports might increase New Zealand’s export potential. According to Rabobank, China’s milk output will grow by 3.2% in 2024. However, this does not eliminate the demand for imported dairy products, exceptionally high-quality and specialized commodities [Rabobank Report 2024].

The United States, now China’s second-largest dairy exporter, may gain from the EU’s prospective trade restrictions. However, difficulties in trade dynamics, such as extra tariffs, logistical hurdles, and geopolitical conflicts, may impact how much of this market share can be successfully captured.

On the other hand, if channeled to different markets to avoid additional Chinese tariffs, an abundance of dairy goods from the EU might drive down world prices. According to the UK’s Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board (AHDB), China’s drop in powder imports has already impacted global markets [AHDB Report, 2024].

Ultimately, the global dairy trading picture might change dramatically. Nations such as New Zealand and the United States may benefit in the short term. Still, long-term stability will be determined by how international markets respond to these new trade dynamics.

EU’s Stand: Defending the Dairy Sector 

The European Commission has pledged to safeguard its dairy sector and maintain WTO compliance. But how successful will these methods be in combating China’s investigation? The EU’s case is based on establishing that its subsidies under the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) and other national programs conform with international trade regulations. Furthermore, working with Chinese officials is critical to mitigating the damage.

Olof Gill, a Commission spokeswoman, said that the EU would “follow the proceeding very closely” and “intervene as appropriate” to preserve its interests. This aggressive attitude signals a strong defense, but the controversial nature of the investigation and prior trade friction may hamper settlement attempts. The EU intends to negotiate this complicated trade issue by preserving openness and open conversation while avoiding aggravating tensions.

The Bottom Line

This issue is more than simply a commercial conflict; it reflects deeper geopolitical concerns and emphasizes the interconnectedness of global commerce. Actions in one industry, such as electric cars, may have far-reaching consequences in other sectors, such as dairy. It also emphasizes the strategic use of trade instruments as leverage in more significant geopolitical issues and the fundamental need to adhere to international trade laws. As the situation evolves, firms, governments, and analysts must adjust to a world where trade policy plays a critical part in geopolitical strategy, possibly dictating future global trade dynamics.

Learn more:

Join the Revolution!

Bullvine Daily is your essential e-zine for staying ahead in the dairy industry. With over 30,000 subscribers, we bring you the week’s top news, helping you manage tasks efficiently. Stay informed about milk production, tech adoption, and more, so you can concentrate on your dairy operations. 

NewsSubscribe
First
Last
Consent

EU Dairy Farmers Boost Milk Production While Dutch Farmers Face Decline: What This Means for Milk Prices

EU dairy farmers boost milk production, but Dutch farmers see a decline. What does this mean for milk prices and your farm’s future?

Summary: As we delve into the first half of 2024, the landscape of milk production within the European Union reveals a complex mix of growth and decline. Overall, the EU’s dairy farmers have produced 1.0 percent more milk than last year’s last year, with Poland and France leading the charge. Conversely, countries like Ireland and the Netherlands are experiencing notable decreases in milk output, mirroring trends in other global dairy markets such as Argentina and Uruguay. Dutch farmers experienced a 3% drop in milk output in July, and the total milk volume is 1.6% lower over the first seven months of 2024, affecting milk pricing and market dynamics. Meanwhile, European milk prices surged 8 percent in July 2024, reflecting a volatile yet dynamic market environment. This multifaceted scenario prompts us to examine the intricacies behind these regional fluctuations and their broader implications for dairy farmers worldwide. Australia stands out in this global context, with a notable 3% increase in milk production, further influencing market dynamics.

  • EU dairy farmers produced 1.0% more milk in the first half of 2024 compared to 2023.
  • Poland and France significantly contributed to the increase in EU milk production.
  • Ireland and the Netherlands saw notable declines in milk output.
  • Global milk production trends show declines in Argentina, Uruguay, and the US, contrasting with growth in Australia.
  • Dutch milk output decreased by 3% in July and is 1.6% lower over the first seven months of 2024 than last year.
  • European milk prices rose 8% in July 2024, indicating a volatile market environment.
  • The fluctuations in milk production across regions have broader implications for global dairy markets and farmers.
European dairy farmers, milk production, European Union, Poland, France, Dutch farmers, milk output, milk pricing, market dynamics, pricing tactics, export potential, manufacturers, larger market, production, EU dairy output, Ireland, challenges, Netherlands, regional trends, worldwide trends, Australia, milk volume, milk prices, opportunities, profitability, farm management, veterinarian checkups, diet, cow habitats, technology, innovation, feed quality, climate change, grazing conditions, feed sources, agronomists, fodder systems, forage systems, weather patterns, sustain milk production levels.

