How an unassuming cow built a global dairy empire. Discover how Laurie Sheik’s genetics dominate barns worldwide—40 years later.
Do you know how people talk about game-changers in sports or tech visionaries who transform industries overnight? In the dairy cattle breeding world, we also have our legends. And honestly, they don’t come much more significant than Comestar Laurie Sheik.
Picture this: It’s a chilly autumn day in 1989, and the buzz at the first-ever Comestar Sale in Quebec is reaching a fever pitch. Nobody expected much from this modest-looking, more white-than-black cow from Victoriaville when she entered the ring. But when the gavel finally dropped? A staggering $45,000 price, with the Pussemier family from Belgium joining Comestar to take a gamble that would reshape Holstein breeding worldwide.
Talk about an underdog story! This unassuming cow would go on to rewrite the genetic playbook for the next four decades. And I’m not exaggerating when I say her influence is still being felt today in barns across 51 countries.
WHY ONE COW CHANGED EVERYTHING (AND WHY YOU SHOULD CARE)
Even if you’re not a Holstein fanatic (though if you’re reading The Bullvine, chances are you might be!), Laurie Sheik’s accomplishments will make anyone’s jaw drop:
- She produced FOUR millionaire bulls – Leader, Lee, Lheros, and Outside. Can you imagine having just ONE bull reach that status from your breeding program? She gave our industry FOUR.
- Her maternal line is ridiculous – 23 brood cow stars for Laurie Sheik herself, and her daughter Laura Black topped her with 24. That’s like having a Hall of Fame player whose kid becomes an even bigger star.
- She bookended Holstein Canada’s Cow of the Year award by winning the inaugural honor in 1995 and having her descendant Lamadona grab the same title in 2022. That’s 27 years of genetic dominance!
- Her genes are EVERYWHERE – 51 countries have her bloodlines, and at Bois Seigneur Holstein in Belgium, about 70% of their herd traces back to her. That’s not influence; that’s a takeover.
And get this – her descendants are still crushing it in both old-school tie-stall barns AND cutting-edge robotic milking systems. Talk about standing the test of time!
FROM FARM KID TO VISIONARY: THE MAN BEHIND THE LEGEND
I’ve always loved the human stories behind great breeding programs. Marc Comtois wasn’t some corporate genetic wizard with fancy degrees – he was a farm kid who loved cows so much he quit school at 15 to work with them. By 18, he’d already bought his farm in Princeville, Quebec.
Demonstrating his commitment to the industry, Marc became an official Holstein Canada member on February 14, 1977 – a Valentine’s Day dedication to dairy breeding. Just months later, on April 23, 1977, he married France Comtois, forging a personal and professional partnership that would shape Holstein history.
Starting with 44 grade animals, the newlyweds quickly transitioned to purebred Holsteins, setting the foundation for what would become a breeding program of global significance. This rapid progression – from farm purchase to industry membership to marriage – within just 14 months showcased Marc’s relentless drive. The couple’s shared vision would soon give birth to a genetic revolution.
The pivotal moment? When he spotted Elysa Anthony Lea EX-15* in 1985. Something about her caught his eye.
“I’ve always believed that exceptional cows build exceptional herds,” Comtois once said. “When I saw Elysa Anthony Lea, I recognized a cow that could be the foundation for something special. But even I couldn’t have predicted just how special her daughter would become.”
That daughter, born in December 1986, was Comestar Laurie Sheik ET VG-88-23*. And man, what a cow she turned out to be!
THE BREEDING DECISION THAT BROKE ALL THE RULES
You might think Laurie Sheik came from her time’s trendiest, most fashionable genetics. Nope. Not even close.
Her sire, Puget-Sound Sheik, wasn’t exactly a household name. Born in 1972 and classified VG-85, he brought valuable genetics through his Washington State bloodline sire, Provin Mtn Ivanhoe Jewel, but he wasn’t the “it bull” of his time.
While exceptional, her dam, Elysa Anthony Lea, EX-15*represented Marc’s independent thinking rather than following the crowd. He wasn’t breeding to what was hot; he was breeding what he believed would work.
And boy, did it work! This unconventional pairing created a genetic perfect storm that would redefine what was possible in Holstein breeding.
