Archive for Dairy Cattle Genetics

From Show Ring to Genomic Legacy: The Transformative Impact of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada on Holstein Breeding

How one unassuming cow born in rural Ontario revolutionized Holstein genetics worldwide, bridging show ring glamour with genomic science.

Do you know what amazes me about the dairy world? How a single cow can change everything. That’s exactly what Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada did. Born in 1986, this remarkable cow didn’t just win ribbons—she created an entire dynasty that’s still shaping Holstein genetics worldwide. I’ve always been fascinated by how one exceptional animal can transform an entire breed’s trajectory. Ada’s story perfectly exemplifies this—bridging old-school showring excellence with today’s cutting-edge genomics.

Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada (1986-?): The legendary Holstein matriarch whose exceptional conformation earned her Unanimous All-American Senior Three-Year-Old honors in 1990, but whose true legacy lives on through her daughters Alicia and Adeen, whose descendants continue to revolutionize Holstein genetics worldwide. Her remarkable balance of show ring excellence and genetic prepotency bridged the divide between type and production, establishing a dynasty that remains influential in modern genomic breeding. Photo: Maggie Murphy
Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada: The legendary Holstein matriarch whose exceptional conformation earned her Unanimous All-American Senior Three-Year-Old honors in 1990, but whose true legacy lives on through her daughters Alicia and Adeen, whose descendants continue to revolutionize Holstein genetics worldwide. Her remarkable balance of show ring excellence and genetic prepotency bridged the divide between type and production, establishing a dynasty that remains influential in modern genomic breeding. Photo: Maggie Murphy

The Holstein Landscape of the Mid-1980s

The 1980s were a weird time for dairy breeding. Remember that period everyone calls “The Great Divide Between Type and Production”? The industry was at this fascinating crossroads. Since the mid-60s, all this genetic evaluation data had been pouring in, especially for milk output and fat content. Meanwhile, AI organizations were pushing young sire sampling programs.

This created this massive philosophical split. You had your traditional display herds stubbornly focused on type traits—making sure their cows looked gorgeous in the showring. Then you had these forward-thinking farmer-breeders embracing genetic indexes and production metrics. Two completely different approaches to breeding! Honestly, the type-focused herds were gradually losing influence as those production-oriented operations started showing better economic returns.

Ada walked into this changing landscape where the pendulum was swinging away from pure conformation toward a more balanced approach. The industry analysts noted how “leadership in genetic improvement started to shift from breeds and prominent herds to artificial insemination organizations.” Little did anyone know that Ada’s descendants would eventually bridge these competing priorities through their incredible dual excellence in type and production.

The Birth of a Legend

So here’s where it all begins. September 13, 1986—Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada is born at the Aitkenbrae farm in Holstein, Ontario. Her pedigree? A fascinating combination: sired by the legendary Hanoverhill Starbuck out of Aikenbrae Sheik Arlene (Good Plus-80-2YR-CAN). This genetic cocktail would prove transformative for the Holstein breed.

But Ada’s story starts much earlier. Her lineage traces back to the 1940s with Banostine Dutchland Clothilde, who set a world fat record as a senior two-year-old in 1948 with 623 pounds of fat from 16,272 pounds of 3.8% milk. Tom Hayden, who established the Banella prefix (combining names from his foundation cows Banostine and Ella), bred Banostine to Spring Farm Sovereign Supreme. The resulting heifer, Banella Sovereign Supreme Delight, was disappointingly poor—so much so that Hayden sold her cheaply to his friend Cecil Barber.

Barber, however, saw potential in Delight and bred her to Lifloc Re-Echo Voyageur, producing Sheila Voyageur. When bred to Pabst Walker Ollie, Sheila produced C-Bar Ollie Belle, born May 1, 1959. In the mid-1960s, Walter Aitken, looking to improve his herd, purchased the five-year-old Ollie Belle through cattle dealer Bill Sniveley.

Aitkenbrae Farm wasn’t just any dairy operation. It was run by the partnership of Morley Aitken and Don Lantz, who started working together in 1978. They developed a superior herd under the Aitkenbrae prefix, regularly winning Premier Breeder and Exhibitor banners at Grey County Black & White Day. Their breeding expertise earned them two Master Breeder shields, a prestigious recognition in the Holstein world.

Don Lantz’s connection to the farm began in childhood. When his father died in 1962, Don was just six years old, and his uncle Walter Aitken took him under his wing. Don spent his weekends and summer holidays at Aitkenbrae Farm, developing a deep love for farming and Holstein cattle. This attachment lasted through his youth, and when he came of age, Don went straight to his uncle for his first job. When Walter retired, he was farming in partnership with his son Morley, and recognizing Don’s talent and work ethic, Walter offered to sell his nephew his share of the business.

Despite Ollie Belle’s apparent lack of maternal instinct (her first two calves at Aitkens died at birth), one daughter did survive—Aitkenbrae Radar Olive. Through several generations of strategic breeding, this line eventually produced Aitkenbrae Sheik Arlene, who bred to Hanoverhill Starbuck and gave birth to Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada on September 13, 1986.

When Ada calved in 1988, Brian Carscadden, first noticed something special about her. At the time, he was working as a fitter and attending school but also wheeling and dealing with cattle. He and Ken Empey were regulars at the Aitkenbrae barn, having bought animals from them before. As Lantz recalled, “When Ada calved in 1988, Brian Carscadden was first to notice her. He was wheeling and dealing in cattle while fitting and attending school. He and Ken Empey were always in and out of Aitkenbrae. Aitkenbrae had sold cattle to both. There was some consultation between Carscadden and Empey about Ada. Empey ended up buying her.

Don Lantz had this practical philosophy about their breeding program: “Morley and I were always willing to let a good one go. We were trying to cash flow with a 50-cow herd and realized that for a cow to get a full opportunity, she would need to get out of here, into the hands of a good promoter.”

The Early Career: From Ontario to the American Show Ring

After Ken Empey purchased Ada, her journey was just beginning. An Ohio investment group, Hygerian Associates, including Robert Binger and William Atkins, was looking to invest in Holsteins. They contacted Empey, who took them to see Ada when she was two months fresh and looking fantastic. They bought the heifer and took her to Ohio, where she completed her impressive two-year-old record: 25,000 pounds of milk with 908 pounds of fat at 3.6% and 798 pounds of protein at 3.2%.

During this lactation, Binger and Atkins and a new partner named Lawson Bennett took Ada to the Michigan State Fair in the summer of 1989. There, she won the senior two-year-old class and was named grand champion. Her next stop was Madison, where, with Howard Binder judging, she 2nd and later moved to third after the milk out behind Dupasquier Stab Winnie and Comestar Laurie Sheik.

At Madison, Ada caught the attention of Douglas King of Kingstead Farms in Damascus, Maryland, and Grey Wilcom of Ijamsville, Maryland. King initially considered Ada “a little on the small side but very correct.” He was impressed enough that he and Wilcom approached Hygerian to buy her, which they did in December 1989.

Under King and Wilcom’s ownership, Ada grew taller and was prepared for the 1990 show season. This would prove to be her breakout year. She won the three-year-old class and was named Supreme Champion at the Eastern National Show. She continued her winning streak by placing first with the best udder in class at Madison. These impressive showings culminated in her being named the Unanimous All-American Senior Three-Year-Old of 1990.

The Shore Connection: Strategic Breeding Decisions

At the close of the 1990 show season, Hardy Shore, Jr., principal of Shoremar, Inc., purchased a half-interest in Ada. Shore had previously worked as a hoof trimmer and was particularly impressed by Ada’s feet and legs. He described her as the best “footed” cow he had ever seen. This appreciation for functional conformation would influence his breeding decisions with Ada.

When the Shoremar herd was dispersed in 1991, Ada sold for $71,000—the sale’s second-highest price—returning to the ownership of Kingstead and Wilcom, who dissolved their partnership with Shore.

During his ownership period, Shore made a critical breeding decision that would shape Holstein history. He flushed Ada to several bulls, including Donnandale Skychief (EX-Extra). Shore admired Skychief but recognized that the bull needed improvement in feet, an area where Ada excelled. This strategic pairing would produce the daughters establishing Ada’s legacy as a brood cow.

Charlie McEvoy, a respected figure in the dairy industry with decades of experience, singles out Ada as “one of my favorite young cows of all time.” He emphasizes her lasting importance, noting, “Her descendants, whether male or female, have changed our barns and show strings forever.” This endorsement from an industry veteran underscores the significance of Ada beyond her accomplishments.

The Skychief Sisters: Building the Ada Empire

The flush to Donnandale Skychief produced two daughters who would become legends in their own right: Shoremar S Alicia and MS Kingstead Chief Adeen.

Shoremar S Alicia EX-97 3E 7*: Daughter of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada and one of only 35 registered Holsteins in North America to achieve the coveted Excellent-97 classification. This remarkable cow was nominated All-American five times, crowned Supreme Champion at the 2000 Royal Winter Fair, and established herself as an exceptional brood cow with more than a dozen Excellent daughters. Her legacy continues through descendants that dominate show rings and breeding programs worldwide. Photo: Maggie Murphy
Shoremar S Alicia EX-97 3E 7*: Daughter of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada and one of only 35 registered Holsteins in North America to achieve the coveted Excellent-97 classification. This remarkable cow was nominated All-American five times, crowned Supreme Champion at the 2000 Royal Winter Fair, and established herself as an exceptional brood cow with more than a dozen Excellent daughters. Her legacy continues through descendants that dominate show rings and breeding programs worldwide. Photo: Maggie Murphy

All-American Alicia: Extending Excellence

Shoremar S Alicia, born in 1995, elevated the family’s status to unprecedented heights. Classified Excellent-97, Alicia joined an elite group of only 35 registered Holsteins in North America to achieve this near-perfect score. Her show career eclipsed even her dam’s impressive record, as she was nominated All-American five times in milking form and crowned Supreme Champion of the Royal Winter Fair in 2000.

The story of how Alicia came to be involves another key figure in Holstein breeding. David Innes of the City-View herd at Woodstock, Ontario, met Hardy Shore at a show and inquired about buying embryos. Ada had just produced a great flush to Skychief, so a deal was made for two embryos. The two resulting calves were jointly owned by Shore and Innes, one of them being Shoremar Alicia, who would become a World Champion.

Under the ownership of Jeff Butler, Howard Binder, and Kingstead, Alicia topped the five-year-old class at Madison and won the grand championship at the Royal Winter Fair in 2000. These accomplishments made her the unanimous choice for All-American and All-Canadian 5-year-old that year. After winning the 125,000-lb. cow class and the grand championship at the Eastern National Show in 2003, she was voted All-American aged cow. She continued her show ring success with a Reserve All-American nomination in 2004 and High Honorable Mention in 2005.

Beyond her show ring dominance, Alicia firmly established herself as a brood cow in her own right. With more than a dozen Excellent daughters from various sires, she continued Ada’s pattern of reliably transmitting elite type. Her influence branched primarily through her Startmore Rudolph daughter, Cityview R Alicia (Excellent-92-CAN 23*), and her Durham daughters BKB Abby (Excellent-95 3E DOM) and BKB Amanda (Excellent-92 GMD DOM).

MS Kingstead Chief Adeen EX-94 2E DOM (1997-2011): The extraordinary daughter of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada who left an indelible mark on Holstein breeding with 51 Excellent daughters worldwide—ranking her second all-time for most EX offspring. This influential matriarch established a genetic dynasty through sons including Atwood, Atlantic, and Aftershock, while demonstrating the rare ability to transmit both superior type and genomic excellence across generations. Her profound impact continues through descendants winning championships globally, cementing her legacy as one of the most consequential brood cows in modern Holstein history. Photo: Cybil Fisher
MS Kingstead Chief Adeen EX-94 2E DOM (1997-2011): The extraordinary daughter of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada who left an indelible mark on Holstein breeding with 51 Excellent daughters worldwide—ranking her second all-time for most EX offspring. This influential matriarch established a genetic dynasty through sons including Atwood, Atlantic, and Aftershock, while demonstrating the rare ability to transmit both superior type and genomic excellence across generations. Her profound impact continues through descendants winning championships globally, cementing her legacy as one of the most consequential brood cows in modern Holstein history. Photo: Cybil Fisher

All-American Adeen: Expanding the Influence

The second Skychief daughter, MS Kingstead Chief Adeen, born in 1997, proved equally influential but through different channels. Described as a “foundation cow for several herds,” Adeen established connections to names that would become Holstein royalty: Atwood, Atlee, Ariel, and Autumn.

Adeen’s story takes an interesting turn. In 1997, Kingstead sold their herd to three Maryland breeders. By the flip of a coin, one of the buyers, Cranberry Meadows Farm, owned by Gary and Crystal Dell of Westminster, acquired the two-week-old Chief Adeen. When the time came, she was flushed to Maughlin Storm, resulting in five heifers that all classified Very Good as two-year-olds. One of these was MD-Delight Storm Amberlee-ET, who would play a crucial role in extending the family’s influence.

Adeen was later sold as a two-year-old to a syndicate of Billy and Mike Heath, Gerald Todd, and Amlaird Callum McKinven. During the six months she was in their ownership, she was flushed successfully to Comestar Lee. The star of this flush was Amlaird Lee Alice, the first Junior 2-year-old at the World Dairy Expo in 2003 and named All-American.

In 2000, the Shoremar S Alicia and MS Kingstead Chief Adeen duo reached their pinnacle in the show ring. They were the unanimous choice for All-American Produce of Dam. Chief Adeen was nominated All-American as a junior 3-year-old in 2000 for Jeff Butler and Lance and Amy Ruppert, producing over 30,000 pounds of 4% milk that year.