Why are European dairy farmers increasing output while Dutch farmers are declining? In the first six months of 2024, EU dairy farmers produced 1% more milk than the previous year, with Poland and France leading the growth. In contrast, Dutch farmers face a 3% drop in milk output in July. Understanding these conflicting patterns is critical for anybody working in the dairy business since they directly influence milk pricing and overall market dynamics. This disparity may affect anything from pricing tactics to export potential. Staying ahead requires manufacturers to comprehend the larger market, locally and worldwide, and keep up with their production. So, what is driving these developments, and how can you remain competitive in such a turbulent market?

The Dynamic Landscape of EU Dairy Production: Comparing Growth and Decline 

In the intricate fabric of European Union dairy output, the first half of 2024 has woven a story of moderate but significant rise. The collective efforts of dairy farmers throughout the EU have resulted in a 1% rise in milk production compared to last year, showcasing a region-wide resilience to enhance milk supply despite various local challenges.

Poland has performed remarkably in this trend, contributing significantly to the EU’s total results. In June alone, Polish dairy producers increased output by an astonishing 4%, considerably increasing the EU’s total results. France also played a key role, with its production increasing substantially in June. Germany, a dairy production powerhouse, reported a tiny but encouraging increase compared to June 2023, adding to the total growth.

However, the success story is not universal throughout the continent. Ireland’s dairy industry has faced challenges, with June output falling by 1%. These challenges could be attributed to [specific factors such as weather conditions, feed expenses, or government policies]. Though this reduction is an improvement over prior months’ steeper declines, it contrasts sharply with improvements witnessed in other important dairy-producing countries.

Global Milk Production: A Story of Interconnected Declines and Surprising Growth

Milk production in the Netherlands is declining significantly, mirroring regional and worldwide trends. Dutch dairy producers witnessed a 3% decrease in July compared to the previous year. Over the first seven months of 2024, total milk volume is 1.6 percent lower.

This declining tendency isn’t limited to the Netherlands. Several major dairy-exporting nations throughout the world are facing similar issues. For example, Argentina’s milk production dropped 7% in June, while Uruguay’s plummeted 13%. The United States likewise recorded a 2% reduction in milk output over the same time.

In contrast, Australia is an anomaly, with a 3% increase in milk output, breaking the global declining trend. Such variances illustrate the many variables influencing dairy output across locations, emphasizing the significance of resilience and adaptation in the dairy farming business.

Rising Milk Prices: An Industry in Flux and What It Means for You 

Milk production changes are significantly influencing milk prices across the European Union. The 8% rise in milk prices in July 2024 over the same month in 2023 is strong evidence of this trend. When milk production declines, like in the Netherlands and Ireland, supply tightens, resulting in higher prices. This price rise is also influenced by [specific factors such as market demand or government policies].

Furthermore, the comparison of EDF and ZuivelNL milk pricing demonstrates this tendency. In July, most firms saw a rise in milk prices, with just a handful holding prices steady and one reporting a decrease. This reflects a more significant, industry-wide trend toward higher milk pricing, mainly owing to changing production levels.

Understanding these patterns can help dairy producers negotiate the market more effectively. Are you ready to adjust to the changes? Whether aiming to increase output or save expenses, remaining aware and agile will be critical in these uncertain times.

What’s Behind the Fluctuations in Regional Milk Production?

Have you ever wondered why certain places see a surge in milk production while others lag? When studying these different patterns, several variables come into play. Weather conditions are a crucial factor. Unfavorable weather may disrupt feed supplies and cow health, affecting milk output. On the other hand, favorable weather conditions might increase output rates. Have you recently faced any weather-related issues on your farm?

Feed expenses are also an important consideration. Rising feed costs discourage farmers from retaining big herds, reducing milk yield. Have you seen any swings in feed prices, and how have they impacted your operations?

Government policies also have a huge impact. Regulations governing environmental standards, animal welfare, and trade regulations might result in higher expenses or operational adjustments that may help or impede milk production. Have recent legislative changes in your nation affected your farm?

Market demand plays a pivotal role in shaping manufacturing decisions. Farmers are more likely to optimize productivity when milk prices are high. Conversely, low pricing might inhibit output, leading to reductions. Understanding and adapting to current market demand can empower your manufacturing strategy.

