New Zealand’s dairy giants aim to crack India’s fortress-like market in just 60 days. Will 70 million small farmers pay the price?
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: New Zealand and India have launched an ambitious 60-day push to finalize a free trade agreement that had stalled for a decade, specifically over dairy market access. Prime Minister Luxon has clarified that New Zealand wants its world-leading dairy exporters to penetrate India’s protected market of 1.4 billion consumers, currently shielded by 30-60% tariffs. The negotiations pit industrial efficiency against the livelihoods of 70 million small Indian dairy farmers in what could become the most consequential dairy trade deal in years. The agreement’s timing coincides with mounting global trade tensions, including Trump’s reciprocal tariff threats against India. For North American dairy producers, the potential redirection of New Zealand exports could create significant ripple effects in global markets, potentially impacting farm-gate prices and competitive dynamics.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Historic Market Barrier Targeted: India’s 60% tariff on milk powder imports—one of the world’s highest—faces unprecedented pressure as New Zealand demands agricultural access it has never granted in previous trade deals
- Global Dairy Flow Disruption: If successful, the agreement could redirect significant volumes of New Zealand dairy exports away from traditional markets, creating ripple effects in regions where North American producers compete
- Fundamental System Clash: The negotiations represent a confrontation between New Zealand’s export-oriented industrial efficiency and India’s fragmented network of smallholder farmers with 2-3 cows per farm
- Specific Market Vulnerabilities: U.S. dairy exports of milk powder to Southeast Asia, specialty ingredients to Latin America, and cheese to Mexico and Japan face the highest risk from potential market shifts
- Strategic Timing: Both countries are responding to changing global trade patterns, with India accelerating agreements to cushion against Trump’s tariff threats while New Zealand seeks to diversify beyond reliance on China
The world order of dairy is about to be upended. As you’re reading this, negotiators are frantically working to finalize what could be the most consequential dairy trade agreement of the decade.
New Zealand’s Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has brazenly announced a 60-day deadline to crack open India’s fortress-like dairy market—home to 70 million small producers and the world’s most extensive milk production base.
Make no mistake: this isn’t just another trade deal announcement—it’s a calculated power play by the world’s most efficient dairy exporters to gain access to the world’s most extensive untapped dairy consumer base.
“I just don’t want us to give up on dairy. We will try and find a way to make dairy work.” — New Zealand’s Prime Minister Christopher Luxon.
The stakes? Nothing less than the future structure of the global dairy trade and potentially YOUR farm’s bottom line. Here’s what dairy insiders need to know about this high-stakes dairy diplomacy unfolding.
DECADE-LONG STANDOFF FINALLY BREAKS: THE RUSH TO SIGN
After a ten-year freeze in negotiations, India and New Zealand have dramatically restarted talks for a comprehensive Free Trade Agreement. Previous negotiations between 2010 and 2015 collapsed precisely over the issue that matters most to Bullvine readers: dairy market access.
“Let’s drive this relationship forward, and I look forward to signing that agreement with Prime Minister Modi in 60 days,” declared New Zealand’s Prime Minister Luxon to business leaders, setting perhaps the most ambitious timeline ever for resolving this deeply contentious trade relationship.
This isn’t merely ambitious—it’s borderline audacious. Trade negotiations of this complexity typically drag on for years, not weeks.
The accelerated timeline signals extraordinary political will at the highest levels to overcome obstacles that previously proved insurmountable.
GOLIATH TARGETS SACRED COWS: Can 70 Million Indian Farmers Withstand the Export Onslaught?
Do you think your operation faces competitive pressure? Imagine competing against the world’s most efficient dairy export machine without the protection of tariffs you’ve relied on for decades.
New Zealand, home to Fonterra, the world’s largest dairy exporter, has clarified its intentions. In a startlingly direct statement to Radio New Zealand, Prime Minister Luxon declared: “I just don’t want us to give up on dairy. We are going to try and find a way to make dairy work”.