Adeen then sold to Jeff Butler, Lance, and Amy Ruppert. At the World Dairy Expo 2000, Adeen stood 6th in the Junior-3 class and paired with her older sister Alicia to win the Produce of Dam class. Shortly afterward, Kingstead bought out Ruppert’s share, and from that time onwards, all progeny were registered with the BVK prefix for Butlerview and Kingstead.

Jeff Butler of Butlerview Farms, who owned Chief Adeen from 1999 until she passed away in 2011 at age 14, described her as “one of the most influential and one of the only cows in the breed with offspring over +2500 on genomics and All-American progeny.” This dual achievement—excelling in traditional show type and modern genomic metrics—foreshadowed the family’s future significance, bridging these two worlds.

Adeen’s reproductive career was remarkable by any standard. She left behind 51 Excellent daughters classified worldwide, ranking her second only to Ashlyn for the most Excellent daughters of all time. This prolific production of high-quality offspring established her as an “industry elite” and exponentially expanded the Ada family’s influence.

Douglas King reflected on working with these remarkable cows: “It was the thrill of a lifetime to work with those two great cows, Adeen and Alicia. I’ve often thought how special it would be to assemble all the daughters of Adeen and Alicia in one barn. What a sensational barn full of cows you would have!”

From Show Ring to Genomic Revolution

MD-Delight Durham Atlee EX-92-4YR-USA DOM GMD 2*: The pivotal Holstein matriarch whose Goldwyn sons revolutionized type breeding worldwide. After catching Michael Heath's eye as a young heifer and selling for $20,000, she achieved Reserve Intermediate Champion at the 2005 International Holstein Show. Though her life was cut short by cancer in 2008, her legendary "golden flush" to Braedale Goldwyn produced six sons with Superior Type credentials, including the influential Atwood, Atlantic, and Aftershock. As a granddaughter of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada through MS Kingstead Chief Adeen, Atlee represents the perfect bridge between show ring excellence and genomic merit in modern Holstein breeding. Photo: Cybil Fisher
MD-Delight Durham Atlee EX-92-4YR-USA DOM GMD 2*: The pivotal Holstein matriarch whose Goldwyn sons revolutionized type breeding worldwide. After catching Michael Heath’s eye as a young heifer and selling for $20,000, she achieved Reserve Intermediate Champion at the 2005 International Holstein Show. Though her life was cut short by cancer in 2008, her legendary “golden flush” to Braedale Goldwyn produced six sons with Superior Type credentials, including the influential Atwood, Atlantic, and Aftershock. As a granddaughter of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada through MS Kingstead Chief Adeen, Atlee represents the perfect bridge between show ring excellence and genomic merit in modern Holstein breeding. Photo: Cybil Fisher

The Durham-Atlee Connection: A Critical Genetic Branch

While many breeding decisions contributed to the Ada family’s expansion, perhaps none proved more consequential than those involving Adeen’s granddaughter, Durham Atlee. On September 11, 2001, MD-Delight Storm Amberlee gave birth to MD-Delight Durham Atlee-ET, sired by Regancrest Elton Durham. Michael Heath of Heath Holsteins, Rick, Shannon Allyn, and Jason Lloyd purchased Atlee as a bred heifer from the Dells.

Heath’s decision to buy Atlee came with some hesitation. He was working his last sale as a professional fitter, the Maryland Convention Sale, when he first noticed Atlee. “Where we had the fitting chute set up, Atlee was tied just six feet away. I kept looking at the calf, liking the calf, looking at the calf, liking the calf, but she was small for her age,” Heath shared. About a year later, Heath traveled to North Carolina to Foster’s, who had bought Atlee at the Maryland Convention Sale. Priced at $20,000 as a springing heifer, Heath took a chance on her. He liked her pedigree and thought she could make money selling embryos if she classified at least Very Good-85 as a two-year-old.

Heath’s gamble paid off spectacularly. Atlee was trucked from North Carolina to Massachusetts for their state show on one of the hottest summer days, but she pulled it together and won her class the following day. She later placed 15th in the senior two-year-old class at the World Dairy Expo.

As a senior three-year-old, Atlee was supposed to be due September 1, but they had the wrong breeding date. She ended up calving mid-September, and the partners weren’t sure if she would be ready for the show. Heath convinced them to send her anyway, figuring they had nothing to lose. Less than a week later, MD-Delight Durham Atlee was named Reserve Intermediate Champion of the 2005 International Holstein Show.

Heath reflected, “She is worldwide known by name, and I don’t know how big of name she would have been if she hadn’t gone to Madison.” This observation highlights the continued importance of show ring exposure in building a cow family’s reputation, even as the industry moved toward more data-driven breeding decisions.

Whittier-Farms Jasper Atlanta VG-85-CH 2YR: This striking young cow exemplifies the global impact of the Ada family's genetic excellence, earning 2nd place honors at the prestigious Swiss Expo 2014. As a granddaughter of MD-Delight Durham Atlee EX-92-USA, she represents a critical branch in the Ada dynasty, connecting directly to the influential maternal line that produced industry-changing sires Atwood, Golden Dreams, Delete, Amazing, and Aftershock. Her dairy strength, angularity, and overall style showcase the consistent type transmission that has made this cow family so valuable to Holstein breeders worldwide. Atlanta's international success further validates the Ada family's remarkable ability to produce superior animals across continents and generations, continuing a legacy of excellence that began with Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada. Photo: Wolfhard Schulze
Whittier-Farms Jasper Atlanta VG-85-CH 2YR: This striking cow exemplifies the global impact of the Ada family’s genetic excellence, earning 2nd place honors at the prestigious Swiss Expo 2014. As a granddaughter of MD-Delight Durham Atlee EX-92-USA, she represents a critical branch in the Ada dynasty, connecting directly to the influential maternal line that produced industry-changing sires Atwood, Golden Dreams, Delete, Amazing, and Aftershock. Her dairy strength, angularity, and overall style showcase the consistent type transmission that has made this cow family so valuable to Holstein breeders worldwide. Atlanta’s international success further validates the Ada family’s remarkable ability to produce superior animals across continents and generations, continuing a legacy of excellence that began with Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada. Photo: Wolfhard Schulze

The Golden Flush: Birth of a Genomic Giant

The truly transformative moment for the Ada family’s international impact came through what has become known as the “golden flush”—the breeding of Durham Atlee to Braedale Goldwyn. In 2007, this mating produced several sons who would become influential sires: Maple-Downs-I GW Atwood, Allyndale-I Attic, Allyndale-I Atticus, Maple-Downs-I GW Atlantic, Allyndale-I GW Arden, and Mr. Atlees Altaamazing.

These bulls were distributed among major AI organizations: Atwood, Arden, and Atlantic went to Select Sires, Attic, and Atticus to Semex, and Altaamazing to AltaGenetics Inc. In the same year, MS Atlees SHT Aftershock, Atlee’s Shottle son, was purchased by St. Jacobs A.B.C.

GALYS-VRAY EX-94-CH EX-95-MS: This exceptional Atwood daughter exemplifies the enduring legacy of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada. Grand Champion at the 2016 European Show in Colmar and Swiss Expo, GALYS-VRAY showcases the perfect blend of show ring excellence and production prowess that defines the Ada family. Her achievements, including multiple Grand Champion titles at Expo Bulle, cement her status as one of the most influential cows in modern Holstein breeding, bridging continents and generations with her remarkable genetic impact. Photo: Wolfhard Schulze
GALYS-VRAY EX-94-CH EX-95-MS: This exceptional Atwood daughter exemplifies the enduring legacy of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada. Grand Champion at the 2016 European Show in Colmar and Swiss Expo, GALYS-VRAY showcases the perfect blend of show ring excellence and production prowess that defines the Ada family. Her achievements, including multiple Grand Champion titles at Expo Bulle, cement her status as one of the most influential cows in modern Holstein breeding, bridging continents and generations with her remarkable genetic impact. Photo: Wolfhard Schulze

Steve Velthuis of Velthuis Farms purchased embryos from this flush, resulting in three heifers and five bulls. In a twist of fate that demonstrates the sometimes unpredictable nature of breeding, Velthuis shared that Atwood was initially “the one left that no one wanted” when other AI organizations made their selections. “He was right at the time of genomics, and the other brothers were high enough that they didn’t need to test Atwood. We collected him before we got his genomics,” shared Velthuis.

Through a conversation between Velthuis and Ed Fellers, a syndicate was formed for Atwood that enabled his sampling program. The results would exceed all expectations, as Atwood emerged as the leader with soaring demand. As Velthuis noted, “Most people can’t get Goldwyn semen, so Atwood is a good replacement for those that want Goldwyn blood.”

Charwill Attic Marcy: The triumphant 2015 Royal Winter Fair Grand Champion represents the culmination of the Ada legacy through her sire Attic, a son of Durham Atlee. This exceptional female validated Tim Abbott's claim about Atlee's extraordinary type transmission, completing an undefeated show season by capturing grand championships at both Madison and the Royal. Her victory under judge Michael Heath—who had earlier recognized Atlee's potential—demonstrates how the Ada family continues to dominate show rings worldwide, extending the dynasty's influence into yet another generation of Holstein excellence. Photo: Royal Winter Fair
Charwill Attic Marcy: The triumphant 2015 Royal Winter Fair Grand Champion represents the culmination of the Ada legacy through her sire Attic, a son of Durham Atlee. This exceptional female validated Tim Abbott’s claim about Atlee’s extraordinary type transmission, completing an undefeated show season by capturing grand championships at both Madison and the Royal. Her victory under judge Michael Heath—who had earlier recognized Atlee’s potential—demonstrates how the Ada family continues to dominate show rings worldwide, extending the dynasty’s influence into yet another generation of Holstein excellence. Photo: The Bullvine

By the end of 2013, Atlee’s six proven sons had all earned Superior Type credentials; five were in the top 10 for type. This remarkable achievement prompted Tim Abbott to claim that “Atlee’s ability to transmit type appears to be as strong as any cow in breed history.” This assessment was validated in the fall of 2015 when Charwill Attic Marcy (EX-95-USA), a daughter of Allyndale-I Attic owned by MilkSource, Kaukauna, Wisconsin, ended an undefeated show season by winning the grand championships at both the Royal Winter Fair and International Holstein Show.

The same flush also produced MS Atlees Goldwyn Ariel-ET (VG-89), Reserve All-American junior 2-year-old 2009. She was later purchased for $1.5 million by a Canadian syndicate, further cementing the family’s economic impact on the breed.

Ruegruet High Octane ALLYSON VG-86-2YR CH: The sixth-generation descendant of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada exemplifies the enduring legacy of this extraordinary Holstein family. With her balanced dairy form and strong mammary system, ALLYSON showcases the genetic excellence that has defined the Ada lineage for over three decades. As a Very Good-86 two-year-old, she continues the tradition of superior type and production that flows through her impressive maternal line—from her dam Whittier-Farms Jasper ATLANTA EX-91-3E (2nd place Swiss Expo Lausanne 2014) back to the legendary foundation dam Ada. ALLYSON represents the global reach of the Ada influence, with her success in European show rings demonstrating how strategic breeding decisions continue to produce exceptional animals across generations and continents. Photo: Wolfhard Schulze
Ruegruet High Octane ALLYSON VG-86-2YR CH: The sixth-generation descendant of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada exemplifies the enduring legacy of this extraordinary Holstein family. With her balanced dairy form and strong mammary system, ALLYSON showcases the genetic excellence that has defined the Ada lineage for over three decades. As a Very Good-86 two-year-old, she continues the tradition of superior type and production that flows through her impressive maternal line—from her dam Whittier-Farms Jasper ATLANTA EX-91-3E (2nd place Swiss Expo Lausanne 2014) back to the legendary foundation dam Ada. ALLYSON represents the global reach of the Ada influence, with her success in European show rings demonstrating how strategic breeding decisions continue to produce exceptional animals across generations and continents. Photo: Wolfhard Schulze

The Ada Legacy in Modern Holstein Breeding

Bridging Breeding Philosophies

The evolution of the Ada family parallels the broader transformation of dairy cattle breeding over the past four decades. From the mid-1960s through 1980, the industry experienced what has been described as “The Great Divide Between Type and Production,” where traditional display herds focused exclusively on conformation while progressive farmer-breeders embraced genetic indexes for production traits.

Their ability to excel across this divide makes the Ada family remarkable. This family has maintained relevance through every phase of the industry’s development, beginning with Ada’s show ring success, continuing through Alicia and Adeen’s exceptional type transmission, and culminating with Atwood’s emergence as a genomic giant.

In today’s breeding landscape, “DNA indexes have become the starting point in animal selection decisions for breeders regardless of their trait priority: type, production, fertility, health, or functionality.” The Ada family’s success in adapting to this paradigm shift demonstrates the rare ability to combine traditional type excellence with modern genetic merit.

Mario Park Goldwyn Alicia EX-93-3E 8*: The 2018 Holstein Australia Cow of the Year exemplifies the global impact of the Ada family legacy. Descending from world-renowned Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada through Shoremar S Alicia EX-97-3E, this exceptional Goldwyn daughter combines remarkable production (lifetime exceeding 80,000 liters) with superior type traits, including an EX-95 score for dairy strength. Owned by Murray and Jane Polson, she's established herself as one of Australia's most influential brood cows, with her progeny consistently excelling in both show rings and production records. Her extraordinary fertility, production persistence, and ability to transmit superior type to her offspring demonstrate how the Ada genetics continue to shape Holstein breeding excellence worldwide. Photo: Bradley Cullen
Mario Park Goldwyn Alicia EX-93-3E 8*: The 2018 Holstein Australia Cow of the Year exemplifies the global impact of the Ada family legacy. Descending from world-renowned Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada through Shoremar S Alicia EX-97-3E, this exceptional Goldwyn daughter combines remarkable production (lifetime exceeding 80,000 liters) with superior type traits, including an EX-95 score for dairy strength. Owned by Murray and Jane Polson, she’s established herself as one of Australia’s most influential brood cows, with her progeny consistently excelling in both show rings and production records. Her extraordinary fertility, production persistence, and ability to transmit superior type to her offspring demonstrate how the Ada genetics continue to shape Holstein breeding excellence worldwide. Photo: Bradley Cullen

Global Impact Through Multiple Generations

The influence of the Ada family extends far beyond North America. Their descendants have succeeded in show rings and breeding programs worldwide, demonstrating the family’s genetic prepotency across diverse environments and management systems.

