In February 2025, dairy margins will be pressured as milk prices stagnate and corn costs surge. Record cheese exports to Mexico are at risk due to retaliatory tariffs, while new processing plants offer hope. Farmers must navigate this volatile landscape with strategic risk management and proactive planning to maintain profitability.
Summary:
The first half of February 2025 presents a complex landscape for U.S. dairy farmers, with margins holding steady to slightly weaker amid stagnant milk prices and volatile feed costs. While 2024 saw record cheese exports, particularly to Mexico, retaliatory tariff threats now jeopardize this crucial market. Corn prices have surged 12% month-over-month, squeezing margins, though soybean meal costs have declined. Production shifts favor Italian-style cheeses, with mozzarella output surpassing 6 billion pounds annually. New processing plants coming online offer potential relief, but their success hinges on preserving export markets. Farmers face critical decisions on risk management, including optimizing Dairy Margin Coverage and exploring feed hedging strategies. With projected margins between $10.14-$12.47/cwt, the industry must navigate trade uncertainties, adapt to changing consumer preferences, and leverage emerging opportunities in functional dairy and sustainability-focused products to maintain profitability in 2025.
Key Takeaways:
- Dairy margins remain under pressure in early February 2025, with milk prices stagnant and corn costs up 12% month-over-month.
- Record cheese exports in 2024 (1.13 billion pounds) face threats from potential retaliatory tariffs, especially from Mexico.
- Production is shifting towards Italian-style cheeses, with mozzarella surpassing 6 billion pounds annually.
- New processing plants add capacity but success depends on maintaining export markets.
- Farmers need to optimize risk management strategies, including Dairy Margin Coverage and feed hedging.
- Regional disparities in feed costs and climate impacts require tailored management approaches.
- The delayed 2024 Farm Bill negotiations create uncertainty for policy support.
- Consumer trends favor functional dairy and sustainability-certified products.
- Strategic imperatives include securing tariff exemptions, adopting component-first breeding, and pre-booking summer feed.
- Projected all-milk price for 2025 is $23.05/cwt (+2.7% YoY), offering cautious optimism amidst volatility.
Dairy margins faced sustained pressure in the first half of February 2025 as milk prices stagnated, corn costs surged 12% month-over-month, and retaliatory tariff threats jeopardized record cheese exports to Mexico. While USDA data confirmed 2024 as a banner year for dairy exports (1.13 billion pounds of cheese shipped globally), farmers now navigate a precarious landscape of geopolitical risks, shifting consumer demand toward Italian-style cheeses and the highest feed costs since 2022. With margins projected between $10.14-$12.47/cwt and new processing plants coming online, strategic risk management becomes critical for profitability.
Market Dynamics: Prices, Production, and Policy Crosscurrents
Milk Prices and Feed Cost Squeeze
Class III milk futures held near $20.01/cwt for February contracts but fell 1.2% in deferred months, reflecting concerns over softening demand and rising input costs. Corn prices jumped to $4.9325/bu (March 2025 futures), while soybean meal dipped marginally to $10.5875/bu—a divergence complicating ration planning. The USDA projects 2025 feed costs to decline 10.1% annually but warns of regional disparities: Midwest operations pay 15-20% less for feed than Western farms grappling with lingering drought impacts.
Michael Harvey, RaboResearch Senior Analyst:
“Feed volatility remains the wildcard. While global grain stocks improve, logistical bottlenecks and climate-driven yield variations create localized price spikes that erode margins1.”
Cheese Exports: Record Highs Meet Retaliation Risks
December 2024 set a monthly cheese export record at 96.7 million pounds (+21.2% YoY), with Mexico accounting for 38% of annual shipments. However, Mexico’s inclusion of cheese on its retaliation list for U.S. steel/aluminum tariffs threatens $950 million in annual trade. New U.S. processing plants add 8 billion pounds of capacity—enough to absorb 2-3% more domestic milk production if exports falter.
Production Shifts and Inventory Pressures
American-style cheese output fell 3.9% in 2024, while Italian varieties like Mozzarella (+3.6%) surpassed 6 billion pounds annually. Cheddar production hit a four-year low, reflecting consumer preference shifts toward pizza and prepared foods. Butter inventories grew 7% yearly, contributing to a 2¢/lb price decline in early February, while dry whey plummeted 8.9% weekly on weak export demand.
Trade Policy: Tariff Moratoriums and Farm Bill Uncertainty
U.S.-Canada Dairy Tariff Standoff
A 30-day hold on reciprocal tariffs temporarily relieved markets, but Canada’s threat of $1.2 billion in retaliatory measures keeps markets on edge. The dispute centers on Canada’s dairy TRQ (Tariff Rate Quota) system, which the U.S. claims unfairly restricts access. With $450 million in annual dairy exports to Canada at stake, farmers fear prolonged negotiations could disrupt spring milk checks.