The Intricate Dance of Milk Production Trends: Balancing Opportunities and Challenges 

Dairy producers face both possibilities and problems as milk production patterns shift throughout the EU and worldwide. Higher milk prices, such as the 8% rise in July 2024, may significantly improve a farmer’s bottom line. This price rise offers a cushion to withstand rising manufacturing costs, and promises improved profitability. But remember the other side: sustaining or increasing output levels amidst variable supply is no simple task.

For many farmers, effectively managing their farms is critical to navigating these changes. Given the reported decreases in areas such as the Netherlands and Ireland, the focus should be on improving herd health and milk output. Regular veterinarian checkups, adequate diet, and stress-free cow habitats are essential. Adopting technology to improve herd management may simplify many of these operations.

Consider using data to track cow performance and anticipate any health concerns before they worsen. Automated milking systems, precise feeding methods, and real-time data analytics may all provide significant information. This proactive strategy not only assures consistent output but also improves the general health of your cattle.

Innovation in feed quality should be considered. Climate change impacts grazing conditions and feed quality; thus, diversifying feed sources to include nutrient-dense choices will assist in sustaining milk production levels. Collaborate with agronomists to investigate alternate fodder or forage systems tolerant to shifting weather patterns.

Finally, developing a supportive community around dairy farming is critical. Networking with other farmers via local and regional dairy groups, attending industry conferences, and participating in cooperative ventures may provide emotional and practical assistance. Sharing information and resources contributes to developing a resilient and adaptable agricultural community that meets current and future problems.

Although increasing milk prices provides a glimpse of optimism and possible profit, the route to steady and expanded output requires planning and competent management. Dairy producers can successfully navigate these turbulent seas and secure a sustainable future for their farms by concentrating on herd health, adopting technology, optimizing feed techniques, and developing communities.

The Bottom Line

As we’ve negotiated the changing terrain of EU dairy production, it’s become evident that regional discrepancies are distinctively influencing the business. The extreme disparities between nations such as Poland, which is increasing, and the Netherlands, which is declining, underscore the global dairy market’s complexity and interdependence. Furthermore, although some areas are suffering a slump, others, such as Australia, are seeing growth that defies global trends. European milk prices have risen during these developments, creating both possibilities and problems for dairy producers.

Today’s challenge is adjusting to the dairy industry’s altering trends. Staying informed and active with industry changes is critical for navigating this volatile market. As trends shift, your ability to adapt proactively will decide your success. Maintain industry awareness, embrace change, and prosper in uncertainty.

Learn more:

June 2024 Brings Unprecedented Milk Prices: European Dairy Farmers Reap the Benefits

Find out why European dairy farmers are thrilled about record-high milk prices in June 2024. How will this affect their farm’s earnings? Read more.

Summary: European dairy farmers are seeing record-high milk prices in June 2024, largely due to increased valuations of fat and protein in milk. This price spike provides a boost to the industry, yet variations in milk supply growth across different regions present unique challenges and opportunities. Continuous monitoring of these trends will be vital for understanding their broader impact on the dairy sector.

  • Average milk price in Europe reached 44.73 euros per 100 kg in June 2024, the year’s highest.
  • The increased milk price is primarily due to the higher valuation of fat and protein in the milk.
  • Milk prices have remained stable, fluctuating around 44 euros per 100 kg since January 2024.
  • Milk supply in Europe grew by 0.8% in May 2024, with Poland leading the growth at 4%.
  • Germany also saw an increase in milk supply, while Ireland experienced a smaller decrease.
  • Contrarily, milk production in the Netherlands fell by more than 2% in June 2024, with a 1.4% decrease in the first half of the year compared to 2023.

European dairy farmers are rejoicing as milk prices in June 2024 hit an all-time high with an average price of 44.73 euros per 100 kg of milk, marking the highest price recorded this year. The increase, attributed to higher valuations of fat and protein content, saw a rise of 0.65 cents since the beginning of the year and reflects unparalleled stability in milk prices.

The average milk price saw an increase of 0.65 cents from the previous month. Compared to June 2023, the current price is now 2.34 euros higher, according to the milk price comparison by EDF and DairyNL. This rise in prices is a significant boost for dairy farmers across Europe.

The stability of European milk prices has been notable this year. Dairy enterprises started 2024 with a milk price of 43.64 euros per 100 kg of milk. Since then, prices have hovered around 44 euros per 100 kg. The increase in milk prices is primarily due to the higher appreciation of fat and protein content in the milk. However, French and Spanish dairies have kept their prices stable or have seen slight decreases.

