2025’s genetic base change could cost your herd $147K! Learn how rigid bull thresholds accelerate inbreeding & slash profits. Act now!
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The 2025 genetic base reset demands urgent shifts in bull selection strategies. Producers maintaining rigid milk thresholds risk 7,000 in losses over five years (500-cow herd) while accelerating inbreeding costs (/cow/year per 1% increase). Virginia Tech data shows adaptive strategies—like percentile-based Z-scores and custom indexes—boost profits by 37% and reduce sire-related inbreeding by 29%. With the CDCB’s updated Net Merit Index prioritizing butterfat (+11%) and feed efficiency (+79%), the article provides actionable steps to future-proof herds, including genetic diversity audits and dynamic threshold tools. Ignoring these changes risks misalignment with market shifts and unsustainable genetic bottlenecks.
KEY TAKEAWAYS:
- $147K Loss Risk: Fixed thresholds waste $147K/500 cows over 5 years vs. adaptive strategies.
- Inbreeding Tax: Every 1% inbreeding increase costs $23/cow/year (Virginia Tech, 2024).
- Z-Scores > Raw PTAs: Calculate breed-specific Z-scores to auto-adjust for genetic progress.
- Custom Indexes Win: Herds using balanced indexes gain +37% profit/cow (Pennsylvania case study).
- Audit Genetics Now: CDCB tools identify high-risk sires (>8% relatedness) pre-2025 reset.
The 2025 genetic update isn’t just a routine change—it’s a big warning about money. If you keep using old rules for picking bulls, you might lose $147,000 over five years for a 500-cow herd. Let’s see why this matters and how to avoid it.
What’s Changing in 2025?
Every five years, the dairy industry updates how it measures cattle genetics. In 2025, these “genetic scores” will drop for all breeds:
| Trait | Holstein | Jersey | Ayrshire |
| Milk Yield | -750 lbs | -380 lbs | -550 lbs |
| Fat Yield | -45 lbs | -20 lbs | -28 lbs |
| Protein Yield | -30 lbs | -15 lbs | -18 lbs |
| Productive Life | -1.8 months | -1.2 months | -1.5 months |
Source: CDCB, USDA ARS
Example: A Holstein bull scoring 1,750 lbs of milk before 2025 will show 1,000 lbs after. This doesn’t mean he’s worse—it’s just a new yardstick.
“This update shows how much better cows have gotten. Ignoring it is like farming with a broken compass.”
Murray Hunt, Bullvine’s genetics expert
The $64,000 Mistake
A Wisconsin dairy farmer learned this the hard way. He rejected a bull because it missed his milk target by 2 lbs. Later, he found out:
- That bull’s cows produced +65 lbs more fat (worth $214 per cow)
- His herd lost $64,000 yearly
Why? Rigid rules (like “only pick bulls with 1,000+ lbs milk”) exclude good bulls that excel in other areas (fat, fertility, feed use).
The Hidden Cost: Relatedness
Too many cows in your herd being “cousins” hurts profits. Each 1% increase in relatedness costs $23 per cow yearly.
| Relatedness | Cost for 500 Cows |
| 8% (old rules) | $92,000/year |
| 6% (new rules) | $69,000/year |
Over five years, that’s a $115,000 difference.
Three Simple Fixes
1. Don’t Obsess Over Milk
The new “Net Merit” core values:
- Butterfat (+11% importance | $3.80/lb profit)
- Feed efficiency (+79% importance | saves $0.14/cow/day)
Try using “genetic rankings” (top 10%) instead of fixed numbers.
2. Create a Custom Score
A Pennsylvania farm used a 60% fat / 20% fertility score and saved:
- 37% more profit per cow
- 29% less money on semen
3. Check for “Problem Genes”
Tools like CDCB’s calculator help avoid:
- Bulls are too closely related
- Cows with genes that hurt fertility or health
Breeding Checklist
✅ Do This Now
- Update your bull list using CDCB’s new 2025 scores.
- Pick the top 10% for fat/fertility instead of fixed milk targets.
- Split your focus: 40% milk, 30% health, 20% feed use, 10% cow type.
The Bottom Line
Old rules are like using a map from 2015 to 2025. If you adapt, you’ll:
- Avoid $147,000 losses
- Keep cows healthier (less relatedness = fewer sick cows)
- Profit from butterfat premiums
“The bulls you skip today decide your herd’s future.”
Murray Hunt, Bullvine Genetics Expert
This isn’t rocket science. It’s about using better tools to protect your herd and profits. The choice is yours.
Learn more:
- “U.S. Dairy Genetic Evaluations Set for Historic Reset in April 2025”
Dive into the specifics of the 2025 genetic base change, including PTA adjustments and revised merit indices like NM$ and CM$. Learn how to recalibrate sire thresholds and align with market demands. - “The AI Secret Weapon Reshaping Dairy Genetics”
Explore how Biologically Annotated Neural Networks (BANNs) are revolutionizing genomic predictions, boosting accuracy by 5%+ in traits like mastitis resistance. Understand the risks and rewards of AI-driven breeding. - “A Comprehensive Guide to Enhanced Genetic Selection”
Master practical strategies for selecting bulls and dams, balancing production, health, and type traits. Learn how to prioritize traits aligned with your farm’s goals and avoid genetic pitfalls.
Join the Revolution!
Join the Revolution!Join over 30,000 successful dairy professionals who rely on Bullvine Daily for their competitive edge. Delivered directly to your inbox each week, our exclusive industry insights help you make smarter decisions while saving precious hours every week. Never miss critical updates on milk production trends, breakthrough technologies, and profit-boosting strategies that top producers are already implementing. Subscribe now to transform your dairy operation’s efficiency and profitability—your future success is just one click away.