Mexico’s Retaliation List and Export Alternatives
Mexico’s proposed 20-25% tariffs on U.S. cheese would slash processor margins by $0.15-$0.20/lb, forcing buyers to source from the EU or New Zealand. However, Southeast Asia offers growth potential:
- Philippine cheese imports rose 14% in 2024
- Vietnam’s milk powder demand increased 10% YoY
Risk Management Strategies for Volatile Margins
Beginning February 2025, dairy farmers will need to pay close attention to both costs and pricing to make informed financial decisions. Understanding the intricacies of milk pricing is key, and this is where the current Class 4(m) prices come in. These prices, effective from February 1 to February 28, 2025, hold specific significance for your risk management strategies.
| Milk Class | Butterfat ($/kg) | Proteins ($/kg) | Other Solids ($/kg) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4(m) | Provincial 4(a) butterfat price | 3.3503 | 3.3503 |
This table offers current, specific pricing information that could be valuable for farmers considering risk management strategies. By being proactive with these data points, you can position your farm for more resilient financial health amid market fluctuations.
Dairy Margin Coverage (DMC) Adjustments
With projected 2025 DMC payments $8.9 million lower than 2024 (-12%), farmers must optimize coverage:
- Update Production Histories: Leverage USDA’s one-time adjustment to reflect 2019-2024 output
- Layer LGM-Dairy: Combine DMC with Livestock Gross Margin insurance for price upside
- Monitor Class IV Markets: Butter ($2.40/lb) and NDM ($1.30/lb) stability supports component-focused hedging.
Feed Procurement and Storage Tactics
- Lock in 40-60% of Q2 corn needs via $4.68/bu December 2025 futures
- Consider sorghum-sudangrass hybrids for drought-prone regions
- Utilize USDA’s Feed Cost-Share Program (launched Jan 2025), covering 15% of silage storage costs
Regional Spotlights: Herd Management and Climate Adaptation
Understanding the regional differences in profitability is crucial for dairy farmers as it allows them to benchmark and strategize effectively. By analyzing specific data, you can gain valuable insights into how your region compares to others. The table below provides concrete data on regional differences in profit per cow and the key drivers influencing these figures:
| Region | Profit per Cow | Key Driver |
|---|---|---|
| Southeast (>5000 cows) | $1,640 | Operational Efficiency |
| Northeast (large herds) | $1,625 | Market Access |
| Southeast (<250 cows) | $531 | Improved Margins |
Midwest Advantage
Proximity to corn/soybean hubs cuts feed costs by $1.50/cwt vs. Western farms. Genetic gains drive milk solids growth:
- Butterfat: +0.1% monthly
- Protein: +0.05% monthly
Southwest Recovery Challenges
Though the percentage of drought-affected herds dropped to 12% (from 23% in 2024), forage quality remains subpar. The USDA reports that 18% of Texas dairies now use methane digesters to offset energy costs, a 7% annual increase.
Northeast Production Headwinds
Severe winter storms disrupted 8% of February milk shipments, compounding labor shortages (34% of farms report unfilled positions). Robotic milker adoption rose 12% YoY, with ROI periods shrinking to 4.5 years.
Looking Ahead: Policy, Innovation, and Consumer Trends
2024 Farm Bill Implications
Delayed negotiations threaten DMC updates, including:
- Raising the 5-million-pound coverage cap to 8 million
- Adding cheese whey as a risk-adjustment factor
Functional Dairy and Sustainability Demands
Consumer trends favoring A2 milk, probiotics, and carbon-neutral labeling drive innovation:
- Danone’s “Digestive Health” yogurt line grew 22% in 2024
- 48% of millennials pay premiums for dairy from methane-certified farms
Conclusion: Strategic Imperatives for Q2 2025
Dairy farmers enter spring cautiously optimistic—record exports and improved feed costs vie with geopolitical risks and margin compression. Key actions include:
- Secure Tariff Exemptions: Engage co-ops to lobby for cheese as an “essential trade” in NAFTA renegotiations
- Adopt Component-First Breeding: Prioritize butterfat/protein yields over volume
- Pre-Book Summer Feed: Hedge 50% of July-September corn at $4.70-$4.85/bu
The USDA forecasts an all-milk price of $23.05/cwt (+2.7% year over year), so proactive operators can turn volatility into opportunity.
Learn more:
- Efficient Energy Practices: A Guide for Dairy Farmers
- Solar Energy Revolution on European Dairy Farms: Navigating Hurdles and Reaping Benefits
- Key Factors for Dairy Farmers Evaluating Anaerobic Digester Proposals: Essential Tips for Dairy Farmers
Join the Revolution!
Join the Revolution!Bullvine Daily is your essential e-zine for staying ahead in the dairy industry. With over 30,000 subscribers, we bring you the week’s top news, helping you manage tasks efficiently. Stay informed about milk production, tech adoption, and more, so you can concentrate on your dairy operations.