THE THREE SISTERS WHO MULTIPLIED THE MAGIC
Here’s where the story gets fascinating. Laurie Sheik had 18 Very Good daughters (impressive enough), but three in particular – all sired by Tomar Blackstar – became the genetic highways that spread her influence globally:
Laura Black VG-87-CAN 24* gave us Lee and Lheros – bulls that combined production punch with dairy strength that commercial farmers loved.
L Or Black VG-87-CAN 16* produced Outside, who completely transformed how we think about udders in modern Holsteins. Before Outside, we struggled with udders that couldn’t hold up through multiple lactations. His daughters changed that forever.
Lausan Black VG-87-CAN 23* gave us Stormatic, creating a line that uniquely excels in both genomic rankings AND show rings. My friend who judges major shows likes to say, “They look as good as they test, and they test as good as they look.” That’s rare!
A Quebec farmer friend who milks several Laura Black descendants put it best: “When you milk these cows, you can hear the milk hitting the bucket. They’re not just pretty cows—they’re profit machines.” I can’t argue with that!
THE BELGIAN BREAKTHROUGH THAT NOBODY SAW COMING
I’ve always been fascinated by the international side of this story. When the Pussemier family spotted Laurie Sheik’s potential at that 1989 sale, they faced a significant roadblock: Belgian regulations wouldn’t let them import live cattle from Canada.
So, what did they do? Got creative! They bought partial ownership of Laurie Sheik herself and imported her embryos instead. Talk about thinking outside the box!
The 1989 sale of Laurie Sheik to Belgium marked a groundbreaking moment in international genetics trade, achieved against significant logistical odds. At the time, no formal embryo export agreements existed between Canada and Belgium, forcing Marc and France Comtois to pioneer new bureaucratic pathways. Every document – health certificates, ownership transfers, and customs declarations – required painstaking manual processing without today’s digital tools. In an era before routine computer use, the couple relied on paper records, international phone calls, and the emerging technology of fax machines to coordinate this unprecedented transaction. Their success in navigating these analog-era hurdles not only secured Laurie Sheik’s Belgian partnership but laid the groundwork for modern global embryo trade protocols.
This workaround triggered what became known as “Blackstar Mania” at Bois Seigneur Holstein. They crossed Laurie Sheik with Tomar Blackstar and struck genetic gold. The resulting offspring included standouts like Blacklaure de Bois Seigneur, who produced over 100,000 kg of milk in her lifetime – showcasing this lineage’s remarkable productivity and longevity.
Jonas Pussemier, who now runs the operation his parents started, told me: “What we could never have anticipated was how completely this one genetic investment would reshape our entire breeding program. Today, about 70% of our herd traces back to Laurie Sheik. That single decision in 1989 determined the direction of our breeding program for generations.” (Read more: From Laurie Sheik to Robotic Milking: Bois Seigneur Holstein’s Journey of Innovation)
Isn’t it amazing how one smart purchase can completely transform a herd’s future?
GENERATIONAL EXCELLENCE: THE LAURIE SHEIK GENETIC PROGRESSION
The remarkable consistency of the Laurie Sheik lineage becomes clear when tracking key metrics across generations. While most families show regression toward breed average over time, this extraordinary maternal line has maintained—and often improved upon—elite performance across nearly four decades.
Maternal Line Classification Progression:
- Elysa Anthony Lea (Dam): EX-15*
- Laurie Sheik: VG-88-23*
- Blackstar Daughters: All three key daughters classified VG-87
- Modern descendant Lamadona: EX-94-2E 21*
Brood Cow Star Progression:
- Elysa Anthony Lea: 15* (Exceptional for her era)
- Laurie Sheik: 23* (Near-record achievement)
- Laura Black: 24* (Exceeded her dam’s remarkable total)
- Lausan Black: 23* (Matched her dam’s excellence)
- L Or Black: 16* (Still extraordinary by industry standards)
- Lamadona: 21* (Continuing the family tradition of elite status)
Genetic Impact Distribution: The influence expanded exponentially through each generation:
- First generation: Comestar herd improvement
- Second generation: National impact through Canadian genetics program
- Third generation: International reach through Semex to 51 countries
- Current generation: Global distribution plus concentration in specialized herds
This multi-generation excellence isn’t accidental. It represents the extraordinary genetic transmission capacity that makes the Laurie Sheik family the most influential maternal line in modern Holstein history. Notably, the * (brood cow star) designation applies exclusively to animals born in Canada – a testament to her domestic impact. If her global descendants were included, spanning the 51 countries where her genetics took root, Laurie Sheik’s legacy would shine even brighter. From Belgian barns to Brazilian pastures, her uncounted international daughters and granddaughters continue to amplify her unmatched influence.