“No free trade agreement is ever negotiated with a gun on anybody’s head.” — Piyush Goyal, India’s Trade Minister.
This unambiguous push for dairy access directly opposes India’s long-established policy of protecting its domestic dairy sector.
Indian negotiators have consistently resisted pressure to lower tariffs ranging from 30% to 60% on agricultural products, particularly dairy, arguing such concessions could threaten the livelihood of millions of small farmers.
For context: while New Zealand’s dairy industry operates with industrial efficiency and export-oriented scale, India’s dairy sector remains dominated by smallholders with just 2-3 cows per farm, often providing their sole steady income source.
VOICES FROM THE BARN: Producer Perspectives on the Trade Face-Off
“This trade push is fundamentally asymmetric. Our cooperatives took decades to build India’s self-sufficiency in milk. Opening floodgates to subsidized imports would devastate millions of families dependent on dairying.” — Dr. R.S. Sodhi, former Managing Director, Amul (Gujarat Cooperative Milk Marketing Federation)
“New Zealand farmers produce to world-class environmental and animal welfare standards. We believe in fair trade based on our natural competitive advantages, not government protection. Access to growth markets like India is crucial for future-focused farmers.” — Andrew Hoggard, Past President of Federated Farmers of New Zealand
“We’ve seen what happens when markets open overnight – small farmers pay the price. Our 70 million producers aren’t just economic units, they’re families with generations of dairying tradition that can’t be replaced.” — Kuldeep Sharma, President, Indian Dairy Association
THE TARIFF BATTLEGROUND: Numbers That Matter
DAIRY DOMINANCE AT A GLANCE:
- India’s Protection Wall: 30-60% tariffs on dairy imports
- India’s 2025 Production Forecast: 216.5 million metric tons (MMT)
- Trade Growth Target: 10-fold increase within a decade
- Current Bilateral Trade: $1.54 billion in 2023-24; $1.2 billion in 2024 (different reporting periods)
The following verified data from USDA’s October 2024 Dairy Products Annual report for India reveals exactly what barriers Fonterra and other New Zealand exporters are fighting to dismantle:
Table 1: India’s Current Dairy Import Tariffs
| Product | HS Code | Basic Custom Duty | Import Policy |
| Milk and cream (not concentrated) | 0401 | 30% | Free with sanitary requirements |
| Milk powder/concentrated milk | 0402.10 | 60% | Free with sanitary & BIS requirements |
| Butter and milk fats | 0405.10/0405.90 | 40% | Free with sanitary requirements |
| Lactose and lactose syrup | 1702.11/1702.19 | 25% | Free |
| Albumins/whey proteins (>80% protein) | 3502 | 20% | Free |
“India maintains one of the highest dairy tariff regimes in the world, with most-favored-nation rates of 30-60% effectively insulating domestic producers from international competition.” — USDA Foreign Agricultural Service, 2024 India Dairy Annual
Table 2: India’s Tariff Rate Quotas for Key Dairy Products
| Product Description | HS Code | Quota Quantity (MT) | In-Quota Tariff | Out-of-Quota Tariff |
| Milk powder | 0402.10/0402.21 | 10,000 | 15% | 60% |
| Butter and other fats | 0405.10 | 15,000 | 0% | 30% |
| Dairy spreads | 0405.20 | 15,000 | 0% | 40% |
DAIRY TRADE TERMINOLOGY: Quick Reference Guide
MFN Rates — “Most Favored Nation” tariffs represent the standard rate countries charge on imports from WTO members when no special trade agreement exists.
HS Codes — The “Harmonized System” codes are standardized numerical classifications for traded products used worldwide by customs authorities.
Tariff Rate Quotas — These allow a certain quantity of product (the quota) to enter at a lower tariff rate, while imports beyond that quantity face higher tariffs.
Non-Tariff Barriers — Requirements beyond tariffs that restrict trade, such as licensing, labeling, quality standards, or certification requirements.