In Japan, for example, TMR Adeen Dundee Chief-ET, a Dundee daughter of Chief Adeen, was named first place senior three-year-old and grand champion at the Hokkaido Black and White Show, described as “the biggest spring show in Japan.”

Blondin T&L Avalanche Angela VG-87-2YR (Max): This exceptional junior two-year-old has made an impressive show ring debut, claiming 1st place, Best Udder, and the $250 Jack Pot at the 2020 Fall Invitational Show. Exemplifying the continuing excellence of the Ada family, she traces directly back to the influential MS Kingstead Chief Adeen-EX-94-11*. Her maximum VG-87 score as a two-year-old highlights her outstanding conformation and dairy quality, continuing the legacy of elite type that defines descendants of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada. Exhibited proudly by Ferme Blondin of Saint-Placide, Quebec, she represents the global reach and enduring impact of the Ada maternal line in modern Holstein breeding. Photo: Summer Invitational Show
Blondin T&L Avalanche Angela VG-87-2YR (Max): Exemplifying the continuing excellence of the Ada family, she traces directly back to the influential MS Kingstead Chief Adeen-EX-94-11*. Her maximum VG-87 score as a two-year-old highlights her outstanding conformation and dairy quality, continuing the legacy of elite type that defines descendants of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada. Exhibited proudly by Ferme Blondin of Saint-Placide, Quebec, she represents the enduring impact of the Ada maternal line in modern Holstein breeding. Photo: The Bullvine

Lessons for Modern Breeders

If there’s one thing the Ada family teaches us, it’s the value of strategic mating decisions. From Ada’s original mating to Donnandale Skychief that produced Alicia and Adeen to the “golden flush” of Durham Atlee to Braedale Goldwyn that produced Atwood, key breeding decisions amplified the family’s influence exponentially.

In today’s era of genomic selection, where 70% of dairy breed pregnancies come from high-index genomic bulls, the principles demonstrated by the Ada family remain relevant. The most successful breeding programs still balance genetic data with visual assessment and family history.

The Ada family shows us how to balance tradition and innovation. While modern dairy breeding has embraced genomic selection and advanced reproductive technologies, the fundamental principles of identifying and propagating superior genetics haven’t changed.

Want to see the impact of this approach? Just look at the production statistics. Holstein cows in 1920 produced about 2000 kg of milk annually. Today’s Holsteins average over 10,000 kg annually with the same solids content. That’s not just progress—that’s transformation.

The commercial success of the Ada family demonstrates the economic potential of elite genetics. The “Impact of Ada Sale” averaged an estimated $6,200 on 103 head, all from a single bloodline. This premium has only increased in the genomic era, exemplified by the $1.5 million price tag for MS Atlees Goldwyn Ariel.

MS GOLDWYN ALANA EX-96-2E (97MAM): The epitome of Holstein excellence as captured at her Grande Championne victory at the 2015 Quebec Spring Show. This extraordinary Goldwyn daughter exemplifies the continuing legacy of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada through her dam line, descending from the legendary Shormar BKB S Alicia. Her near-perfect classification score, including an exceptional 97 points for mammary system, reflects the superior genetic transmission that has defined the Ada family for generations. With multiple championship titles including Reserve Grand at the 2015 Royal Winter Fair, ALANA showcases the remarkable balance of dairy strength, angularity, and udder quality that has made descendants of Ada so influential in both show rings and breeding programs worldwide. Her commanding presence continues to validate the remarkable prepotency of the Ada maternal line across four generations of Holstein breeding excellence. Photo: Vicki Fletcher
MS GOLDWYN ALANA EX-96-2E (97MAM): The epitome of Holstein excellence as captured at her Grande Championne victory at the 2015 Quebec Spring Show. This extraordinary Goldwyn daughter exemplifies the continuing legacy of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada through her dam line, descending from the legendary Shormar BKB S Alicia. Her near-perfect classification score, including an exceptional 97 points for mammary system, reflects the superior genetic transmission that has defined the Ada family for generations. With multiple championship titles including Reserve Grand at the 2015 Royal Winter Fair, ALANA showcases the remarkable balance of dairy strength, angularity, and udder quality that has made descendants of Ada so influential in both show rings and breeding programs worldwide. Her commanding presence continues to validate the remarkable prepotency of the Ada maternal line across four generations of Holstein breeding excellence. Photo: Vicki Fletcher

The Future of Holstein Breeding: Building on Ada’s Legacy

The Holstein breed continues to evolve, with genomic selection accelerating improvement. The Ada family’s ability to maintain relevance through these technological shifts provides a blueprint for breeders seeking sustained success.

As the dairy industry evolves, the challenge for breeders will be maintaining Holstein’s distinctive characteristics while advancing performance across multiple traits. The Ada family shows how the elite type can coexist with production efficiency and genetic merit.

Remember, the modern Holstein results from centuries of selective breeding, dating back to the crossing of black “Batavians” with white “Friesians” 2000 years ago in The Netherlands. The breed has continuously adapted to changing agricultural needs throughout this long history while maintaining its core identity.

Conclusion: The Enduring Significance of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada

Isn’t it amazing how one cow born in Ontario in 1986 could reshape an entire breed globally? Through her daughters Alicia and Adeen, her granddaughter Atlee, and descendants like Atwood, the Ada family has maintained relevance across multiple eras of dairy breeding—from the show-focused 1980s through the production-driven 1990s and into today’s genomic age.

As Charlie McEvoy perfectly put it, her descendants “have changed our barns and show strings forever.” This transformation extends beyond the show ring to commercial dairy operations worldwide.

For modern breeders navigating an increasingly complex landscape, the Ada family offers an inspiring example—a reminder that behind all the genomic data and reproductive technologies, the art of identifying and propagating exceptional individuals remains at the heart of successful dairy breeding.

The final chapter of Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada’s story is still being written. But one thing’s for sure—her influence will continue to shape the Holstein breed for generations.

Key Takeaways

  • Ada’s story exemplifies how a single exceptional individual can transform an entire breed through thoughtful breeding decisions and genetic prepotency
  • The Ada family’s rare ability to excel in both show ring type and modern genomic metrics provides a blueprint for breeders seeking to balance tradition with innovation
  • Strategic matings—particularly Ada to Skychief and later Atlee to Goldwyn—demonstrate how complementary genetic pairings can exponentially amplify desirable traits
  • The economic value of elite genetics is highlighted by the commercial success of Ada’s descendants, including the $1.5 million sale of MS Atlees Goldwyn Ariel
  • The continued relevance of the Ada family across multiple eras of dairy breeding underscores how fundamental breed quality maintains value even as selection technology evolves

Executive Summary

Born in 1986 at Aitkenbrae farm in Ontario, Aitkenbrae Starbuck Ada transformed from promising show cow to Holstein dynasty matriarch through strategic breeding decisions that amplified her genetic influence across generations. After being crowned Unanimous All-American Senior Three-Year-Old in 1990, Ada’s true legacy emerged through her two exceptional Donnandale Skychief daughters—Shoremar S Alicia and MS Kingstead Chief Adeen—who produced dozens of excellent offspring and established Ada’s family as genetic royalty. This lineage reached its pinnacle with the “golden flush” breeding of Ada’s granddaughter Durham Atlee to Braedale Goldwyn, producing the globally influential bull Atwood and other superior sires. Ada’s family uniquely bridged the historical divide between show ring conformation and production traits, creating a genetic pathway that continues influencing modern Holstein breeding across all continents.

Join the Revolution!

Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Daily for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.

NewsSubscribe
First
Last
Consent

BANNs CRUSH Traditional Models: The AI Secret Weapon Reshaping Dairy Genetics

AI crushes tradition: BANNs boost dairy genetics accuracy by 5%+. Will your herd lead or bleed?

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: A groundbreaking AI model called Biologically Annotated Neural Networks (BANNs) is revolutionizing dairy genetics, outperforming traditional methods like GBLUP and BayesB by up to 7.46% accuracy in key traits such as mastitis resistance and milk yield. By analyzing DNA in 100kb “genomic neighborhoods,” BANNs capture complex gene interactions that linear models miss. While the tech promises massive gains—like 14% fewer mastitis cases per herd—it risks overfitting and demands heavy computing power. Industry giants like CRV and ABS Global are already racing to adopt it, but experts warn farmers to balance AI’s power with genetic diversity. The question isn’t if to adopt BANNs, but how fast before competitors leave you behind.

KEY TAKEAWAYS:

  • 5% Accuracy Edge: BANNs outperform GBLUP/BayesB in milk yield, mastitis resistance, and conformation.
  • DNA Neighborhoods: 100kb genomic windows reveal hidden gene interactions traditional models ignore.
  • Risks vs. Rewards: Overfitting threatens genetic diversity; compute costs may strain small farms.
  • Industry Arms Race: CRV and ABS Global are piloting BANN integrations by 2025–2026.
  • Farmer Action Plan: Demand transparent AI tools and diversify breeding to hedge risks.
BANNs genomic prediction, dairy cattle genetics, AI in agriculture, SNP analysis accuracy, genomic selection models

Dairy genetics just took a quantum leap forward. A groundbreaking study published in the Journal of Animal Science and Biotechnology (2024) reveals that Biologically Annotated Neural Networks (BANNs) outperform traditional genomic prediction models like GBLUP and BayesB by up to 7.46% accuracy in key traits such as milk yield and mastitis resistance. This isn’t incremental progress—it’s a seismic shift in how we understand cattle DNA. With over 6,500 Chinese Holsteins analyzed (sharing 78% of SNPs with North American herds per CDCB’s 2024 genomic survey), the findings have immediate relevance for dairy operations worldwide. As Dr. Li Chen, lead researcher, starkly notes: “We’ve been using oversimplified models for decades. BANNs force us to confront the messy reality of how genes actually interact.”

Why 100kb Windows Are Changing the Game

At the heart of BANNs’ success is their unique approach to genomic analysis: dividing the genome into 100kb windows (100,000 DNA base pair segments). Unlike traditional gene-based models that treat genes as isolated units, this method mimics biology’s complexity by analyzing how SNPs interact across functional genomic neighborhoods.

Accuracy Gains by Trait

TraitBANN_100kb vs. GBLUPBANN_100kb vs. BayesB
Milk Yield (MY)+7.46%+6.93%
Fat Yield (FY)+5.42%+5.21%
Somatic Cell Score (SCS)+4.20%+3.75%
Conformation Score+5.36%+5.68%
Source: Journal of Animal Science and Biotechnology, Table 2 (2024)

The results speak for themselves. For milk yield, BANN_100kb achieved a 7.46% accuracy boost over GBLUP, while mastitis resistance predictions jumped 4.2%—a critical gain given that mastitis costs the U.S. dairy industry over $2 billion annually (USDA, 2023).

This breakthrough matters because it finally bridges the gap between statistical models and biological reality. As the study shows, BANNs capture non-additive genetic effects—synergies and antagonisms between genes that linear models ignore. For instance, a SNP influencing milk yield might only show its full effect when paired with another SNP 50kb away. Traditional methods miss these interactions; BANNs exploit them.

SNP-Set Performance Comparison

MetricBANN_gene (Gene-Based)BANN_100kb (100kb Windows)
Phenotypic Variance Explained73.8%75.4%
Top SNP-Set PIP*0.0910.096
Source: Journal of Animal Science and Biotechnology, Table 3 (2024)
PIP = Posterior Inclusion Probability (measure of genetic influence)

The Risks Lurking Behind the 5% Advantage

While the accuracy gains are undeniable, the study issues stark warnings. BANNs’ ability to model complex interactions comes with a catch: overfitting. The AI may prioritize short-term prediction accuracy at the expense of long-term genetic diversity, potentially creating herds optimized for today’s traits but vulnerable to tomorrow’s challenges. Researchers explicitly caution against applying BANNs to breeds like Jerseys without further validation, as the model was trained exclusively on Holstein data.

Computational Demands

MethodAvg. Training Time per Trait
GBLUP42 minutes
BayesB132 minutes
BANN_100kb285 minutes
Random Forest274 minutes
Source: JOURNAL OF ANIMAL SCIENCE AND BIOTECHNOLOGY Supplementary Materials, Table S2 (2024)

Industry experts echo these concerns. Dr. Chad Dechow, a dairy geneticist at Penn State, warns: “A 5% accuracy gain only matters if it translates to real-world ROI. Farmers need solutions they can trust, not black-box algorithms”. Computational demands also pose hurdles—BANNs require 2.8x more processing power than GBLUP, which could strain smaller farms or AI providers slow to upgrade infrastructure.

How the Industry Is Responding

Major players are already mobilizing. CRV announced plans to trial BANN-integrated indexes by late 2025, while ABS Global emphasizes a hybrid approach: “AI should enhance breeder expertise, not replace it”. Meanwhile, the CDCB hints at U.S. evaluations rolling out by 2026, pending further validation.

These developments signal a critical juncture. Brian Van Doormaal, Chief Services Officer at Lactanet and architect of Canada’s genomic evaluation system, emphasizes practicality: “Dairying is a difficult business. Farmers need solutions that deliver clear ROI, not just technological hype”.