Production Excellence Markers: While specific metrics evolved over generations, the family consistently ranked among the elite. This legacy continues with modern descendants at Bois Seigneur Holstein, where exceptional performers like Maxima de Bois Seigneur (Chief) EX-94 set a farm record of 80 kg milk in 24 hours at just 47 days in milk. Lamadona’s impressive production records (5-09 2x 365d 56,799 lbs milk, 4.9% fat, 3.7% protein) represent the continuation of this family’s excellence.
Adaptability Across Systems: Perhaps most impressive is how this family has maintained superiority through:
- The classification-focused 1980s
- The production index era of the 1990s
- The balanced LPI/TPI approach of the 2000s
- Today’s genomic evaluation systems
This multi-generation excellence isn’t accidental. It represents the extraordinary genetic transmission capacity that makes the Laurie Sheik family the most influential maternal line in modern Holstein history.
THE MILLION-DOLLAR CLUB: THE SONS THAT CHANGED EVERYTHING
Let’s talk money. Breeding great cows is rewarding, but it doesn’t hurt when they make you a fortune, too! Comestar did something unprecedented by producing FOUR millionaire bulls from the same cow family:
Comestar Leader – Laurie Sheik’s son brought solid production and components. Comestar Lee – Laura Black’s son who dominated Canadian LPI rankings. Comestar Lheros – another Laura Black son known for balance and longevity Comestar Outside – L Or Black’s famous son who revolutionized udder conformation.
I’ve visited herds worldwide where these bulls’ influence is still clearly visible generations later. Their genetic fingerprints are everywhere!
FROM 1995 TO 2022: A DYNASTY THAT WON’T QUIT
Do you want proof that Laurie Sheik’s genetics have staying power? Consider this incredible bookend to her story:
In 1995, Holstein Canada created its prestigious “Cow of the Year” award, and Laurie Sheik herself was the inaugural winner. Fast-forward to 2022 – 27 years later—and her descendant Comestar Lamadona Doorman EX-94-2E 21* won the same award.
Think about that. Laurie Sheik’s family has remained elite for nearly three decades in the rapidly evolving Holstein breeding industry, where genetic trends come faster than smartphone models.
Lamadona is a beast in her own right – EX-94 classification, 21 brood cow stars, and those impressive production records I mentioned earlier. Marc Comtois says she’s “well-known internationally for her numerous exploits at shows and for her milk production records.”
She’s also passing it on through sons, grandsons, and great-grandsons like LEMAGIC (Semex), LOYALL (Blondin Sires), LATAYO (Semex), and BARLOT (Semex).
The dynasty just won’t quit!
GENOMIC ERA BLUEPRINT: APPLYING LAURIE SHEIK PRINCIPLES IN TODAY’S BREEDING WORLD
You might wonder if breeding lessons from the 1980s still apply in our genomic selection era. They do – maybe now more than ever.
Laurie Sheik’s success offers a framework that works beautifully alongside modern genomic tools. Here’s how today’s breeders can apply her principles:
Look beyond the numbers for maternal strength. While genomic indexes give us incredible prediction power, they don’t tell the whole story of maternal potential. When evaluating potential brood cows, pay special attention to:
- Family consistency across generations: Like Laurie Sheik’s family, look for maternal lines showing stable transmission of key traits. The best genomic numbers mean little if they disappear in the next generation.
- Balanced trait profiles: Laurie Sheik wasn’t extreme in any trait – her power came from combining suitable components, functional type, and production longevity. In genomic selection, prioritize females with balanced profiles over single-trait wonders.
- Cross-system performance: The Laurie Sheik family thrived as evaluation systems evolved from classification to production indexes to genomics. Look for families that maintain excellence regardless of how they’re measured.
Practical application tip: Create a maternal scorecard that tracks genetic transmission strength across three generations of any potential foundation female. A prepotent maternal line will show consistency in trait expression regardless of what sires were used.
Bois Seigneur Holstein exemplifies this approach, masterfully blending traditional maternal evaluation with modern genomic tools. As noted in The Bullvine’s coverage, they’ve incorporated tried-and-true methods alongside advanced genetics while focusing on the Laurie Sheik lineage.