Poland continues to lead in milk supply growth, with a 4% increase in May. German dairy farmers have also increased their milk supply. In contrast, Ireland’s milk supply has been lagging, although the decline has been less severe in recent months. Overall, the total milk supply in Europe increased by 1.1% in the first five months of 2024.

The Netherlands presents a different picture, with a decrease in milk supply accelerating slightly. In June, the country saw a decline of more than 2%. For the first half of the year, the Netherlands produced 1.4% less milk compared to the same period last year.

The record-high milk prices in June 2024 bring a wave of optimism for European dairy farmers. The increase in prices, driven by higher fat and protein valuations, offers a much-needed boost to the industry. However, regional disparities in milk supply growth highlight the varying challenges and opportunities across Europe. As the year progresses, it will be crucial to monitor these trends and their impact on the dairy sector.

Learn more: 

European Dairy Farmers Parade Plaster Cows in Brussels Protest for Fair Milk Prices

European dairy farmers parade plaster cows in Brussels. Curious about their demand for fair milk prices? Discover the story behind this unique protest.

In the heart of Europe, an unusual spectacle recently unfolded that neither tourists nor residents could ignore. Clad in overalls and high-visibility vests, European dairy farmers converged on Brussels, pushing life-sized plaster cows along the cobblestone streets. These farmers were not staging a quirky festival but making a powerful statement that rippled far beyond Belgium’s borders. 

The parade of plaster cows through the European Union’s de facto capital was a symbolic and literal push for recognition. Dairy farmers from the lush pastures of France to the expansive dairy farms of Germany, and from other corners of Europe, marched, united by a shared frustration. Their demand is both simple and profound: fair prices for their milk. This straightforward request masks a deeply entrenched economic struggle. For years, farmers have faced volatile milk prices influenced by global markets, subsidies, and trade policies, stripping them of financial stability and driving many to the brink of insolvency. 

“We’re not just fighting for our livelihoods; we’re fighting for the future of sustainable farming and food security,” one farmer declared amidst the bustling protest. 

For dairy farmers, fair pricing is not merely about securing a decent wage; it is about maintaining traditions and nurturing rural communities. It is linked to food quality, safety, and affordability for consumers. If dairy farming collapses under unfair pricing, the ripple effects will extend far beyond the cobblestone streets of Brussels. Higher prices, lower quality, and reliance on imports could disrupt a cherished way of life, threatening the very fabric of European agriculture. 

Thus, this protest was not just a desperate plea but a resounding call underscoring the vital interdependence between those who produce our food and those who consume it. The fight for fair milk prices is not just for the sustainability of farms, but for the very future of our food systems, casting a long shadow over future generations if left unresolved.

The Heart of the Protest: Why European Dairy Farmers Are Marching

On a brisk morning in Brussels, cobblestone streets echoed with the determined steps of dairy farmers demanding “fair” milk prices. This protest springs from years of economic strain. From France’s verdant pastures to Germany’s extensive dairy farms, European dairy farmers unite under one banner: fair compensation for their labor. 

The glaring gap between the retail price of milk and what farmers actually receive is at the crux of their grievances. While consumers pay a premium for dairy products, farmers earn only a fraction of these profits. This imbalance threatens countless farms, pushing them toward financial collapse. 

Organized by the European Milk Board, the demonstration gathered farmers from over 15 countries, aiming for attention and action. As placards declaring “Fair income for farmers now” waved, their frustration was evident. They demand policies for stable, fair pricing and greater market transparency. These changes, if implemented, could not only save countless farms from financial ruin but also ensure a sustainable future for European agriculture. 

Protesters are eager to dialogue with political figures, including European Agriculture Commissioner Janusz Wojciechowski, believing these discussions can lead to reforms. With the European elections on the horizon, farmers seek to shape agricultural policy to reflect their needs and challenges.

Historical Context: Previous Protests and Their Outcomes

The roots of dairy farmers’ protests in Europe trace back decades, highlighting persistent tensions between agricultural producers and market regulators. Historically, these protests have emerged due to price depressions, subsidy cuts, and changes in EU agrarian policies. In 2009, thousands of farmers stormed Brussels to protest plummeting milk prices, dramatically pouring milk onto streets and setting hay bales ablaze to draw attention to their plight. 