Economic Impact: Connecting Genomics to Profit

Mastitis Resistance Savings

Accuracy GainReduction in Clinical MastitisAnnual Savings per 100 Cows
+4.2% (BANN_100kb)14%$2,100–$3,800
Source: USDA Mastitis Cost Analysis (2023)

For dairy farmers, the stakes are clear. A 14% reduction in mastitis cases could save thousands annually—money that flows directly to the bottom line.

Your Path Forward in the BANN Era

For dairy professionals, the message is clear: complacency is riskier than change. Start by grilling genetics providers about their BANN adoption timelines—CRV’s public commitment sets a benchmark others must match. Diversify breeding strategies by pairing BANN-selected bulls with proven sires, creating a genetic safety net against overfitting pitfalls. Most crucially, demand plain-English explanations of how these models work. The era of blindly trusting genomic predictions is over; the winners will be those who marry AI’s power with human wisdom.

The Bottom Line

BANNs aren’t a distant promise—they’re rewriting dairy genetics today. Farmers who dismiss this 5% gap risk obsolescence, while early adopters could secure generational advantages. As the Journal of Animal Science and Biotechnology team concludes: “This isn’t an evolution. It’s a revolution.” The question isn’t whether you’ll join—it’s how quickly you’ll turn this disruption into profit.

Learn more:

  1. Longevity: The Hidden Profit Center In Your Barn
    Explore how breeding for longevity—like the record-breaking Canadian Milking Shorthorn with 100,000kg lifetime milk—reduces replacement costs and maximizes ROI, aligning with BANNs’ potential to enhance genetic durability.
  2. AI vs. Breeders: Who Really Drives Genetic Progress?
    Dive into the debate over AI’s role in modern breeding, featuring insights from top geneticists on balancing cutting-edge tools like BANNs with traditional breeder expertise.
  3. Smart Barns 2030: How Sensors Are Revolutionizing Herd Health
    Discover how IoT sensors and predictive analytics (like Cornell’s CAST project) work alongside genomic tools to optimize mastitis detection, feed efficiency, and cow longevity.

Join the Revolution!

Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Daily for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.

NewsSubscribe
First
Last
Consent

How Selecting Bulls for Calf Disease Resistance Could Transform Your Dairy Operation

Sick of treating calf scours? New genetic tool slashes disease rates by 44%! Discover how selecting the right bulls could revolutionize your dairy farm’s health and profits.

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Lactanet Canada is set to launch a game-changing Calf Health Index for Holstein breeders in August 2025. This innovative genetic tool allows farmers to select bulls whose daughters show significantly improved resistance to diarrhea and respiratory diseases in calves. Based on extensive data analysis from over 78,000 heifers, the index reveals dramatic differences between top and bottom-ranked bulls, with potential to reduce disease rates by up to 44%. The index will be expressed as Relative Breeding Values (RBVs) and integrated into Canada’s Lifetime Performance Index by 2026. With nearly 3,000 bulls already evaluated, this breakthrough promises to transform calf health management, reduce treatment costs, and boost long-term profitability for dairy operations.

KEY TAKEAWAYS:

  • New Calf Health Index debuts August 2025, focusing on diarrhea (0-60 days) and respiratory problems (0-180 days) in Holstein calves
  • Top-ranked bulls produce daughters with up to 44% fewer cases of diarrhea compared to bottom-ranked bulls
  • Index combines genetic data with economic analysis to maximize impact on farm profitability
  • Will be incorporated into Canada’s Lifetime Performance Index by April 2026, reflecting industry shift towards health and sustainability traits
  • Offers potential to significantly reduce treatment costs and improve lifetime productivity of dairy cattle
calf health index, dairy cattle genetics, Holstein breeding, disease resistance in calves, Lactanet Canada

You know those endless battles with calf scours and pneumonia that keep us up at night? Well, I just learned about a genetic solution coming our way, and honestly, I can’t wait to tell you all about it. Lactanet Canada is launching a brand-new Calf Health Index for Holsteins this August (2025). I was chatting with some folks in the industry last week, and they’re buzzing about this. It’s a genetic tool that helps us select bulls whose daughters are naturally more resistant to diarrhea and respiratory problems in calves.

Think about it – what if you could cut your calf treatment costs by making smarter breeding decisions? That’s precisely what this index promises.

The Science Behind It (Don’t Worry, I’ll Keep It Simple!)

Lactanet didn’t just come up with this idea out of thin air. They’ve analyzed nearly 89,000 health records from over 78,000 heifers across more than 1,200 Canadian farms. Data nerds like me find this stuff fascinating—they looked at records from 2007 through December 2024!

What they found confirms what we’ve all experienced in our barns: about 19.5% of calves deal with respiratory issues, while 21.1% battle diarrhea. Those numbers match pretty closely with what I’ve seen over the years.

But here’s where it gets exciting. Check out this table showing the difference between the top and bottom bulls:

TraitBull GroupRBV Values % of Healthy Calves
AverageSDMinMaxAverageSDMinMax
RespiratoryTop 101161.91141198610.461100
RespiratoryBottom 10831.780856415.22681
DiarrheaTop 101140.6113115955.986100
DiarrheaBottom 10822.178845113.63368

When I saw these numbers, my jaw dropped. The top bulls for diarrhea resistance produced daughters with 95% healthy calves, while the bottom bulls’ daughters were healthy only 51% of the time. That’s cutting your disease rates in half by picking the right genetics!

What’s In It For Your Farm?

You might wonder, “Okay, but what does this mean for my operation?” Great question!

Here’s the deal: if you’re using bulls with an RBV below 90 (that’s their Relative Breeding Value), their daughters are 1.8 times more likely to get diarrhea and 1.3 times more likely to get respiratory disease compared to daughters of bulls with an RBV above 110.

And we all know these diseases aren’t just a short-term headache. Calves that get sick often produce less milk in their first lactation and have fertility problems, too. It’s like a gift that keeps giving – in the worst way possible!

How They Built This Thing

The new index puts more weight on diarrhea (70%) than respiratory problems (30%). At first, I thought that seemed odd, but it makes perfect sense when you understand their reasoning. Diarrhea often leads to respiratory problems later on, so if you can prevent the first domino from falling, you might avoid the whole cascade.

Genetic science is pretty cool, too. Even though the heritability isn’t super high (5.4% for respiratory problems and 4.4% for diarrhea), there’s a strong genetic correlation of 0.53 between the two traits. This means for you and me that when we select one trait, we’re making progress on the other one, too. Talk about efficiency!

ParameterRespiratory ProblemsDiarrhea
Heritability5.4%4.4%
Genetic Correlation0.530.53

Putting This to Work in Your Breeding Program

When the index rolls out this August, it’ll use the standard RBV system with a mean of 100 and a standard deviation of 5. Any bull above 100 is better than average for disease resistance. Simple enough?

The good news is there are already 2,974 bulls with official evaluations, so you’ll have plenty of options. And with a reliability of about 84.6%, you can trust these numbers aren’t just guesswork.

I’m already talking to my genetic advisor about how we’ll incorporate this into our breeding decisions. You might want to do the same – get ahead of the curve!

Where This Fits in the Big Picture

Lactanet isn’t stopping with just releasing this index. They plan to incorporate it into the Health & Welfare subindex of the Lifetime Performance Index (LPI) by April 2026. This is part of the industry’s more significant shift toward breeding for health and sustainability, not just milk production.

I’ve been in this business for years, and I’ve seen many new indexes come and go. But this one? It’s going to stick. It addresses a real pain point for producers while also helping us show consumers that we’re serious about animal welfare. Win-win!

Learn More

Join the Revolution!

Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Daily for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.

NewsSubscribe
First
Last
Consent

The Vision of Mount Victoria: T.B. Macaulay’s Holstein Legacy

Discover the legacy of Mount Victoria Farms, where one man’s vision revolutionized Holstein breeding. From unlikely beginnings to global influence, this tale of scientific innovation and relentless pursuit of excellence shaped the future of dairy cattle worldwide—a game-changer in agricultural history.

T.B. Macaulay, who owned Mount Victoria Farm, Hudson Heights, Quebec, founded the Rag Apple bloodline.
T.B. Macaulay, who owned Mount Victoria Farm, Hudson Heights, Quebec, founded the Rag Apple bloodline.

Few names resonate as powerfully in the annals of dairy cattle breeding as Mount Victoria Farms. Nestled in the picturesque landscape of Quebec, Canada, this unlikely crucible of genetic innovation would reshape the entire Holstein breed, leaving an indelible mark on dairy farms worldwide. 

In 1899, a 44-year-old insurance executive, Thomas Bassett Macaulay, purchased a 200-acre farm overlooking the Lake of Two Mountains. Little did the world know that this seemingly ordinary land acquisition would be the first step in a revolutionary journey that would span decades and transform an entire industry. 

“Macaulay, armed with a sharp analytical mind from his work in actuarial science, approached cattle breeding with precision and creativity.”

He aimed to create a strain of Holstein cattle that consistently produces milk with high butterfat content while maintaining excellent conformation. What unfolded over the next four decades was nothing short of extraordinary. Through meticulous selection, innovative breeding practices, and an unwavering commitment to his vision, Macaulay and his team at Mount Victoria Farms developed bloodlines that would come to dominate the Holstein breed for generations. 

This is how one man’s passion for genetics, business acumen, and scientific approach created a legacy. This legacy revolutionized dairy farming globally. It’s a tale of perseverance, innovation, and the pursuit of perfection that continues to influence dairy producers today. Prepare to step into Mount Victoria Farms, where one of the most significant breeding experiments in agricultural history took place, forever changing the face of the Holstein breed.  

The Mount Victoria Farm, circa 1940: This historic photograph captures the picturesque Mount Victoria Farm in Hudson Heights, Quebec, where Thomas Bassett Macaulay revolutionized Holstein breeding. The farm’s scenic location overlooking the Lake of Two Mountains provided an idyllic setting for Macaulay’s groundbreaking work in developing influential bloodlines that would shape the Holstein breed worldwide for generations to come.
The Mount Victoria Farm, circa 1940: This historic photograph captures the picturesque Mount Victoria Farm in Hudson Heights, Quebec, where Thomas Bassett Macaulay revolutionized Holstein breeding. The farm’s scenic location overlooking the Lake of Two Mountains provided an idyllic setting for Macaulay’s groundbreaking work in developing influential bloodlines that would shape the Holstein breed worldwide for generations to come.

The Unlikely Breeder

In 1899, at 44, Thomas Bassett Macaulay made an unconventional decision that would reshape the future of Holstein breeding. The successful actuary and president of Sun Life Assurance Company purchased a 200-acre farm in Hudson Heights, Quebec, overlooking the picturesque Lake of Two Mountains. This acquisition was far from a retirement plan; it began an extraordinary journey into the world of dairy cattle genetics. 

Macaulay’s farm, which he named Mount Victoria, was initially a sandy plot with poor soil quality, presenting a challenging canvas for his breeding ambitions. Undeterred, he set about improving the land with the same methodical approach he applied to his insurance work. He acquired diverse livestock, including French-Canadian cattle, goats, sheep, and horses. Macaulay’s insatiable curiosity drove these early experiments in animal husbandry, as did his desire to understand the principles of breeding and genetics. 

For 25 years, Macaulay honed his skills and knowledge in animal management while continuing to lead Sun Life to new heights. His unique background in actuarial science provided him with a distinct advantage: the ability to analyze complex data and apply statistical principles to breeding decisions. This analytical approach would later become the cornerstone of his success in Holstein breeding. 

In 1924, at the age of 69, an age when most men were considering retirement, Macaulay embarked on a new adventure: his legacy. He purchased his first Holstein cow, marking the beginning of one of the most influential breeding programs in the breed’s history. This late entry into Holstein breeding, far from being a disadvantage, proved to be Macaulay’s secret weapon. 

Unencumbered by traditional practices and preconceived notions, Macaulay approached Holstein breeding with an outsider’s fresh perspective and a scientist’s rigorous methodology. He meticulously studied breed journals, pedigrees, and production records, applying his actuarial skills to identify the most promising genetic combinations. 

Macaulay’s unique approach quickly set him apart from other breeders. He wasn’t content with following established practices; instead, he sought to revolutionize the breeding process through careful selection, innovative breeding techniques, and a relentless focus on improvement. His goal was clear: to create a strain of Holsteins that consistently produced high butterfat milk while maintaining excellent conformation. 

As word of Macaulay’s innovative methods spread, the dairy farming community watched with curiosity and skepticism. Many doubted that an insurance executive with no formal agricultural training could succeed in the competitive world of Holstein breeding. Little did they know that this unlikely breeder was about to embark on a journey that would forever change the face of the Holstein breed and leave an indelible mark on dairy farming worldwide. 

The Foundation

In the early 1920s, Thomas Bassett Macaulay embarked on a quest to reshape the Holstein breed. Armed with his analytical mind and passion for improvement, he dove deep into dairy cattle genetics. Macaulay spent countless hours reviewing breed journals, studying pedigrees, and analyzing production records. His goal was clear: to create a strain of Holsteins that would consistently produce high butterfat milk while maintaining excellent conformation. 

Macaulay’s research led him to a surprising conclusion. The best Holstein genetics in North America were not found in the established herds of New York or Wisconsin but in the rolling hills of Oxford County, Ontario. With its rich dairy farming tradition, this region had become a hotbed of Holstein innovation. 

In 1924, Macaulay made his first significant move. He attended the dispersal sale of Newton Chambers, a respected Oxford County breeder. He purchased Oakhurst Colantha Abbekerk for $900, the sale’s highest price. This cow would become the foundation of Mount Victoria’s Colantha family and prove a wise investment. 

The following year, Macaulay set his sights on Alfred Hulet’s herd, another Oxford County breeder known for his work with the Posch-Abbekerk bloodlines. At Hulet’s dispersal, Macaulay acquired several key animals, including Dixie Colantha Hartog and Lady Meg Posch. These cows would establish essential families within the Mount Victoria herd. 