Their breeding decisions reflect this balance. While using genomic testing, they value good mothering more than high production numbers. Rather than focusing solely on genomic rankings, they select for traits and bloodlines proven to work rather than relying on a single bull. According to The Bullvine, Chief and Lambda are their plan’s top sires. Their breeding goals integrate milk production excellence and show competition success – precisely the kind of balanced approach that made the Laurie Sheik line so successful.
Remember: genomic indexes are potent tools, but they work best when paired with the time-tested maternal selection principles Laurie Sheik’s legacy demonstrates.
OLD GENETICS, NEW TECHNOLOGY: WHY LAURIE SHEIK STILL MATTERS
As dairy farming evolves through the technological revolution, Laurie Sheik’s descendants continue demonstrating remarkable adaptability. Bois Seigneur Holstein exemplifies this, as Jonas Pussemier has successfully integrated these genetics into a modern, progressive operation.
Comestar has embraced the future, transitioning to robotic milking in 2020 with 7 Delaval V300 robots. Laurie Sheik’s descendants are adapting beautifully to being milked by robots instead of human hands. A plus for Comestar will be that the robots will capture additional information that The Comtois Family can use to take the Laurie Sheik family to even greater heights.
What’s most impressive about these genetics is how they’ve maintained their excellence through dramatic changes in evaluation systems and management practices. This cow family has consistently remained at the forefront, from tie-stall barns to robotic milking, from classification to genomics.
FOUR BREEDING LESSONS THAT STILL APPLY TODAY
So, what can today’s breeders learn from the Laurie Sheik phenomenon? Here’s my take:
- Focus on females, not just fancy bulls – Marc Comtois built a dynasty by identifying exceptional brood cows rather than chasing the hottest sires. The maternal side matters – a lot.
- Sometimes, your best partners are oceans away—the Belgium connection supercharged Laurie Sheik’s impact. Don’t be afraid to look globally for collaboration.
- Breed for adaptability, not trends – Laurie Sheik’s family has thrived through multiple evaluation systems and management styles. That’s more valuable than being temporarily “hot” under one system.
- Genetic transmission is everything – Those 23 brood cow stars represent extraordinary prepotency. Look for animals that reliably pass their traits to the next generation, not just ones that look good themselves.
WHY I’M STILL FASCINATED BY THIS COW
When Laurie Sheik passed away on April 30, 2004, she left behind more than just an impressive résumé —she created a genetic legacy that continues to evolve and adapt two decades later.
What fascinates me most about her story is how it challenges our assumptions about what makes a breed-defining cow. She wasn’t the highest classifier or the top producer of her time. She didn’t dominate the show ring or top the genomic lists (which didn’t exist yet).
She consistently produced offspring that improved the breed in meaningful ways. Her legacy wasn’t about flash or hype but about fundamental quality that stood the test of time.
Laurie Sheik may offer the most valuable lesson in our industry’s relentless pursuit of the next big thing: true genetic excellence isn’t measured in the momentary spotlight but in generational impact.
Her story isn’t over. Not by a long shot! And that might be the most remarkable thing about the unassuming, more white-than-black cow from Victoriaville who changed Holstein’s breeding forever.
Key Takeaways:
- Maternal lines matter most: Laurie Sheik’s 23 brood stars and her daughters’ success prove prepotent cows outlast trendy sires.
- Adaptability = longevity: Her genetics excelled through classification (1980s), production indexes (1990s), and genomics (today).
- Global collaboration pays: Belgian embryo imports in 1989 spread her influence to 70% of Bois Seigneur Holstein’s herd.
- Balance beats extremes: Her descendants succeed in robotic milking systems and show rings by prioritizing balanced traits over single metrics.
- Legacy over trends: Four decades later, her family still claims top honors—a masterclass in breeding for generational impact.
Executive Summary:
This riveting deep dive traces how Marc Comtois’ 1986 breeding gamble on Comestar Laurie Sheik VG-88-23* reshaped Holstein genetics globally. From her record 23 brood stars to producing four millionaire bulls (Leader, Lee, Lheros, Outside), her lineage thrives in 51 countries. The article reveals how strategic partnerships with Belgian breeders and adaptability across eras—from classification systems to robotic milking—cement her as history’s most influential cow. Modern descendants like 2022 Cow of the Year Lamadona prove her genetics remain elite, offering breeders timeless lessons in maternal selection and genetic prepotency.