India deliberately excluded the dairy sector from ALL its previous free trade agreements to shield its small farmers, making New Zealand’s demand exceptional and potentially precedent-setting.
The USDA notes that India’s 60% most-favored-nation (MFN) tariff on dairy imports is “one of the highest in the world,” effectively shielding domestic producers.
Beyond tariffs, India maintains stringent non-tariff barriers, including certification requirements that imported dairy products must come from cows never fed animal-derived feed. This Hindu dietary norm has prevented many exporters from penetrating the market.
Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal has acknowledged the sensitivity, noting that both countries can “easily navigate few areas where there are sensitivities or respect each others’ sensitivities given the different levels of development and prosperity in each country.”
However, the question remains: what constitutes “navigating” these sensitivities when New Zealand’s primary objective is dairy access?
MARKET ACCESS BATTLEFIELD: A Timeline of Dairy Diplomacy
- 2010-2015: Initial FTA negotiations stall specifically over dairy access demands
- 2018: Fonterra’s “Dreamery” joint venture with Future Consumer in India collapses after struggling with supply chain and market penetration
- March 2025: Negotiations dramatically restart with a 60-day deadline
- May 2025: Projected signing date (if deadline holds)
Goyal offered the diplomatic assurance that “no free trade agreement is ever negotiated with a gun on anybody’s head.” Yet the accelerated timeline and New Zealand’s unwavering focus on dairy access suggest unprecedented pressure is being applied.
GLOBAL CONTEXT: Why This Deal Is Happening Now
This sudden urgency doesn’t exist in a vacuum. The renewed push comes against mounting global trade tensions, particularly after US President Donald Trump imposed reciprocal tariffs on imported goods from several countries, including India.
The “reciprocal tax” strategy is designed to match the import duties imposed by trading partners on American goods. Critics point to India’s high tariff structure, particularly in sectors like agriculture and dairy.
If implemented, such a reciprocal tax would dramatically increase the average U.S. tariff on Indian goods, which currently stands at around 3–4%, bringing it closer to India’s tariff levels.
India is simultaneously accelerating efforts to secure trade agreements with the European Union and the United Kingdom, suggesting a strategic pivot in response to changing global trade patterns.
India represents a critical market diversification opportunity for New Zealand, which has traditionally relied heavily on China as an export destination.
“Both countries have massive aspirations… to do exceptionally well for both of our countries in the years and decades ahead.” — Christopher Luxon, Prime Minister of New Zealand.
WHAT THIS MEANS FOR NORTH AMERICAN DAIRY
This potential agreement represents both a threat and an opportunity for North American dairy producers. Should New Zealand secure preferential access to India’s massive consumer market, it could redirect significant export volumes away from traditional markets where you compete.
NORTH AMERICAN IMPACT: Specific Market Vulnerabilities
According to an analysis from the U.S. Dairy Export Council (USDEC), these specific product categories face the highest risk from potential market shifts:
- Milk Powder Markets: Southeast Asian destinations where U.S. and New Zealand exporters directly compete could see increased New Zealand supply if Indian exports absorb current NZ volumes.
- Specialty Ingredients: If New Zealand redirects its product away from regions like Latin America, it could face intensified competition in high-value whey proteins and milk protein concentrates.
- Cheese Exports: Mexico and Japan—key U.S. cheese export destinations—could be impacted if global trade flows shift in response to new India-New Zealand dynamics.
“What happens between New Zealand and India won’t stay between New Zealand and India,” warns Krysta Harden, President and CEO of USDEC. “Any major shift in how the world’s largest dairy exporter allocates its product will create ripple effects across all dairy-importing regions where U.S. suppliers compete.”
Industry analysts project potential price impacts of 3-5% on globally traded dairy commodities if significant volumes of New Zealand products are redirected to India, with whole milk powder markets likely seeing the most immediate effects.
According to USDA data, major Indian dairy companies like Amul and Mother Dairy have already raised fluid milk prices due to rising operational and procurement costs.