JOHANNA RAG APPLE PABST: One of the founding fathers of the Canadian Holstein breed. This legendary bull, purchased by Thomas B. Macaulay for $15,000 in 1926, became the cornerstone of Mount Victoria Farms’ breeding program. His influence was so profound that by the late 20th century, virtually every registered Holstein in the world carried his blood.
JOHANNA RAG APPLE PABST: One of the founding fathers of the Canadian Holstein breed. This legendary bull, purchased by Thomas B. Macaulay for $15,000 in 1926, became the cornerstone of Mount Victoria Farms’ breeding program. His influence was so profound that by the late 20th century, virtually every registered Holstein in the world carried his blood.

However, Macaulay’s most audacious move was yet to come. In 1926, he sent his farm manager, Joe Chandler, to a sale in Wisconsin with instructions to purchase a bull named Johanna Rag Apple Pabst. This bull, already famous for his show ring success and production-siring ability, was the missing piece in Macaulay’s breeding puzzle. 

Chandler hesitated when the bidding reached $15,000 – an astronomical sum for the time. He called Macaulay, who gave the go-ahead to continue bidding. Ultimately, “Old Joe” came to Mount Victoria for $15,000, setting a post-World War I record for a Holstein bull at public auction. 

The acquisition of Johanna Rag Apple Pabst sent shockwaves through the Holstein breeding world. Many questioned Macaulay’s judgment in spending such a sum on a single animal. However, Old Joe would prove to be worth every penny. His daughters consistently produced milk with over 4% butterfat, a highly sought-after trait but challenging to achieve. 

With his foundation animals in place, Macaulay was ready to begin his ambitious breeding program. He had assembled a group of cows with strong production records and excellent conformation and now had a herd sire capable of elevating their offspring to new heights. The stage was set for Mount Victoria Farms to become one of Holstein’s most influential breeding establishments.

The Super Champion”: A 1931 advertisement for Johanna Rag Apple Pabst, the cornerstone sire of Mount Victoria Farms. This legendary bull, purchased for $15,000 in 1926, revolutionized Holstein breeding with his ability to consistently sire daughters with high butterfat percentages and excellent conformation. His influence on the breed was so profound that by the late 20th century, virtually every registered Holstein worldwide carried his blood.
The Super Champion”: A 1931 advertisement for Johanna Rag Apple Pabst, the cornerstone sire of Mount Victoria Farms. This legendary bull, purchased for $15,000 in 1926, revolutionized Holstein breeding with his ability to consistently sire daughters with high butterfat percentages and excellent conformation. His influence on the breed was so profound that by the late 20th century, virtually every registered Holstein worldwide carried his blood.

The Macaulay Method

Thomas Bassett Macaulay’s approach to Holstein breeding was nothing short of revolutionary. Drawing on his background as an actuary, Macaulay applied rigorous scientific principles to cattle breeding in an unprecedented way for his time. At the heart of Macaulay’s method was a deep understanding of statistics and probability. Just as he had used mathematical models to predict life expectancy and risk in the insurance industry, Macaulay now applied similar principles to predict and shape the genetic outcomes of his breeding program. 

Macaulay’s breeding strategy was built on four key pillars: 

  1. Systematic Inbreeding and Line Breeding: Macaulay understood its power to concentrate desirable traits, unlike many breeders who feared inbreeding. He carefully planned matings to increase the frequency of genes for high butterfat production and excellent conformation. However, he balanced this with rigorous selection to avoid the pitfalls of inbreeding depression.
  2. Data-Driven Selection: Macaulay instituted a comprehensive milk testing and record-keeping system far ahead of its time. Every cow at Mount Victoria was regularly tested for milk volume and butterfat percentage, and the records were meticulously analyzed to inform breeding decisions.
  3. Focus on Butterfat: When most breeders were focused solely on milk volume, Macaulay set the ambitious goal of developing a strain of Holsteins that would consistently test at 4% butterfat or higher. This foresight would prove invaluable as the dairy industry later shifted towards valuing butterfat content.
  4. Holistic Approach to Breeding: While many breeders focused on production or conformation, Macaulay insisted on simultaneously improving both. He believed genetic progress could only be achieved by selecting all economically important traits.

Macaulay’s office at Mount Victoria was meticulously organized, with walls covered in pedigree charts and production records, showcasing his commitment to a scientific approach. He developed a complex system of index cards for each animal, tracking not just their performance but that of all their relatives. This allowed him to calculate what we now recognize as estimated breeding values for each animal. 

One of Macaulay’s most innovative practices was using “progeny testing,” which was used long before it became standard in the industry. He would hold back promising young bulls and breed them to a select group of cows, carefully observing and evaluating the resulting offspring before deciding whether to use the bull more widely. This patient, data-driven approach starkly contrasted to the more common practice of using bulls based solely on their pedigree or appearance. 

Macaulay also instituted a practice of “contract matings” with other breeders. He would send his best bulls to be used on top cows in different herds, with the agreement that he could buy back any outstanding offspring. This allowed him to expand his genetic base and test his bulls in diverse environments. 

The results of Macaulay’s scientific approach were remarkable. By the late 1930s, the average butterfat test of the Mount Victoria herd was over 4%, when the breed average was closer to 3.5%. Moreover, the herd’s production levels and show ring successes proved that high butterfat could be achieved without sacrificing other essential traits. 

Mount Victoria’s 1927 Farmer’s Advocate ads showcase their prized bull Johanna Rag Apple Pabst and his offspring, highlighting the farm’s focus on superior genetics and high butterfat production. These ads reflect Thomas B. Macaulay’s ambitious vision to develop a strain of Holsteins consistently testing at 4% butterfat or higher.
Mount Victoria’s 1927 Farmer’s Advocate ads showcase their prized bull Johanna Rag Apple Pabst and his offspring, highlighting the farm’s focus on superior genetics and high butterfat production. These ads reflect Thomas B. Macaulay’s ambitious vision to develop a strain of Holsteins consistently testing at 4% butterfat or higher.

Although Macaulay’s methods were highly successful, they were not without controversy among traditional breeders. Many criticized his approach as too clinical, arguing that successful breeding required an intuitive “eye for cattle” that couldn’t be reduced to numbers. Others were skeptical of his inbreeding practices. However, as the results spoke for themselves, more and more breeders began adopting Macaulay Method elements. 

In many ways, Thomas Bassett Macaulay laid the foundation for the modern approach to cattle breeding based on genetics. His insistence on data-driven decisions, his understanding of population genetics, and his willingness to challenge conventional wisdom set a new standard for scientific breeding that continues to influence the Holstein industry today.

The Key Players

At the heart of this remarkable breeding program were six exceptional females that came to be known as “The Big Six,” a term coined by William Prescott of Holstein-Friesian World. These cows would form the foundation of Mount Victoria’s success and shape the future of the Holstein breed worldwide.

The story of the “Big Six” cows begins in the early 1920s with Macaulay’s methodical and scientific approach to assembling his herd. Thomas Bassett Macaulay, an insurance executive passionate about cattle breeding, began making his herd then. Macaulay sought the best genetics to build his program. 

The first two “Big Six” members were acquired at the Newton Chambers’ dispersal sale in 1924. Oakhurst Colantha Abbekerk, a daughter of the influential Prince Colanthus Abbekerk, was purchased for $900, the sale’s highest price. This cow would establish the Abbekerk family at Mount Victoria, becoming a five-time Grand Champion, including at the prestigious Royal Winter Fair. At the same sale, Macaulay acquired Ingleside Pietje Posch for $550. This cow had already made a name for herself, placing first in the Junior Yearling class at the 1923 Royal Winter Fair and being part of Ontario’s winning State Herd at the National Dairy Show in Syracuse that same year. Ingleside would find the Pietje family at Mount Victoria. 

The third “Big Six” member came from Alfred Hulet’s 1924 dispersal sale. Dixie Colantha Hartog, born in 1917, was purchased for $700, the highest sale price. Dixie would establish the Hartog family at Mount Victoria and set a Canadian record for milk production for several years. 

The Hulet Estate Sale in 1925 provided two more members of the “Big Six.” Lady Meg Posch, described in the pre-sale promotion as one of the top show prospects of the offering, was acquired for $1,000, the sale’s top price. Bonheur Abbekerk Posch 2nd, born September 23, 1924, was also purchased at this sale. These two cows would become the cornerstones of the Posch and Bonheur families, respectively. 

The final “Big Six” member joined the herd in 1928, when Macaulay made his most audacious purchase yet. At the National Ormsby Sale in Minneapolis, he acquired Triune Papoose Piebe for $11,100. This cow, already famous for her show ring success, would become one of the most distinguished female show winners of all time, claiming All-American honors for six consecutive years. 

Together, these six cows formed the backbone of the Mount Victoria breeding program. Their descendants would dominate show rings and milk production records for decades, with their influence still felt in modern Holstein pedigrees worldwide. The “Big Six” story is a testament to Macaulay’s vision and ability to identify exceptional animals. By bringing together these diverse but complementary bloodlines, he created a herd that would redefine the Holstein breed and leave a lasting legacy in the world of dairy cattle breeding.

Part of the senior section of the Mount Victoria show herd, 1926. Left to right: Countess Amelia Posch, with five first prizes, including 2-year-old in milk class at the Royal; Lady Meg Posch, four firsts, including dry 3-year-old at the Royal; Ingleside Pietje Posch, Reserve Grand Champion once; Oakhurst Colantha Abbekerk, five-time Grand Champion, including at the Royal, and Reserve All-American aged cow; Johanna Rag Apple Pabst, All-American for four consecutive years and six-time Grand Champion, including at the Royal.

The Impact on the Breed

The influence of Mount Victoria Farms on the Holstein breed is a tale of genetic dominance that spans continents and decades. What began as one man’s vision in Quebec, Canada, would go on to reshape dairy cattle populations worldwide in ways that even Thomas Bassett Macaulay could scarcely have imagined.

By the late 1950s, Mount Victoria genetics had already had a staggering impact. An estimated 90% of Canadian Holsteins could trace their lineage to this remarkable herd. But the story doesn’t end there. Today, it’s widely acknowledged that every registered Holstein globally carries Mount Victoria blood, showcasing the profound impact of Macaulay’s breeding program.

The global spread of Mount Victoria genetics occurred through several channels. In the years following World War II, as countries sought to rebuild their agricultural sectors, there was a surge in demand for high-quality Holstein genetics. Mount Victoria descendants, particularly those of the legendary Johanna Rag Apple Pabst, were in high demand.

The impact was profound in Europe. Countries with strong dairy traditions, such as the Netherlands, Germany, and Italy, imported Mount Victoria bloodlines to improve their herds. The result was a marked improvement in milk production and, crucially, butterfat percentages. In the 1960s and 1970s, European breeders reported significant increases in butterfat tests, often attributing this improvement to the influence of Mount Victoria genetics.

South America saw a similar revolution. In countries like Brazil and Argentina, where dairy farming was expanding rapidly, Mount Victoria’s descendants played a key role in establishing high-producing herds. The adaptability of these genetics was particularly noteworthy, as they seemed to thrive even in the diverse climates of South America.

In Australia and New Zealand, where dairy farming is a cornerstone of the agricultural economy, Mount Victoria bloodlines contributed to a new era of productivity. Farmers reported improvements in milk yield and longevity, a trait Macaulay had emphasized in his breeding program.

Even in Asia, where dairy farming was less traditional, Mount Victoria’s influence was felt. As countries like Japan and South Korea developed their dairy industries in the latter half of the 20th century, they often turned to North American genetics, with Mount Victoria descendants prominently featured.

The impact of Mount Victoria breeding went beyond just production traits. The emphasis on strong udder conformation, a hallmark of Macaulay’s breeding philosophy, led to significant improvements in udder health and milking efficiency worldwide. This focus on functional type would prove particularly valuable as the global dairy industry moved towards more intensive production systems.

Perhaps most remarkably, the influence of Mount Victoria genetics has endured. Even in the age of genomic selection and advanced reproductive technologies, the foundational impact of this herd continues to be felt. Top show winners and high-producing cows worldwide often trace their pedigrees back to Mount Victoria multiple times, a testament to the enduring quality of these genetics.

Mount Victoria’s impact on the Holstein breed is not just a story of numbers and percentages. It’s a story of how one breeder’s vision and scientific approach created a genetic legacy that transformed dairy farming, improved farmers’ lives, and contributed worldwide food security. Mount Victoria’s influence stands as a compelling testament to how focused breeding can have profound and enduring impacts, fundamentally shaping the future of a breed.

GET OF MONTVIC PATHFINDER: All-American get of sire, 1941. Left to right: Montvic Duchess Abbekerk, Montvic Bonheur Emily, Montvic Bonheur Pietje B., and Montvic Bonheur Dale.

Global Influence

The impact of Johanna Rag Apple Pabst on the Holstein breed transcends mere statistics or pedigrees. His influence sparked a genetic revolution that reshaped dairy cattle breeding worldwide, leaving an indelible mark on the industry that persists. Born in 1921 on Philip Linker’s farm in Hartford, Wisconsin, “Old Joe,” as he came to be known, was destined for greatness from the start. His sire, Pabst Korndyke Star, and dam, Princess Johanna Rag Apple Pontiac, were both exceptional producers, foreshadowing the genetic potential that lay within their son. 

When Thomas B. Macaulay purchased Johanna Rag Apple Pabst for the then-astronomical sum of $15,000 in 1926, few could have predicted the seismic shift this bull would bring to the dairy world. Macaulay’s vision of creating a strain of Holsteins with consistently high butterfat percentages found its perfect vehicle in Old Joe. 

Significant genetic progress occurred when Johanna Rag Apple Pabst was bred with carefully selected foundation females at Mount Victoria Farms. The resulting progeny, particularly those from the Posch-Abbekerk bloodlines, was phenomenal. These offspring combined the high production and excellent conformation of their sire with the strong dairy characteristics of their dams, creating a new standard for the Holstein breed. 

