Why are cheese prices climbing when production is falling? What does this mean for your dairy business? Get the latest insights for September 15, 2024.

Summary:

Welcome to the Weekly Dairy Outlook for September 15th, 2024. This week, we observe notable changes in the cheddar cheese market, highlighted by a surge in barrel prices on the CME cash market. Domestically, cheddar cheese production is declining, creating a limited supply environment that has pushed futures prices upwards. The USDA’s latest report indicates mixed results across different dairy products, with daily cheese and butter production experiencing fluctuations and powder production showing a significant downtrend. With the dry whey market experiencing a remarkable price increase due to plummeting production levels, dairy farmers face a volatile landscape. Understanding these trends and responding strategically is crucial to navigating this dynamic market.

Key Takeaways:

• Cheddar cheese supply remains tight, causing a surge in barrel prices on the CME cash market.
• Cheese futures rose by six ¢/lb, while butter futures dropped by 2.7 ¢/lb, impacting the implied six-month protein strip to increase by 23 ¢/lb.
• USDA reported a 1.9% increase in total cheese production in July 2024 compared to July 2023 but a 0.6% decline from June 2024.
• Cheddar cheese production has decreased significantly from last year and the previous month, affecting component pricing in the FMMOs.
• In July, the daily production of Nonfat Dry Milk (NDM) and Skim Milk Powder (SMP) declined by 10.4% combined year over year.
• Daily butter production was up compared to July 2023 but significantly down from June 2024.
• Dry whey production fell sharply, explaining the recent spike in dry whey prices.
• Unexpected decline in whey protein concentrate production due to changes in the processing stream.

Have you felt the pressure of the recent surge in cheddar prices this week? This is not just a statistical blip; it’s a seismic shift reverberating throughout the dairy sector. With domestic cheddar cheese output declining, traders are bracing for a sustained shortage. This isn’t just a short-term issue; it’s a long-term change that could affect everything from farm operations to consumer prices. A 6¢/lb increase in cheese futures for the next six months signals a persistent tightening of cheddar supplies. So, what does this mean for you and the entire dairy industry? Let’s delve into the facts to understand the full impact of this price surge.

Cheddar Market Dynamics: Surge, Scarcity, and Strategic Moves 

The cheese market has been extremely active lately, with barrel prices on the CME cash market rising significantly. This move is consistent with emerging indications of declining domestic cheddar cheese output. You may question what is causing these developments.

Traders are responding to various causes, the most notable of which is a shortage of cheddar cheese. Given the relatively shallow cash markets, even little changes in supply and demand may cause considerable price variations. The recent jump in barrel prices implies that traders expect this tight supply scenario to persist for the foreseeable future. Cheese futures for six months have risen by 6¢/lb, indicating market restrictions in the long run.

The USDA’s July Dairy Products report sheds further light on the situation. The figures reveal a noticeable decrease in daily cheddar cheese output compared to last year and the prior month. This decrease emphasizes the ongoing product shortage, which concerns those constantly following the market. The supply problem is crucial since cheddar is essential for component pricing in Federal Milk Marketing Orders (FMMOs). Traders are wagering that the issues causing low output will not resolve fast, resulting in these price increases. This could lead to higher consumer prices, affecting your business and the market as a whole.

Understanding these factors provides a better sense of why market players anticipate prolonged supply constraints. The ripple effects are apparent, and awareness may help you navigate these rough seas more efficiently.

USDA Dairy Products Report: Deciphering the Shifts in Cheese Production 

It identifies possible supply chain challenges that dairy farmers and industry stakeholders must solve quickly to stabilize and improve market conditions.

Regarding American-style cheese, the daily production figures reflect a slight rise of 0.6% from June 2024 but a 1.6% decrease compared to July last year. While central to the American diet, this specific type of cheese has shown a modestly inconsistent production pattern over recent months.