Similarly, in 2015, dairy farmers protested against the abolition of milk quotas, a system in place since 1984 to regulate production and stabilize prices. The removal of the quota led to oversupply and subsequent price drops, prompting farmers to dump milk and distribute it for free, symbolizing their frustration and the futility of their labor under new regulations. 

Despite these dramatic protests, the outcomes have varied. Some resulted in temporary price support and emergency funds, yet many farmers feel these measures must be revised. The core issues—structural imbalances and the market power of large retailers—remain unresolved, leading to ongoing unrest among Europe’s dairy farming community

The current protests revive these historical grievances, pressing EU institutions for more effective and equitable policies. The use of plaster cows in the protests symbolizes the farmers’ demand for visibility and acknowledgment. As these symbolic cows parade through Brussels, they call for lasting and substantive change.

Voices from the Ground: Stories of Farmers and Their Struggles

The tales of struggle from these farmers are as varied as their countries, yet they all share a common plea for fairness and sustainability. Carlos, from Spain, shares how his farm shrank from over a hundred cows to struggling with fifty. “When I took over from my father, we had over a hundred cows. Now, we struggle to keep fifty,” he laments, his frustration evident. The gap between production costs and milk prices has driven many to bankruptcy. 

Julia, from Germany, highlights the emotional toll. “My children don’t want to take over the farm because they have seen us struggle. It’s heartbreaking because this is more than a business; it’s our heritage,” she explains. These shared experiences underscore a broader crisis in European agriculture. Farmers across Europe grapple with a market that often values their milk less than water. 

The stories also underscore the physical and mental exhaustion from long hours, increasing paperwork, and EU regulations. Yet, amidst this turmoil, there is an unwavering resilience and a steadfast hope. The Brussels demonstration signifies not just a cry for help but a belief in the power of collective action. Their stories are not just pleas for change but powerful calls for systemic change, resonating far beyond their farms.

Economic Impact: How Milk Prices Affect Farmers

Fluctuating milk prices in the global market have long been a cause of anxiety for dairy farmers, significantly impacting their livelihood. At its core, the economic distress is rooted in the gap between the cost of production and the market price that farmers receive for their milk. This disparity often leaves farmers struggling to cover basic operational costs, let alone generate any meaningful profit. 

The cost of production encompasses a wide range of expenses, including feed, equipment maintenance, veterinary services, and labor. As these costs continue to rise, the market prices for milk have not kept pace, often due to the imbalance of power in the supply chain. Large retailers and processors wield significant influence, driving down prices and squeezing margins for producers. This inequity is exacerbated by international trade policies and market fluctuations, which frequently disadvantage local farmers. 

The situation is particularly dire for smaller farms, which need more economies of scale to absorb financial shocks. Many are forced to operate at a loss or close down altogether, reducing rural employment and dissolving generations-old family businesses. Thus, the social fabric of rural communities, which traditionally revolves around farming, is further frayed. 

Moreover, the pressures of unsustainable milk prices can lead to a vicious cycle of debt. Farmers might take out loans to stay afloat, inadvertently placing themselves in precarious financial positions. This cycle often culminates in a distressing choice between maintaining their farms or selling them off to more giant agricultural conglomerates, exacerbating the problem of agrarian consolidation and loss of local farm ownership. 

In essence, without intervention and fair pricing structures, the economic viability of dairy farming in Europe remains in jeopardy. The current protests underscore the urgent need for systemic solutions to ensure that farmers can achieve a fair income, safeguarding the future of European dairy farming. —

Fluctuating milk prices globally have severely impacted farmers’ livelihoods. The core issue is the gap between production and market prices, leaving farmers barely covering operational costs

Expenses like feed, maintenance, and labor are rising. Still, milk prices don’t need to be kept up, mainly due to imbalances in the supply chain. Major retailers and processors depress prices, squeezing farmers’ margins further burdened by international trade policies. 

This is particularly harsh on smaller farms, which lack the scale to absorb shocks. Many operate at a loss or close down, eroding rural employment and family businesses

Farmers often resort to loans, creating a debt cycle that forces them to sell to more giant conglomerates, worsening agricultural consolidation. 

Protests highlight the need for fair pricing to ensure the economic viability of European dairy farming.

Political Response: How Governments Are Reacting

The dairy farmers’ protest has elicited a spectrum of reactions from European governments. Politicians are pressured to align with the farmers’ cause as European elections approach. This issue demands a continent-wide response from the EU. 