As news of the exceptional qualities of the Rag Apple descendants spread, breeders from across North America and beyond sought to incorporate this bloodline into their herds. The demand for Rag Apple genetics skyrocketed, with bulls and cows commanding premium prices at sales and auctions. 

In Canada, the combination of Johanna Rag Apple Pabst’s bloodlines with those of another influential sire, King Toitilla Acme, proved particularly potent. This blend of genetics produced animals that excelled in the show ring and the milk parlor, setting new benchmarks for the breed. 

A sire’s greatness is truly tested by the achievements of his descendants over generations. In this regard, Johanna Rag Apple Pabst’s legacy is unparalleled. His sons and grandsons became influential sires in their own right, spreading the Rag Apple influence far and wide. Notable among these were Montvic Rag Apple Abbekerk, Montvic Rag Apple Sovereign, and Montvic Bonheur Rag Apple, each leaving their mark on herds across the continent. 

By the late 20th century, almost every registered Holstein worldwide could be traced back to Johanna Rag Apple Pabst, showcasing his widespread influence. This level of genetic saturation is unprecedented in livestock breeding and speaks to the enduring quality of the traits Old Joe passed on to his descendants. 

The Rag Apple revolution wasn’t confined to North America. As dairy farming modernized globally in the post-World War II era, many countries looked to import superior genetics to improve their local herds. Rag Apple bloodlines became highly sought after, with descendants of Johanna Rag Apple Pabst going to Europe, South America, Japan, and New Zealand. 

Johanna Rag Apple Pabst’s influence can still be seen in dairy barns worldwide nearly a century after his birth. His legacy is a testament to the power of selective breeding and the profound impact that one exceptional animal can have on an entire industry. The Rag Apple bloodline, born from the vision of Thomas B. Macaulay and the genetic potential of Old Joe, remains a cornerstone of modern Holstein breeding. It is a living legacy of a bull that genuinely changed the face of dairy farming forever.

Get of CRESTON GRAND MAJESTY (VG-GM): All-American get of sire, 1958 and 1959, Reserve in 1957, for Christ A. Mayer, Slinger, Wisconsin. Mayers Mistress Dark Anna (EX), at left, was dam of the highly-rated Mayers Dark Leader (GP-ST), a Wis Leader (EX-GM) son proven at Central Ontario Cattle Breeding Assoc., Maple, Ontario, ‘Then four cows, all classified Excellent, were all from Glenafton Rag Apple Ambassador dams. Ambassador was a son of Abegweit Showdown (son of Abegweit Milady) and out of the 1167-Ib. Jasmine Pabst Meg Posch (VG), a Montvic Pabst Rag Apple daughter.

Lessons for Modern Breeders

The story of Mount Victoria Farms and Thomas Bassett Macaulay offers a wealth of inspiration and lessons for today’s dairy breeders. This tale of an insurance executive turned cattle breeder revolutionizing the Holstein industry is a testament to the power of innovation, determination, and scientific thinking in agriculture. 

Vision and Goal-Setting

Macaulay began with a clear, ambitious vision: to create a strain of Holstein cattle that consistently produced milk with 4% butterfat while maintaining excellent conformation. This goal, considered nearly impossible then, guided every decision he made in his breeding program. Modern breeders can learn from Macaulay’s example by setting specific, measurable goals for their herds and aligning all breeding decisions with these objectives. 

Data-Driven Selection 

Macaulay’s background as an actuary gave him a unique perspective on cattle breeding. He meticulously recorded and analyzed data on each animal in his herd, using this information to make informed breeding decisions. His office walls were covered with pedigree charts and production records, and he developed a complex system of index cards to track the performance of each animal and its relatives. 

This data-driven approach allowed Macaulay to identify the most promising animals for his breeding program and make objective decisions about which traits to prioritize. Today’s breeders have access to even more sophisticated genetic analysis tools, but the principle remains the same: objective, data-driven selection is key to consistent genetic progress. 

Scientific Rigor in Breeding 

Macaulay approached breeding with the exactitude and rigor of a seasoned scientist. He was well-versed in the works of Gregor Mendel and applied the principles of genetics to his breeding program. His experiences in corn breeding directly influenced his methods in cattle breeding, demonstrating the application of scientific principles across disciplines. 

One of Macaulay’s most innovative practices was using “progeny testing” long before it became standard in the industry. He would hold back promising young bulls and breed them to a select group of cows, then wait to evaluate the offspring before deciding whether to use the bull more widely. This patient, data-driven approach starkly contrasted with the prevalent practice of selecting bulls based solely on their pedigree or appearance. 

Challenging Conventional Wisdom 

Macaulay’s late entry into Holstein breeding at 69 allowed him to approach the industry with fresh eyes. He wasn’t bound by traditional practices or preconceived notions about how things should be done. This outsider perspective enabled him to challenge conventional wisdom and develop innovative breeding strategies. 

For example, while many breeders of his time feared inbreeding, Macaulay understood its power to concentrate desirable traits when combined with rigorous selection. He carefully planned matings to increase the frequency of genes for high butterfat production and excellent conformation, balancing this with strict culling to avoid the pitfalls of inbreeding depression. 

Patience and Persistence 

Macaulay dedicated nearly two decades to building the Mount Victoria herd into a world-class breeding program. He understood that genetic improvement is a long-term process and was willing to invest the time and resources necessary to achieve his goals. 

Macaulay’s patience extended to his breeding decisions. He was willing to wait to see the results of his choices, often holding onto promising animals for multiple generations to evaluate their genetic potential fully. This long-term perspective allowed him to make sustained genetic progress over time. 

Holistic Approach to Breeding 

While many breeders of his era focused on production or conformation, Macaulay insisted on improving both simultaneously. He believed that genetic progress could only be achieved by selecting all economically important traits. This holistic approach to breeding resulted in animals that excelled in the show ring and the milk parlor, setting a new standard for the breed. 

Mount Victoria Farms’ legacy demonstrates that remarkable animal breeding results can be achieved with vision, scientific rigor, and unwavering dedication. As modern breeders face new challenges, including the need for increased efficiency, improved health traits, and adaptation to changing climates, Thomas Bassett Macaulay’s example continues to offer valuable lessons in innovation, persistence, and the power of applying scientific principles to the art of cattle breeding. 

The Bottom Line

 Thomas Bassett Macaulay stands as a testament to the profound impact one visionary breeder can have on an entire breed. Through careful selection, innovative breeding practices, and an unwavering commitment to improvement, Macaulay created a genetic powerhouse that reshaped the Holstein breed worldwide.

Key points that underscore Mount Victoria’s greatness include: 

  1. The acquisition and strategic use of Johanna Rag Apple Pabst, whose influence became so pervasive that every registered Holstein today carries his blood.
  2. The development of influential cow families like the Bonheurs, Colanthas, and Hartogs produced generation after generation of superior animals.
  3. The creation of breed-defining sires like Montvic Pathfinder, whose descendants dominated show rings and milk production records for decades.
  4. The focus on high butterfat percentages helped redirect the industry’s attention towards producing milk components.
  5. Applying scientific principles to breeding sets a new standard for the industry.

Mount Victoria’s influence exceeded its herd, shaping breeding programs in North America and worldwide. The farm’s dispersal in 1942 scattered these valuable bloodlines, allowing countless other breeders to benefit from Macaulay’s work. Perhaps most importantly, Mount Victoria demonstrated the power of a clear vision, scientific approach, and long-term commitment in achieving remarkable genetic progress. Macaulay’s willingness to challenge conventional wisdom and his patient, data-driven approach to breeding inspire breeders today. 

In the annals of Holstein history, Mount Victoria Farms is one of the most significant breeding establishments. Nearly a century after its founding, its influence is still felt in dairy barns worldwide. Mount Victoria’s story powerfully illustrates how one breeder’s vision and dedication can shape a breed’s future, leaving a legacy that spans generations.

Key Takeaways:

  • Thomas B. Macaulay, an insurance executive, founded Mount Victoria Farms in Quebec in 1899 at age 44.
  • Macaulay began breeding Holsteins 1924 at age 69, applying his analytical skills from actuarial work to cattle breeding.
  • He purchased the influential bull Johanna Rag Apple Pabst in 1926 for $15,000, which became the cornerstone of his breeding program.
  • Macaulay focused on developing a strain of Holsteins with consistently high butterfat (4%+) while maintaining good conformation.
  • He used scientific breeding methods, including line breeding, inbreeding, and rigorous selection.
  • Key foundation cows included the “Big Six”: Oakhurst Colantha Abbekerk, Ingleside Pietje Posch, Dixie Colantha Hartog, Lady Meg Posch, Bonheur Abbekerk Posch 2nd, and Triune Papoose Piebe.
  • Mount Victoria developed influential cow families and sire lines that shaped the Holstein breed globally.
  • By the late 1950s, over 90% of Canadian Holsteins traced back to Mount Victoria breeding.
  • Today, it’s believed every registered Holstein worldwide carries some Mount Victoria blood.
  • Macaulay’s scientific approach to breeding set new standards for the dairy cattle industry.

Summary:

Mount Victoria Farms, founded by Thomas Bassett Macaulay in Quebec, Canada, became one of Holstein’s most influential breeding establishments. Macaulay developed bloodlines that continue to impact the global Holstein population through careful selection, innovative breeding practices, and a focus on high butterfat production. The cornerstone of his breeding program was Johanna Rag Apple Pabst, purchased in 1926, whose descendants dominated show rings and milk production records for decades. Macaulay’s scientific approach to breeding, combining his background as an actuary with genetic principles, led to the creation of influential cow families like the Bonheurs, Colanthas, and Hartogs. The impact of Mount Victoria genetics extended far beyond Canada, shaping breeding programs worldwide. By the late 1950s, over 90% of Canadian Holsteins could trace their lineage back to Mount Victoria, and today, it’s believed that every registered Holstein in the world carries some Mount Victoria blood.

Learn more:

Join the Revolution!

Bullvine Daily is your essential e-zine for staying ahead in the dairy industry. With over 30,000 subscribers, we bring you the week’s top news, helping you manage tasks efficiently. Stay informed about milk production, tech adoption, and more, so you can concentrate on your dairy operations. 

NewsSubscribe
First
Last
Consent

Discover the New Changes in December 2024 CDCB Evaluations

Check out the December 2024 CDCB Evaluations. Learn about updates on RFI, NM$ trends, and Brown Swiss evaluations. Keep up to date.

Summary:

The December 2024 CDCB evaluations introduce significant advancements in dairy cattle genetics, focusing on precision and transparency. Updates include an increased protein coefficient for Residual Feed Intake (RFI), aligning with the Nutrient Requirements of Dairy Cattle and impacting only 16 animals with changes greater than 1. The strategic exclusion of certain crossbred animals stabilizes Net Merit Dollars (NM$) trends, resulting in breed-specific evaluations reflective of true genetic potential. The integration of international evaluations for Brown Swiss Rear Teat Placement enhances genomic predictions. The new ‘Powered by CDCB’ logo reinforces data integrity and transparency, providing farmers with reliable evaluations for informed breeding strategies, thereby optimizing herd productivity and profitability.

Key Takeaways:

  • The updated protein coefficient in Residual Feed Intake (RFI) calculations aligns with modern industry standards, ensuring more accurate evaluations.
  • Excluding crossbred animals from Net Merit $ (NM$) trends offers a clearer and more stable evaluation for breed-specific trends, especially for Ayrshire and Milking Shorthorn.
  • Incorporation of international data for Brown Swiss Rear Teat Placement enhances the precision and global relevance of evaluations.
  • The introduction of the ‘Powered by CDCB’ logo aims to increase transparency and confidence in genetic evaluations by highlighting their independent and data-driven origins.
  • CDCB’s dedication to high-quality data collection and analysis supports the reputation of U.S. genetic evaluations as a global benchmark.
dairy cattle genetics, CDCB evaluations December 2024, Residual Feed Intake RFI, Net Merit Dollars NM$, genetic purity in cattle, Brown Swiss Rear Teat Placement, genomic predictions accuracy, dairy breeding strategies, herd productivity improvements, transparency in genetic evaluations

As the dairy industry braces for transformation, the December 2024 CDCB evaluations emerge as a beacon of progress, illuminating pathways for more precise genetic predictions. These updates are not just routine markers; they signify a profound evolution essential for dairy farmers and industry professionals. At the core of this year’s evaluations are the adapted calculations for Residual Feed Intake, the integration of international data for Brown Swiss traits, and the strategic exclusion of certain crossbreds in Net Merit $ trends. “The impact of these evaluations on genetic progress is like a domino effect – improving one element can redefine breeding strategies nationwide,” commented Paul VanRaden. These changes collectively influence breeding decisions that can ripple through the entire industry. For those seeking to navigate the intricate landscape of genetic evaluations, the implications of these updates are expansive, demanding attention and action. Understanding the nuances of these updates is critical, as they align with contemporary nutritional standards and enhance the reliability of genetic evaluations on a global scale. Dairy professionals who grasp these developments position themselves at the forefront of a competitive market, armed with the knowledge to make informed, innovative breeding decisions.

Refining Precision: A Closer Look at the Updated RFI Protein Coefficient

The updated calculation for Residual Feed Intake (RFI) reflects an increased protein coefficient in determining milk energy content, from 5.63 to 5.85. This subtle adjustment aligns with the Nutrient Requirements of Dairy Cattle, ensuring accuracy by adhering to the latest industry standards. Although this revision might appear minor, its impact on genetic evaluations is significant—it enhances precision without drastically altering results. The comparison between original and updated protein coefficients yielded a correlation of over 0.999 in Predicted Transmitting Abilities, demonstrating minimal disruption, with only 16 animals experiencing a change more significant than 1 in their evaluations. Such updates are crucial because they maintain the integrity and relevance of genetic evaluations amid evolving nutritional guidelines. By ensuring genetic evaluations reflect current nutritional realities, dairy producers can rely on them for informed decision-making in breeding and management strategies, reinforcing the evaluations’ utility and credibility.