However, the most critical takeaway from this data concerns cheddar cheese. This staple’s production fell noticeably, year over year and month over month. Cheddar cheese output declined from July 2023 and saw a 1.9% drop from June 2024. This decrease is significant as cheddar cheese is pivotal in component pricing within Federal Milk Marketing Orders (FMMOs). The ongoing tightness in the cheddar cheese supply is likely causing ripples across the market, contributing to the observed price volatility.

This divergence in cheddar cheese production from the broader cheese output trend suggests industry-specific challenges, including input costs, labor availability, or shifts in consumer demand. The significant decline in cheddar underscores the importance of closely monitoring production trends directly impacting pricing mechanisms and market stability. Your vigilance in this area is crucial for the industry’s future.

Overall, while general cheese production shows resilience with a slight upward trend, the significant drop in cheddar cheese production raises red flags. It highlights potential supply chain issues that dairy farmers and industry stakeholders must address promptly to stabilize and enhance market conditions.

Butter Gains Amid Powder Pressures: Navigating the Dairy Sector’s Divergent Trends 

The patterns provide fascinating information about butter and powder manufacturing. Daily butter output increased compared to July 2023, demonstrating resiliency and expanding demand in the local market. This growth suits people in the butter industry since it reflects strong customer preferences and perhaps improved processing efficiency.

In contrast, the powder industry presents an entirely different image. Production of nonfat dry milk (NDM) and skim milk powder (SMP) fell 10.4% from July of the previous year. While SMP production has been stable since June 2024, the reduction indicates a tightness in supplies that might affect local and international markets. This trend may indicate changing demand pressures, necessitating strategic responses from dairy farmers supplying milk for these powders.

The Whey Factor: Prices Soar Amid Production Plunge 

The most recent figures on whey production raise a few questions. Notably, the sharp decrease in dry and whey protein concentrate output in July piques your interest. You’re probably wondering what this means for you and the industry.

Let us break it down. Dry whey output fell in July compared to last year and the prior month, causing a spike in dry whey pricing. It’s hardly unexpected. When supply is low, fundamental economics tells us prices will increase, particularly in a sensitive market.

The more surprising trend is a decrease in whey protein concentrate output. Conventional thinking held that the stream of wet whey would be more effectively steered toward greater protein concentrates, but the facts indicate a different tale. This kind of variance might indicate various issues, such as operational inefficiencies or fluctuations in market demand. Regardless, the conclusion undermines market stability, making it more challenging to forecast future price changes.

There are several meanings here. On the one hand, rising dry whey pricing may assist producers in the near term by increasing margins in an otherwise challenging market. However, the uncertainty complicates an already turbulent market. If you’re in the whey industry, whether manufacturing or sourcing, this is a trend you can’t afford to overlook.

Market instability makes strategic decisions even more critical. Are you contemplating changing your manufacturing to match these trends? Do you have any backup plans for pricing fluctuations? It is essential to keep these questions in mind as you plan for the future.

Strategic Steps for Dairy Farmers in a Volatile Market 

Looking forward, our findings suggest a more complicated and competitive dairy market. The rise in cheddar prices, fueled by a scarcity of supply, signals that volatility will persist. Farmers may see increased income if they can capitalize on the rising pricing. However, maintaining profits requires good manufacturing cost management.

Furthermore, the minor drop in cheese output, particularly in essential kinds such as cheddar, indicates the necessity for strategic modifications. Dairy producers must now optimize their operations by diversifying their dairy product offerings or investing in new technology to improve efficiency and production. For instance, they could consider producing more of other types of cheese or investing in automated milking systems to increase production. These strategic moves can help them navigate the changing market conditions.

The significant decline in NDM and SMP output might provide new export opportunities on the powder front. While this is a great opportunity, it also carries substantial risk. Export markets are highly competitive and susceptible to global economic swings, such as trade regulations and currency exchange rates.

Butter’s uneven performance necessitates a cautious balancing. While daily output increases compared to last year, the recent monthly fall suggests that stocking tactics are crucial. Farmers and industry experts should carefully track inventory levels to minimize overstock and waste.