EU agriculture ministers, gathering in Brussels, have stressed the need for swift action to stabilize milk prices and guarantee fair compensation for farmers. Their urgency reflects the escalating tension in the agricultural sector. 

Slovenian Prime Minister Tanja Fajon has emphasized fair agricultural policies while also engaging in significant foreign policy moves, such as recognizing the State of Palestine. This dual focus underscores the interconnected nature of EU socio-economic and political issues. 

Despite these efforts, a cohesive EU response is vital amid geopolitical tensions like the EU’s stance on Gaza. Solidarity among member states is crucial, with farmers’ calls for fair income echoing broader themes of equity and justice that the EU must address. 

While some governments have shown support for agriculture, others remain neutral and cautious of resource-intensive changes. Yet, the looming European elections and social movements like #VoteThemAway emphasize the urgency of concrete governmental action.

Public Support: How the Community Is Rallying Around Farmers

The public support for the dairy farmers has been remarkable. This solidarity is felt in Brussels and across Europe, where communities have taken to the streets, social media, and local town halls. Urban and rural residents recognize the critical role farmers play. They are increasingly aware of the economic pressures on the agricultural sector. Initiatives like the hashtag #FairIncomeForFarmersNow have amplified the protest’s visibility. 

Grassroots organizations have swiftly mobilized, organizing fundraisers and awareness campaigns. From school children creating posters to local businesses offering financial support, the collective action underscores a shared understanding of the dairy farmers’ plight. Many restaurants and cafes have also pledged to source milk locally, demonstrating a tangible commitment. 

Prominent public figures have added significant weight to the movement. Influential voices from entertainment, sports, and academia have urged policymakers to heed the farmers’ demands. This alliance has created a powerful narrative, resonating deeply with a broad demographic and transcending boundaries. 

Media coverage has shifted, with news outlets and independent journalists providing in-depth analyses of the dairy industry’s structural challenges. This has fostered a more informed and empathetic public discourse, dispelling stereotypes and highlighting legitimate economic issues. 

The protest has ignited a crucial conversation about sustainability and fairness within the food supply chain. As the movement gains momentum, it aims for immediate economic relief and long-term structural reforms in the agricultural sector. The rallying cry for fair milk prices is evolving into a broader struggle for equitable food systems and justice for those who nourish the continent.

A Day in Brussels: Inside the Parade of Plaster Cows

As dawn broke over Brussels, an extraordinary scene took over the streets: life-sized plaster cows, painted in vibrant national colors, being wheeled through the city. These weren’t mere artworks; they symbolized the united front of European dairy farmers demanding fair milk prices. 

Organized by the European Milk Board, the event saw farmers from over 15 countries standing together. Each plaster cow signified national identity and a shared struggle against unsustainable income. The determined faces of farmers, some having traveled long distances, spoke volumes. 

The rallying cry echoed through the streets, “Fair income for farmers now.” Passersby captured the moment, their support evident. The atmosphere, charged with energy, remained peaceful. Police, while present, were unobtrusive, gently guiding people and advising public transport to avoid congestion. 

A significant moment occurred when farmers engaged with European Agriculture Commissioner Janusz Wojciechowski. This dialogue highlighted the direct impact of policy on farmers’ lives, underscoring their push for fair pricing and sustainable farming practices as the European elections approached. 

The parade of plaster cows was more than symbolic—it was a powerful call for justice, unity, and a sustainable future for Europe’s dairy farmers.

Europe-Wide Movement: Similar Protests in Other Countries

Across Europe, the effects of the Brussels protest have emerged in various forms, reflecting the urgency and passion displayed at the heart of the EU. In France, dairy farmers rallied in Paris, with tractors carrying slogans for equitable milk prices. The Champs-Élysées became a stage for solidarity among farmers against economic disparities. 

In Germany, symbolic mini-protests took place in cities like Munich and Berlin. The plaster cows, painted in national colors, drew public attention to dairy producers’ challenges, highlighting shared struggles and the collective demand for change. 

Spain and Italy also saw significant activism. Spanish farmers stormed Madrid, stressing the severe impact of low milk prices on their livelihoods. Italian farmers staged creative dairy-themed flash mobs in substantial cities, resonating with younger demographics and keeping the issue alive on social media. 

These coordinated efforts reveal a Europe-wide sentiment, pointing to a systemic issue transcending national boundaries. The urgency has prompted EU agriculture ministers to meet in Brussels as farmers’ voices call for policy reforms to address milk pricing disparities. As these protests echo across the continent, a more unified EU response to agricultural policy remains a key discussion point.