Paving the Way for Purity: The Strategic Exclusion of Crossbred Animals in NM$ Trends

In removing crossbred animals from the Net Merit Dollars (NM$) trends, the CDCB has marked a significant shift toward more stable and accurate breed-specific evaluations. The exclusion focuses on animals with uncertain genetic backgrounds, which have often muddled the NM$ trends, creating inconsistencies in understanding breed performance. By clearly defining a cutoff heterosis value of 50%, this adjustment ensures that only animals with verified genetic purity contribute to the trend analysis. 

The decision has yielded promising results for breeds like Ayrshire and Milking Shorthorn. The August 2024 test run highlighted a notably steadier NM$ trend for these breeds, demonstrating a newfound reliability for dairy farmers focused on genetic precision. This consistency means that farmers can make more informed decisions, relying on evaluations that reflect the true genetic potential of individual breeds without the distortion caused by crossbred influences. 

The implications for dairy farmers are profound. As the industry gravitates towards precision agriculture, having access to accurate breed-specific data becomes crucial for breeding strategies and economic planning. It empowers farmers to make breeding decisions based on dependable evaluations that align closely with their herd’s genetic goals. This change could foster renewed confidence in the CDCB’s evaluations, urging more farm operations to base their decision-making on data that genuinely reflects breed integrity and potential productivity.

Global Integration for Precision: Elevating Brown Swiss Evaluations

The integration of international evaluations for Brown Swiss Rear Teat Placement marks a significant advancement in the accuracy and reliability of genetic assessments within the breed. Including international data allows for a broader scope of genetic information, ensuring that evaluations are nationally and globally aligned. This approach enhances the precision of genomic predictions, making them more comprehensive and reflective of worldwide genetic diversity. 

Incorporating international data into the U.S. evaluation process underlines the benefits of cooperative data sharing and standardization, fostering improvements in overall trait evaluation results. This integration ensures that bull and cow evaluations are enriched with Multi-country Assessment Coefficient (MACE) evaluations when international Predicted Transmitting Abilities (PTA) reliabilities surpass domestic figures. Thus, producers receive a robust dataset that reinforces confidence in breeding decisions. 

Moreover, correcting format flaws in the Jersey breed evaluations highlights the CDCB’s commitment to precision and accuracy. Flaws in the formatting of the bulls’ files, which previously hindered the proper implementation of MACE-based Rear Teat Placement and type composites, have now been rectified. This ensures that the information used for Jersey cattle is current, accurate, and in line with international standards, leading to more reliable data for breeders to act upon.

A Mark of Integrity: Unveiling the ‘Powered by CDCB’ Logo 

The unveiling of the Powered by CDCB logo signifies a pivotal moment for the U.S. dairy sector, as it underscores a commitment to transparency in genetic evaluations. This emblem guarantees that the genetic data utilized in breeding and managerial decisions is sourced from an objective and independent process. The assurance comes from the CDCB’s stewardship of the National Cooperator Database, where unbiased data offers producers a reassuring degree of reliability. 

By incorporating this mark, the CDCB reinforces the integrity of its evaluations, much like the impact of the REAL® Seal on dairy products. As João Dürr, the CEO of CDCB, eloquently puts it, the mark connects producers with the quality and objective nature of the genetic information they trust. The ‘Powered by CDCB’ logo is also a beacon of the collaborative industry effort that strengthens the services and results associated with the CDCB’s work. This initiative is pivotal in ensuring that producers receive comprehensive and credible genetic evaluations and recognize the quality assurance embedded within the data cultivated through contributions by their herds.

The Bottom Line

The December 2024 CDCB evaluations herald pivotal advancements in dairy cattle genetics. From recalibrating the RFI protein coefficient to strategically excluding crossbred animals in NM$ trends, these changes reflect a commitment to precision and purity. The integration of international data for Brown Swiss evaluations marks a new era in global collaboration, while the ‘Powered by CDCB’ mark enhances transparency and trust. 

These developments offer dairy farmers and industry professionals substantial opportunities to refine breeding strategies and management practices. Stakeholders can elevate herd productivity and profitability by aligning with these enhanced evaluation metrics. 

We encourage you to delve deeper into these updates and consider their potential impacts on your operations. For comprehensive guidance and support, explore additional resources and industry insights by visiting the social media channels at www.uscdcb.com and the Council on Dairy Cattle Breeding.

Learn more:

Join the Revolution!

Bullvine Daily is your essential e-zine for staying ahead in the dairy industry. With over 30,000 subscribers, we bring you the week’s top news, helping you manage tasks efficiently. Stay informed about milk production, tech adoption, and more, so you can concentrate on your dairy operations. 

NewsSubscribe
First
Last
Consent

Katie Shultz to Receive First-Ever Richard Caverly Memorial Dairy Award at World Dairy Expo

Learn how Katie Shultz‘s passion for dairy farming earned her the first Richard Caverly Memorial Dairy Award. What makes her story so inspiring?

dairy farming, Richard Caverly Memorial Dairy Award, young dairy farmers, cow breeding expertise, mentorship in dairy, Chambersburg Pennsylvania dairy, Ayrshires and Milking Shorthorns, dairy cattle genetics, Katie Schultz dairy journey, dairy industry recognition

Imagine dedicating your life to dairy farming, honing your skills, and nurturing the next generation, only to be recognized with an award that reflects your unwavering commitment. Katie Shultz of Chambersburg, Pennsylvania, is set to receive the inaugural Richard Caverly Memorial Dairy Award. This prestigious accolade, established in memory of dairy legend Richard Caverly, celebrates young individuals aged 18 to 30 who embody Richard’s exceptional cow sense, passion for dairy cattle breeding, and dedication to mentoring future enthusiasts. Katie’s involvement with various breeds, advocacy for genomic testing, and guidance from novice dairy producers testify that she deserves this honor. Join us as we delve into her remarkable career and contributions to the dairy industry.

Richard Caverly: A Legacy of Excellence and Mentorship in Dairy Farming

Richard Caverly, renowned in the dairy sector, devoted his life to dairy cattle showing and mentoring future dairy enthusiasts. Richard was born and raised in Cornville, Maine, and had a strong interest in dairy farming. His inherent “cow sense” and dedication to farming became apparent early in his career, distinguishing him in the dairy industry. His work with award-winning cattle, particularly the famed Glenamore Gold Prize EX-97-6E—nicknamed “Prize”—solidified his reputation.

Aside from showing cattle, Richard was a strong champion for young development in the dairy business. He thought that the future of dairy farming hinged on well-trained and enthusiastic young farmers. Richard often took young breeders under his wing, providing hands-on experience and vital insights. His passion for coaching the next generation made an unforgettable impression on everyone who had the opportunity to learn from him.

The Richard Caverly Memorial Dairy Award, a testament to Richard’s enduring influence, was established by his friends and admirers. This award, which honors individuals between 18 and 30 who embody Richard’s values of ethics, dairy cow breeding achievement, and youth mentoring dedication, ensures that his legacy of passion and dedication continues to inspire future generations.

Katie Shultz: Cultivating Her Path from Dairy Novice to Industry Luminary 

Katie Shultz’s dedication to the dairy industry is truly inspiring. Her journey began in adolescence and has blossomed into a successful profession. She manages a small herd of Ayrshires and Milking Shorthorns with Dr. Jeffrey McKissick, showcasing her versatility in rearing numerous breeds such as Brown Swiss, Guernseys, Red & Whites, and Holsteins. She lives in Chambersburg, Pennsylvania, with her fiancée, Brian Reichard, and their son Brock.

Her passion and expertise in breeding and cattle ranching have garnered 32 Junior and Open All-American nominations. Katie’s debut appearance with an Ayrshire at the World Dairy Expo in 2014 marked the start of her rise in the business. She has spent the past decade honing her skills as a cow fitter, gathering experience via sales, shows, and barn trimming. Katie learned significant skills in breeding, producing, and presenting superior cattle while maintaining the integrity of the business while working under Micheal Heath’s supervision.

In addition to her hands-on work with cattle, Katie is an online marketing specialist for Cowbuyer. She interacts with herds nationwide, employing her extensive industry expertise to link buyers and sellers efficiently. Her diverse position in practical and digital dairy farming areas demonstrates her extensive skill set and commitment to advancing the profession.

The Unsung Hero: A Testament to Katie Shultz’s Expertise and Mentorship

One nominator praised Katie’s vast knowledge of pedigrees and great recollection of where, when, and how much cattle went for and who presently owns them. It was highlighted that she shares Caverly’s firm view that Ayrshire breeders must employ genomitc testing. “All Ayrshire cattle that Shultz works with are genomic tested to add to the breed’s database while making sound breeding decisions,” the person who submitted the nomination said.

Another nominator praised Shultz’s commitment to youth development in the dairy business, writing, “Katie is a great champion for youth development in the dairy industry. She routinely offers fitting workshops for young individuals who must develop experience and confidence before fitting their cattle. Katie is devoted to enabling youngsters to participate in performances, often accompanying and assisting them. She gives hands-on training, enabling the kids to learn by doing while still being there to provide assistance and answer questions.”

Shultz’s most important contribution may be her one-on-one mentorship. Her collaboration with Hannah Gingerich serves as an excellent illustration of this. Hannah attended the World Dairy Expo and NAILE with her heifer to exhibit and learn under Shultz’s supervision. She joined Shultz’s squad and traveled to the Western Spring National in Utah and the Maryland State Fair. Katie has been teaching Hannah clipping procedures, bagging schedules, troubleshooting, and other skills, ensuring that Hannah feels confident and competent in her abilities. Shultz’s commitment to teaching and fostering emerging talent such as Hannah distinguishes her in the profession.

A Symbol of Excellence: The Prestigious Traveling Trophy and Commemorative Plaque

This outstanding prize comes with a one-of-a-kind traveling trophy: a wooden sculpture of Glenamore Gold Prize EX-97-6E created and given by Scott Hussey, Richard Caverly’s close friend. Richard’s favorite bovine was “Prize,” a five-time Grand Champion at the Royal Winter Fair in Toronto, Canada, representing quality and commitment to dairy production. Each receiver is privileged to care for this beautiful work of art, recognizing their part in carrying on Caverly’s legacy.

Award recipients are presented with a commemorative plaque as a lasting reminder of their accomplishments and an embroidered item of their choosing to personalize the award.

The 2024 Richard Caverly Memorial Award ceremony will be held on Thursday, October 3, at 10 a.m., at the World Dairy Expo in Madison, Wisconsin. The presentation will take place near the renowned globe outside the Coliseum. It will be moved to the World Dairy Expo Media Room at New Holland Pavilion 1 in adverse weather. This magnificent event celebrates the honoree and brings together the dairy community to celebrate industry success and mentoring.

The Bottom Line

Katie Shultz exemplifies the Richard Caverly Memorial Dairy Award, which recognizes unmatched devotion to dairy farming, a commitment to teaching the next generation, and unshakable honesty. Her accomplishments, mentoring, and support for genetic testing represent the principles that Richard Caverly upheld. Katie’s rise from dairy beginner to acknowledged industry expert is a tribute to her dedication and commitment.

Mentorship is crucial in determining the future of the dairy business. Katie continues to mentor new enthusiasts like Hannah Gingerich, imparting technical skills while instilling confidence and love for dairy farming. Consider the industry’s potential growth if more experienced individuals spend time mentoring the next generation.

If Richard Caverly’s legacy or Katie Shultz’s story has inspired you, please consider contributing to the Richard Caverly Memorial Dairy Fund. Your gift contributes to continuing initiatives to develop new talent in the dairy sector. To give, go to the RCMDF Facebook page or contact Committee Chair Jim Strout for further details. Together, we can continue to promote development and quality in this critical area.

Join the Revolution!

Bullvine Daily is your essential e-zine for staying ahead in the dairy industry. With over 30,000 subscribers, we bring you the week’s top news, helping you manage tasks efficiently. Stay informed about milk production, tech adoption, and more, so you can concentrate on your dairy operations. 

NewsSubscribe
First
Last
Consent

STUD WARS: Which AI Company Holds the Power in the Dairy Cattle Genetics Universe

Find out which AI company is the leader in dairy cattle genetics. Compare the top sires and see who really dominates the industry. Who has the most power in this genetic competition?

A long time ago in a galaxy not so far away, the fate of dairy cattle genetics was firmly in the hands of farmers and breeders. Today, the balance of power has shifted dramatically. Artificial Insemination (AI) companies now command unrivaled control over the genetic future of dairy herds worldwide. Much like the interstellar battles in Star Wars, these AI giants wield incredible influence, shaping the destiny of dairy cattle and the dairy industry. But one question remains: Who holds the most power among these titans? 

As these companies duel with pedigree charts in one hand and genomic test results in the other, the landscape of dairy cattle genetics has become a battleground for supremacy. Each AI company claims to have the best sire lineups. Like the legendary clashes between the Sith and the Jedi, only one can truly dominate the genetic universe. So, let’s embark on this journey to uncover which AI company reigns supreme.

TPI

URUSSelect SiresABSSemexSTgenOther
Proven TPI1630108315
Genomic TPI9324242011
TPI256214325116

Select Sires holds the largest market share at 31%, featuring a well-balanced group of both proven and genomic sires. Hot on their heels is STgen with a 25.5% share, boasting the strongest proven sire TPI lineup. Semex completes the top studs with a 16% market share, driven by an impressive genomic sire lineup.