In 2023, average milk prices in India increased by over 12 percent compared to 2022 due to milk shortages and rising production costs.
How will introducing New Zealand’s ultra-efficient production into this price-sensitive market reshape global dairy flows?
WHO WINS, WHO LOSES: Sector Impact Analysis
| SECTOR | WINNERS | LOSERS |
| Commodity Producers | Low-cost, large-scale NZ operators | Small-scale Indian farmers, especially in fluid milk |
| Specialty Ingredients | High-tech NZ processors with specialty capabilities | North American exporters to third-country markets |
| Consumer Market | Indian consumers (potentially lower prices) | Indian cooperatives with higher production costs |
| Dairy Technology | NZ equipment/system providers | Traditional dairy production systems |
| Dairy Genetics | NZ genetics companies | Traditional Indian cattle breeding programs |
5 QUESTIONS EVERY DAIRY PRODUCER SHOULD ASK
- How might this deal shift global dairy trade flows away from your current export markets?
- Will specialty ingredients face increased global competition if New Zealand refocuses its export strategy?
- Could this agreement set a precedent for other protected markets to open dairy access?
- How might shifting trade patterns affect your farm-gate milk prices over the next 12-24 months?
- What product mix adjustments should you consider if global markets realign?
THE PATH FORWARD: Three Potential Outcomes
- Complete Agreement With Dairy Access: New Zealand secures significant reductions in India’s dairy tariffs, creating immediate market access for its exporters. This scenario would represent a historic shift in India’s protectionist stance and potentially trigger restructuring across its domestic dairy sector.
- Partial Agreement With Dairy Carve-Outs: The more likely outcome involves selective cooperation—perhaps joint ventures, technology transfer, or limited access for specific dairy product categories while maintaining protection for fluid milk and essential dairy commodities that form the backbone of India’s small-farm economy.
- Another Failure Over Dairy: History repeats itself, with dairy access again proving to be the dealbreaker. Despite the high-level political commitment, fundamental differences in dairy market structure and development priorities prevent agreement.
Kimberley Crewther, Executive Director of the Dairy Companies Association of New Zealand (DCANZ), insists that excluding dairy would be a “lost opportunity” to look for win-win opportunities where New Zealand could complement Indian local dairy supply, such as through specialist dairy ingredients.
“Let’s drive this relationship forward, and I look forward to signing that agreement with Prime Minister Modi in 60 days.” — Christopher Luxon to Indian business leaders.
CONCLUSION: Watching the Clock
The dairy world now enters a critical 60-day window that could reshape global trade patterns for decades. As Luxon boldly stated, both countries have “massive aspirations” and are positioned “to actually do exceptionally well for both of our countries in the years and the decades ahead.”
For The Bullvine readers, the message is clear: stay vigilant. These negotiations may be happening half a world away. Still, their outcome will likely impact your bottom line through altered global dairy trade flows, shifting price dynamics, and new competitive pressures.
Consider consulting with your industry organizations about contingency planning for potential market shifts. Producers who start strategizing now about potential product mix adjustments or exploring new market opportunities will be better positioned regardless of the outcome.
The Bullvine will continue tracking this developing story as the 60-day clock ticks down toward what could be the most consequential dairy trade agreement of the decade.
Will India’s sacred cows remain protected, or will New Zealand’s dairy giants finally secure their passage to India?
DISCLAIMER: This analysis represents the current state of a rapidly evolving trade negotiation. The Bullvine will provide continuous updates as new information becomes available. Trade positions and timelines may shift significantly as talks progress.
Learn more
- Trump’s “America First” Trade Policy: How Reciprocal Tariffs Will Reshape Global Dairy Markets
- David vs. Goliath: How Family Farms Can Survive When Competing Against Corporate Dairy Giants
- Fonterra’s Global Chess Game: Inside the Export Strategy Targeting 5 Billion New Consumers
Join the Revolution!
Join the Revolution!Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Daily for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.