The Bottom Line

The parade of plaster cows through Brussels is a vivid emblem of European dairy farmers’ plight. Wheeling these life-sized figures through the city’s streets, they demand fair milk prices, spotlighting the severe economic pressures they face. This protest emphasizes the urgent need for reforms to ensure the dairy industry’s sustainability. 

Consumers play a pivotal role by advocating for and buying moderately priced milk. Our collective action can help create a just, sustainable food system, amplifying farmers’ voices and ensuring their demands resonate far beyond Brussels. 

Support for dairy farmers’ rights is essential. Backing fair pricing policies and acknowledging farmers’ hard work can drive meaningful change. While the plaster cows may be stored away, the pursuit of fairness must persist.

Key Takeaways:

  • Fair Milk Prices: Farmers are demanding stable and fair milk prices to ensure sustainable livelihoods and prevent financial collapse of small and medium-sized farms.
  • Economic Disparities: The gap between retail milk prices and what farmers actually earn is a crucial issue, with many farmers receiving only a fraction of the retail price.
  • Political Engagement: Demonstrators are eager to engage with European political figures, including Agriculture Commissioner Janusz Wojciechowski, to advocate for reforms that address their grievances.
  • Historical Grievances: The roots of these protests hark back to 2009, highlighting a long-standing issue of price volatility and inadequate support for dairy farmers.
  • Pan-European Solidarity: Farmers from over 15 countries have united in this demonstration, emphasizing the widespread nature of the problem across Europe.


Summary: European dairy farmers are protesting for fair milk prices in Brussels, highlighting their struggle against volatile prices influenced by global markets, subsidies, and trade policies. The gap between retail milk prices and farmers’ actual earnings is a major issue, as farmers earn only a fraction of the profits, which threatens countless farms and pushes them towards financial collapse. The demonstration, which gathered farmers from over 15 countries, demands policies for stable, fair pricing and greater market transparency to save farms from financial ruin and ensure a sustainable future for European agriculture. Protesters are eager to engage with political figures, including European Agriculture Commissioner Janusz Wojciechowski, to lead to reforms. The roots of dairy farmers’ protests in Europe trace back to 2009, when thousands stormed Brussels to protest plummeting milk prices. The current protests aim to revive historical grievances and press EU institutions for more effective and equitable policies.

Bram Prins – The Global Dairy Business Mentality

Bram Prins picEvery dairy family builds their agricultural legacy over time.  For Bram Prins it started in the Netherlands over forty years ago. “In 1968 our family decided to move to county Groningen. As the oldest of seven children I worked with my father to start farming 54 ha of arable land where we had 100 cows. “  

This is the early motivation that first inspired Bram Prins to look to agriculture as a career.  However, three decades later he is still passionate about dairy farming and more importantly how it can continue to grow and be profitable.  On February 5th he will share his enthusiasm, experience and insights as a keynote speaker at the 2nd Annual Canadian Dairy Xpo in Stratford Ontario.  If you’re looking for a “day off” this is the exact place to get recharged and revitalized for the year ahead. Building on the resounding success of last year’s inaugural event, Canadian Dairy Xpo 2014 organizers have put together a tremendous diversity of products, experts and entertainment in one place at one time (Check out the full Canadian Dairy Expo program).

Bram Prins: Lifelong Learning and Worldwide Classroom

Despite his early involvement on the Groningen farm, Prins, now sixty-two, doesn’t consider himself to have an agricultural background.  However he provides further explanation. “I do not have an agricultural background, but as farmer I do have a wide scope of interests.” This compelled him to lifelong formal and informal expansion of his studies.  “Until last year I undertook training every year and earned minors and training at Nyenrode Businesss School.” A further source of agricultural edification came through many years of involvement with agricultural interest groups. “From 1985 till 2002 I was member of different boards, mainly feed and milk, in the agricultural sector.”

Prins Consulting

From this growing background Bram was prepared to set up a business group. “In 1990 I was the founder of European Dairy Farmers and in this position I travelled a lot around Europe and collected different data, information and knowledge.”

Twelve years later, Bram decided to leave as President of EDF and started working for Wageningen University.  “I began by developing and giving training in a team of Entrepreneurship.” Since that time, he has given trainings in more than 6 different European countries in Interactive Strategic Management.” His interest in problem solving kept him busy too. “I worked also as advisor for individual farms in special topics including mediation, succession and financial management.” His growing expertise became sought out and he has expanded outside the private sector.  “More and more my work includes governments in supporting or coaching farmers in special situations such as outplacement, solving difficult situations etcetera.”