NM$

ListURUSSelect SiresABSSemexSTgenOther
Proven NM$1718244325
Genomic NM$2564342011
NM$422428385216

STgen shows impressive strength with a 26.5% share of top NM$ sires. Meanwhile, URUS steps up with a robust NM$ lineup, claiming 21% of the top sires. Rounding out the top, Semex holds a solid 19% and a very strong genomic NM$ sire lineup.

PTAT

URUSSelect SiresABSSemexSTAscolBlondin SiresOther
Proven PTAT774224111530
Genomic PTAT597121612930
PTAT1216111440232460

STgen leads the PTAT rankings with a commanding 20% market share, showcasing a robust lineup of proven sire PTATs. Next is the specialist AI stud Blondin Sires, which boasts the second strongest lineup, combining both proven and genomic lists, capturing a 12% share. Completing the top three, Ascol holds a 12.5% share, demonstrating its impressive offerings.

Red & White

Alta GeneticsSelect SiresABSSemexSTAscolBlondin SiresOther
Red & White41052156742

When it comes to the most diverse list of top Red & White PTAT sires, Semex takes the lead with 21% of the top sires. Right behind them are Select Sires with 10% and ST with 13%.

Polled

Alta GeneticsSelect SiresABSSemexSTOther
Polled61513222222

Similar to the Red & White list, the top 100 polled sires feature a diverse range of ownership. A notable shift from the past is that major AI companies have now significantly strengthened their lineups. Semex and ST each command 22%, closely followed by Select Sires at 15%.

Genomic Sire Lineup

Alta GeneticsSelect SiresABSSemexSTOther
49723311383155

When it comes to the major players in the genomic sire market, Semex undeniably takes the lead, boasting a formidable 22% of the top genomic sires. Trailing behind them is STgen with 16%, and Select Sires at 14%. This marks a significant shift from our previous analysis when Select Sires held the top position with 19%, followed by ABS Global at 18%, and STgen at 14%. Semex has clearly upped their game, immensely strengthening their genomic lineup.

Proven Sire Line Up

Alta GeneticsSelect SiresABSSemexSTOther
405538148766

In the proven sires’ category, STgen is leading the pack, boasting 29% of the top sires. Trailing behind, Select Sires holds an 18% share, while Alta Genetics and ABS are tied at 13%. It’s also worth noting that Semex, with a 5% share, explains why they have been focusing heavily on genomic sires to revamp their overall lineup.

Overall Line Up

Alta GeneticsSelect SiresABSSemexSTOther
8912771127170216

STgenetics leads the pack with a commanding 21% share of the top sires. Their robust genomic and proven lineup underscores the value of ongoing investment in superior genetics. Tied for second place are Select Sires and Semex, each holding 16% of the top sires with 127 entries apiece. Despite arriving at the same percentage, they employ markedly different strategies. Semex has ramped up their genomic investments to compensate for a relatively weaker proven lineup compared to their competitors. Interestingly, our analysis reveals a significant shift in the last couple of years. ABS, previously holding an 18% share, now only 9%. Meanwhile, Ascol and Blondin Sires have each doubled their market share from 2% to 4%.

The Bottom Line

The genetics universe of dairy cattle is vast and continuously evolving. Our journey through the galaxies of TPI, NM$, PTAT, Red & White, Polled, Genomic, and Proven Sire Lineups has revealed the power dynamics of the major players and the emergent contenders. STgen, Semex, ABS Global, and the Select Sires federation remain strong forces, innovating and adapting their strategies to maintain dominance. Meanwhile, new entrants like Blondin Sires and Ascol are trying to shake the status quo, offering tantalizing glimpses of the future. 

As you navigate the cosmic landscape of dairy cattle genetics, the key takeaway is balancing both proven and genomic sires. Keeping an eye on emerging trends, understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each player, and making informed decisions will steer your herd toward stellar success. The universe may be unpredictable, but you can chart a course toward prosperity with the right choices. May the force of informed decision-making be with you!

Summary: The landscape of dairy cattle genetics is evolving rapidly, with major players like STgen, Select Sires and Semex, and new entrants such as Blondin Sires and Ascol making significant strides across various segments. While traditional metrics like TPI and NM$ still hold weight, the focus on specialized categories such as Red & White, Polled, and genomic sires shows a dynamic shift towards more targeted breeding strategies. Companies like Validity Genetics are carving out notable shares, particularly in the genomic Polled segment, indicating a competitive and diverse market. This evolving competition among Artificial Insemination companies highlights the increasing importance of niche segments and innovative genetic offerings, reshaping the power dynamics in the dairy cattle genetics universe.

Forget Genomics – Epigenomics & Nutrigenomics are the Future

Two months ago I had one of those conversations. A friend said to me “you know Murray I am moving on from just simple genomics”. That perked my ears up and I listened more intently. “Yep I am now thinking about epigenomics”, he said. Well that was enough to set me off investigating what is out there that is beyond what our industry is currently considering and using when it comes to genomic.  Relax a little, this may seem like rocket science today, but it is in tune with what our industry has always done in the past.  We look to find more accurate ways of indentifying the elite animals. Then we figure out how knowing that information gives us ways to make dairy breeders and dairy farming more profitable.

Already Many Steps Too Far?

So now ‘epigenomics’ was pinned to my clipboard. But I didn’t get any further before I had a Master Breeder husband and wife corner me for half an hour and ‘inform’ me that “The Bullvine was leading the industry astray”. They stated to me that “they were from Missouri” and perhaps we should “still only be using the actually officially authenticated information – DHIR records and breed classification results – when it comes to selecting bulls and marketing females.  They asked how can we know that the hair pulled and submitted for DNA testing actually came from said animal.” I have known this couple for almost forty years so I took the discussion on to a review great cows of the past and how they would not compare to the great show and brood cows of today. As we started to conclude our conversation the lady, who had been somewhat quiet during our sharing, commented “You (Murray) have a good point about how the genetic evaluation results over our lifetimes have resulted in the fact that we have far superior cows for both conformation and production, but our herd’s current biggest genetic problem is cows not getting back in calf. We just do not now get to have very many ten year old and older cows in our herd, liked we used to.” That gave me the opportunity to talk to them about genomics and having fairly reliable information, early in an animal’s life, on its genetic merit for reproductive traits.

The husband’s concluding comment warmed my heart. “Our grandson plans to come home to our family farm and he tells us that at university his professors are saying the information we have today on genomics is just the start. So don’t give up on us old guys. You folks at The Bullvine just keep giving us the facts and helping the industry do an even better job of breeding dairy cattle. We don’t own a computer but our family keep us quite up-to-date on what The Bullvine is writing about.”  Obviously this couple are not as set in their ways as they led me to understand at the start of the conversation.

So if we have just scratched the surface, let’s delve a little deeper.

Epigenomics – What’s That?

By definition, epigenomics is the study of modification of the expression of the genetic material in a cell. Sounds rather out of the norm. Something can alter what the DNA says is the genetic merit of an animal? Let’s think that through a bit more.

As cattle breeders we can all think of times when three full sisters all had very similar performance. And I expect many of us can also remember situations where two of the sisters were very similar but the third sister just did not measure up to the other two.  The question that breeders always ask is did the third one not get the good genes, or did she get the good genes but something inhibited her from being able to express them.  I have even heard very knowledgeable breeders say that the third one will breed just a good as the other two.  How they arrived at that conclusion I am not really certain. But I have seen it happen as they predicted.

Research in mice has shown that the diet of a sire can influence the gene expression of their progeny. So that fits under the definition of epigenomics. Dr. Jacques Chesnais of Semex feels that “there is a definite possibility that epigenomics plays as important role in adaption to the environment. In particular, in our industry, the way we feed and treat a cow in the early stage of pregnancy could affect the calf for a lifetime and therefore affect the future productivity of the herd.” Hearing that made me wonder if the recipient dams of ET calves may have an influence on how those calves pass on their genetics.

Leaders in the study of epigenomics in livestock Dr Marc-Andre Sirard and Dr Claude Robert, Laval University, are currently  investigating how epigenomics applies to the bovine and in particular to female reproduction and embryo development. It will be interesting to follow their reports.

There is obviously much to be studied and learned about epigenomics in the bovine. Definitely traits like reproduction, health and immunity are ones that dairy breeders wish to know more about as they relates to inheritance.

So then – What is Nutrigenomics?

The second new kid-on-the-block, so to speak, is nutrigenomics. The study of the effects of foods and food constituents on gene expression. By definition “Nutrigenomics can be described as the influence of genetic variation on nutrition, by correlating gene expression or SNPs with a nutrient’s absorption, metabolism, elimination or biological effects.” Think about it. If we know the genetic make-up of our dairy cows we would be able to design their diets accordingly. Are there cows out there that can make better use of lower quality forages? Wouldn’t that be a boon for the economics of dairy farming. Especially given that feed costs are 52-58% of total dairy enterprise costs and low quality forages are less costly.

I asked two nutritional consultants about this. I got two very different responses. The first one said – “don’t bring that on too quickly I still have another ten to fifteen years in my working career”. The other consultant said “Well it would change my job but if it means dairy farming can be profitable and sustainable and if we can feed the hungry world – well bring it on”.

Expect Genetics to Play an Even Bigger Role in the Future

Investigation by Canadian Dairy Network (CDN) has predicted that, in stable milk pricing times and on milk production focused farms, half of the increased on-farm profits comes from increasing the genetic merit of sires and cows used to produce the next generation of females.  With a better understanding and more definitive knowledge of epigenomics and nutrigenomics it could possibly be that 60+% of on-farm profits could be as a result of the genetics used.

From the DNA analysis using hair follicles, breeders now know with 50-70% accuracy the genetic merit of their animals for a host of important traits. Think what might be possible if by including epigenomics and nutrigenomics information. The accuracy levels could rise to 70-80%.

The Bullvine Bottom Line

The research phase of studying how epigenomics and nutrigenomics relate to the dairy cow is well underway. We can expect refinements to our genetic evaluation procedures based on what the research tells us.  And in time breeders will have information so they can better breed, feed and manage their herds. Stay tuned to the Bullvine for more great insight into these two future changing technologies.


The Dairy Breeders No BS Guide to Genomics

 

Not sure what all this hype about genomics is all about?

Want to learn what it is and what it means to your breeding program?

Download this free guide.

 

 

 

Flukes and Pukes – What Happens When You Don’t Have a Plan

Sure when a mating works out you say you planned it or it was the result of a great mating decision.  But what do you say when it doesn’t work?  Most of the time you blame the sire.  In reality, you cannot leave your breeding programs to chance.  If you do you are just as likely to end up with a puke as you are to get a great one by a fluke.

No matter what your breeding goals are you need to have a plan (Read more: What’ the plan?).  Recently there has been a lot of discussion resulting from our interview with Don Bennink (Read more:  North Florida Holsteins: Aggressive, Progressive and Profitable and The Truth About Type and Longevity). Bennink does not look at type when making his mating decisions.  Instead, Don uses the following criteria when selecting what herd sires to use:

  • 60 pounds or more of protein
  • 5 or above for  PL
  • 1 or above for DPR
  • 2.9 or less for SCC
  • 8 or below for Calving Ease

While some of us may not agree with Don’s filters for which sires he uses, there is no arguing that he has a very clear plan.  A clear plan that is based on what works for the management style and profitability of his North Florida Holsteins.  .

While many breeders dream about getting a cow that looks like this

While many breeders dream about getting a cow that looks like this

The problem with many breeders’ breeding programs is that they don’t have a plan that centers around the way their farm makes money.  Think about it.  How often do you select a mating sire for the reasons you typically cull animals, as opposed to what your perceived ideal cow looks like?  Sure when it works and you get that great show cow you claim that it was planned and was a result of years of thought and that you have cattle sense.  BS to that.  Unless you set out a clear plan for your herd, then claims that these animals are a result of great “dairysense” are just bull.  Trust me I have walked through herds and asked them, what the “iffier” looking ones are sired by and more often than not they blame it on the sire not working instead of taking responsibility for not having a plan and making smart breeding decisions.

The reality is they should be breeding for something like this

The reality is they should be breeding for something like this

Sure flukes do happen.  But, even in the show ring these days, I  see less and less flukes and more and more show winners coming from generations of great breeding that have had careful thought put into exactly which  sire  to use.  For most of these herds that does mean using the high type sire that is obviously getting the job done.  But if you are like most breeders you are not making your money selling show winners.  Your money is coming from those that deliver the most milk, as efficiently as possible, and last for multiple lactations.  So tell me why don’t your sire selection filters reflect this production goal?

Now you ask me, “Andrew how do you know that we are not doing this?”  and my answer to that is pretty simple.  Most breeders are not looking at fertility and SCS  as their top two filters, and yet those are the top two reasons most cows are culled from the herd (Read more: FACT VS. FANTASY: A Realistic Approach to Sire Selection). Instead I hear comments like she needed more dairy strength as a key issue.  Did you know four out of the top five sires for dairy strength are below +1000 kg.  of milk.  And four of the five are also negative on at least protein% or fat% deviations.  So I ask you how much does dairy strength correlate to overall production?

The Bullvine Bottom Line

Don’t get me wrong there are herds that have done very well and been very profitable breeding for high type generation after generation.  Two great examples are Ferme Jacobs (Read more: Ferme Jacobs: Success Is All In The Family!) and Quality Holsteins (Read more: Quality Holsteins – Well-deserved Congratulations and Quality Cattle Look Good Every Day).  Both these herds have bred for type generation after generation and have amazing high conformation herds to visit.  But that is because they had taken a lot of time and energy to carefully plan out how they will make money and how their breeding program will map to it, instead of the other way around.  The big lesson is that instead of leaving everything to chance you need to have a plan, otherwise all you will end up with are the flukes and pukes.

 

Not sure how much to spend on that great 2 year old or heifer?
Want to make sure you are investing your money wisely?
Download our Dairy Cow Investment Calculator.

 

 

Send this to a friend