Finally, the whey market demonstrates the uncertainty of dairy output. With dry whey output down and prices rising, dairy processors may investigate if reallocating wet whey streams will alleviate supply concerns and fulfill market needs more efficiently. This necessitates a flexible supply chain and a thorough awareness of industry trends.

In conclusion, remaining ahead in the dairy industry requires adaptation, strategic planning, and innovation. Whether it’s shifting manufacturing emphasis, improving export capabilities, or streamlining supply chains, the path ahead is fraught with problems and opportunities.

Broader Economic Forces at Play: What Dairy Farmers Need to Know 

Understanding the more significant economic dynamics influencing dairy output and pricing is critical. Let’s look at some of the essential variables that are driving our industry today.

Feed Costs

Feed prices remain a big worry for dairy producers. Feed costs have risen due to commodity price fluctuations and disruptions caused by climate change. High maize and soybean prices have especially stressed profits. Are your input costs higher than last year? If so, you are not alone. A collaborative approach to managing these expenditures might be a game changer.

Labor Shortages 

Labor shortages affect several industries, including dairy farming. The sector faces two challenges: an aging workforce and a scarcity of fresh workers. According to the USDA, the agriculture sector’s available workforce has decreased 7% over the last year [source link]. How are you tackling this challenge? Automation and better work conditions may relieve some, but the transformation will not occur quickly.

Global Trade Dynamics

Global trade dynamics are another essential aspect. Tariffs, international trade agreements, and geopolitical concerns may significantly change the environment. For example, current trade talks with China and the European Union have substantial ramifications. Because American dairy exports are significant, any interruption might affect the whole supply chain. Keeping an eye on these trends will allow you to anticipate and adjust.

These broader economic considerations create a challenging but manageable situation. Understanding and addressing these issues may help your business prepare for the road ahead. How are you going to address these difficulties in your business?

Let’s Talk About What These Market Tremors Mean for Your Bottom Line 

Let’s speak about how these market shocks affect your bottom line. With the rise in cheese prices, many dairy producers may see an excellent opportunity. Higher cheddar prices may increase income in the near term, making it more straightforward to meet operational expenses and invest in much-needed renovations. But, before you start rejoicing, consider the long term.

Declining cheese output is more than a transient blip; it has far-reaching consequences that might harm your farm’s profitability. If we continue along this route, scarcity in the market may push prices further higher. While this seems to be a positive development, it also increases market volatility. Such instability may make planning and forecasting very difficult. Long-term scarcity may also improve competitiveness and lead to more laws and control.

What exactly does this imply for you? It is critical to use the present high pricing strategically. Consider allocating part of the excess cash to resilience-building efforts. Diversification, investment in technology, and improving operational efficiency may be your best options for navigating future risks. Remember that taking a proactive approach today might result in more accessible sailing later.

The Bottom Line

Reflecting on recent market developments, the dairy industry is experiencing tremendous instability and strategic adjustments. Cheddar cheese output is declining significantly, resulting in a price increase and signaling that supply will remain tight. According to a recent USDA study, cheese and butter production has fluctuated. Still, the output of dry whey and skim milk powder has decreased significantly. To successfully navigate the present situation, dairy producers must prepare ahead of time and make intelligent modifications.

As we look forward, evaluate how continued supply restrictions and altering production patterns will impact the dairy industry’s future terrain. Will innovation help to offset these issues, or will established techniques hold up? Your current tactics will dictate your future success.

Learn more:

• 2024’s Shocking Milk Price Trends: Declining Production and Surprising Market Gaps
• Markets are not Bullish or Bearish, but Indecisive: Cheese Stocks Shrink Amid Soaring Milk Demand
• How Cheese Exports and China’s Demand are Powering the US Dairy Economy in 2024

Join the Revolution!

Bullvine Daily is your essential e-zine for staying ahead in the dairy industry. With over 30,000 subscribers, we bring you the week’s top news, helping you manage tasks efficiently. Stay informed about milk production, tech adoption, and more, so you can concentrate on your dairy operations.