Global Dairy Farmers

In 2005, this intense building of expertise was the foundation for Bram to start Global Dairy Farmers http://www.globaldairyfarmers.com. In 2004 he was joined by another colleague and started one year later GDF  In 2009 Elise Bregman started working for Bram and  became Manager of GDF. Prins is financially responsible for 100% of the company.” Bram is enthusiastic about the need for a business such as the one in inaugurated with Global Dairy Farmers.  Here is someone who is unique in being eager to work on the problems faced by the dairy industry. “I am always looking for solutions to impossible situations and building relationships based on trust.” Bram outlines the core values of GBF. “We are focused on Global Dairy Farmers, rural development and entrepreneurship.” He points out the international growth that has taken place. “This has led to coaching farmers both inside and outside the Netherlands.”

Facing Challenges. Feeding the World.

The challenges faced by dairy producers have a special place in the heart of the President of GDF. Bram sees feeding the world as the number one challenge facing the dairy industry. At the same time, the industry itself is facing globalization. This raises the reality that today milk prices are becoming more equal worldwide. Dairy producers need to become excellent managers. After that, the biggest challenge facing the industry is the one of fulfilling the wishes of the consumer. The producers must accept and deliver what the consumer values.

Think Like An Entrepreneur

As Prins watches the changes that take place internationally, he is especially convinced that dairy producers must think more like entrepreneurs.  Worldwide the influence of farmers as a political group is declining.  The industry must face the reality that there is much less financial support from governments. Having said that he recognizes that farm business operation is evolving. “In some places dairy farming is just like normal business already. Especially in the new upcoming milk regions where backward integration is usual already.”  Prins sees further globalization of milk production including, “in the long run in Canada.”

Bram Prins has 3 children and 14 grand children

Bram Prins has 3 children and 14 grand children

The Future Marketplace

Bram’s global perspective sees new ways that will differentiate dairy producers since eventually it will no longer be by price only.  He sees that culture, climate and growing conditions will have an impact on competitiveness in the dairy marketplace.  Infrastructure will be of prime importance to the sustainability of the dairy industry of the future.

Best Advice for 21st Century Dairy Producer

Prins encourages dairy producers to think big and see the total picture.  “You must look beyond the farm gate and be aware of what is happening worldwide in dairying and in other agricultural sectors too.”  Bram has personally observed, trained and advised dairy stakeholders on the necessity of being market oriented, thinking value-added and dealing with price fluctuations. “If you look at the increasing influence of the market, I believe the next major challenge will be the creation of added value; in my eyes, the step towards sub-flows within dairy production is a logical next step.”

Always Pro-Actively Moving with the Changing Times

When confronted with the issue of globalization, many of us sit back and stress out asking “How bad are things going to be?” Bram Prins urges the dairy sector to pay attention to three evolving areas. “Dairy producers must address the issues relating to sustainability, animal welfare and pro-active communication. “The latter issue especially causes Prins to urge “It is a necessity to build bridges between producers and consumers.” Unfortunately, another of the trends of the industry one that Bram points out.”There is a lack of farmers and qualified labor.”  While this is a reality, he also sees the potential solution. “We will see growth of the size of our farms with the help of automation.”  Expanding further on this side Prins also sees it applied directly to cow management. “We are coming to a cow approach based on ICT in the growing herds.”

The Bullvine Bottom Line

Bram Prins is a dairy industry futurist and is dedicated to serving the dairy sector and looking for innovations, trends and new farm systems. Global Dairy Farmers is committed to identifying problems and finding solutions through discussion, research, projects and strategic studies. Bram Prins recognizes that “Developing future scenarios is one thing: implementing them is another matter.”  Bram hopes to share and inspire a value-added vision of the dairy industry on Thursday, February 6th at Canadian Dairy Xpo 2014 where he will speak on the creation of Global Dairy Farmers and the top 4 insider global dairy trends that every producer needs to know. “It’s the perfect place to get leading edge feedback and encouragement about dairy perspective in the 21st Century and the challenges and opportunities that await us. Be inspired by Bram Prins at the Maizex Dairy Classroom and you could go home from your “day off” with a solution that’s “right on!”

Want to learn more about the top 5 insider global dairy trends? Bram will be presenting at Canadian Dairy Expo on February 6th.

Send this to a friend